Interview of Danger (Sidekick II) CEO Hank Nothhaft 103
r-blo writes "Know that new T-Mobile Sidekick II that Paris Hilton and Derek Jeter have been totin' around town? Yeah, that one. Well, Engadget has an interview with Danger's (the company that makes the Sidekick) CEO, Hank Nothhaft, talking about all manner of things regarding the mobile-internet device, including its closed development environment. They even ask him what phone he'd buy if it wasn't a Sidekick II, gotta love that!"
I wonder if it does video.... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:3, Insightful)
You have better, more integrated and less fancy and shiny solutions available if you're looking for a mobile business solution (e.g. the Blackberries).
Paris Hilton probably won't win a Nobel prize and a lot of people tend to make fun of her but she does represent that glamerous, in-your-face party girl thing that their ta
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:1)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:2)
Not a troll, honest. I'd just like to know.
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:2)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:1)
Re:I wonder if it does video.... (Score:1)
Is Paris Hilton really the best spokesperson for ANY product? (Other than porn of course...)
Form factor (Score:5, Interesting)
OK (Score:2)
Re:Form factor (Score:3, Insightful)
I think that's just not going to happen anytime soon though (at least not without huge technological advances in terms of battery life or power consumption). What makes these things so desirable, aside from the cool factor, is that they're truly mobile devices. Mobile in the way that the 'mobile office' ads in the mid-90's promised.
Sure, my cell phone ha
Re:Form factor (Score:1)
Re:Form factor (Score:1)
Problem with All-in-one (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:2)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:5, Informative)
That's not the case with the hiptop. Danger has picked and chosen what features to have and what features are out of scope for the device. As many people request features such as bluetooth, mp3 players, javascript in the browser, video recording, etc., Danger has stuck to what works well for the device and kept out most of the stuff that wouldn't work out. The AIM client is the best portable AIM client I've ever used, and I can say the same thing about the e-mail client. For what it is, the web browser is great, and the PIM functionailty suits my needs perfectly. If you want something that also plays MP3s, get an iPod. If you want an awesome phone with MMS, look at Nokia. For what I use most, the hiptop delivers. I formally disagree with you when you say they all-in-one devices always end up doing everything horribly.
-Aaron
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:2)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:2)
Re:Problem with All-in-one (Score:1)
advertorial alert (Score:2, Interesting)
The submitter of this story, r-blo [slashdot.org], has never posted any messages, but has submitted two stories-- both of which were accepted. My guess is that the sidekick PR dept. bought this story placement from Slashdot and this account has been created for the supposed submission of the placed advertorial...
The other story r-blo submitted was probably paid for by Tivo's pr department.
Re:advertorial alert (Score:2)
you might be right (Score:5, Informative)
I looked a bit closer at r-blo's other submission that was accepted. It's the MS-vs-TIVO article on Engadget. The curious thing is that it's written by a Thomas Hawk [slashdot.org]. That name sounded familiar to me.... So I looked at his user record on Slashdot.
Turns out Thomas Hawk submitted two stories last Thursday. Both accepted. One is a review of the Windows Media Player and the other is the article that originally got me suspicious about Advertorial Content on Slashdot. It's the Mark Cuban fluff piece that looks like paid placement to boost Cuban's image as a tech guru. Thomas Hawk writes in his introduction to that slashdot posting--
Mark Cuban, owner of the Mavericks, HDNET, blogger extraordinaire and all around tech visionary really, really gets it.
And when I wrote this post questioning Mark Cuban's predictions [slashdot.org], it was modded down as 'flamebait'... oh, well. I guess slashdot has to pay the bills somehow.
Re:you might be right (Score:1, Flamebait)
So I'll do the math for you.
That said, perhaps you should take note of what Engadget is: a subscription free news source. Emphasis on the word free (beer). I don't really k
be straight with the community you're building (Score:4, Insightful)
Hey Ryan, the story here isn't my paranoia, it's your lack of full disclosure. For starters, you're hyping up your website with posts using a pseudonym that you do not use on said website [engadget.com]. The slashdot community typically frowns on such disingenuous self-promotions. Had you instead been open and said, "Hey slashdotters, here's an article I wrote on my website about XYZ" then it certainly wouldn't have come across as some sort of deception.
Is your site really a news source or a distributor of press releases? I know that sounds like a flame, but I don't mean it that way. I think your site is probably a lot of fun to produce. At the same time, when a site's content is so product-heavy, I get suspicious about the possibility of paid placement, etc. Especially when you gush about a product like this-- "Know that new T-Mobile Sidekick II that Paris Hilton and Derek Jeter have been totin' around town?" The only reason Paris Hilton would have any tech gadget is if she's paid to endorse it. By commenting on Paris Hilton owning a Sidekick II, you've taken on the role of a mouthpiece for the Danger PR department. Does your community really care what consumer products Paris Hilton owns? Actually, it would have been a hundred times more interesting had your contacts at Danger's PR department arranged for you to interview Paris about what she does with her Sidekick rather than the CEO.
If you want to call Engadget a news source, you need to brush up on your journalism ethics. Real journalists don't accept gifts or freebies of any kind from people / companies they might write about. For example, Roger Ebert [ojr.org] pays to see the movies he reviews. Quality journalists don't present advertisements as news. Does Engadget qualify?
Please check the Society of Professional Journalist's website [spj.org] on the issue:
Distinguish news from advertising and shun hybrids that blur the lines between the two.
Deny favored treatment to advertisers and special interests and resist their pressure to influence news coverage.
Be wary of sources offering information for favors or money; avoid bidding for news.
Re:be straight with the community you're building (Score:2)
Thank you for pointing it out.
Re:advertorial alert (Score:1)
Re:advertorial alert (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:advertorial alert (Score:2)
So?
Re:advertorial alert (Score:1)
Heh.
Re:advertorial alert (Score:1)
Re:advertorial alert (Score:1)
Although we shouldn't rule out your point, if we start judging the value of a user on how much time he/she has spent on slashdot, then this community will be driven by the "grandfa
What they needed to ask him about (Score:5, Insightful)
I bought a Sidekick back in April and have been vigilant about it's upkeep. Never dropped it, never sat anything down on it. One day, the action wheel just stops working - literally, I am sending an email and it just doesn't work anymore.
One of the things mentioned in this article is that the Sidekick crowd tends to be 30-ish, which means people are going to have active lifestyles where things can happen to a phone. What is the sense of investing in such a snazzy device if it is not going to keep up with you?
M
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:3, Informative)
Here's a Press Release [danger.com] about it.
-Aaron
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:1)
Good to see that you're still around, by the way. I remember you from the Hiptop boards. The hiptop Community was always one of the best parts of owning a Hiptop, and it's good to see that it's still going strong.
I stopped reading... (Score:2)
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:2)
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:2)
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:1)
The T (time) part of TDMA means that as you get far enough away from the tower your roundtrip times will exceed the time interval the tower expects to find your signal.
next
Re:What they needed to ask him about (Score:1)
First one... lasted the longest about 2 months... Backlight on the screen stopped working properly(every time I opened it, it would turn off)
Second one... Broke the day after I bought it(the scroll wheel button stopped responding).
Third one... Scroll wheel again.
Fourth one... The screen started inverting when I had it open, while inverted key entry wasn
The perfect all-in-one would be modular. (Score:3, Insightful)
This could different options for components/functionality and perhaps leave plenty of room for upgradability.
Just a thought..
Re:The perfect all-in-one would be modular. (Score:1)
Unlike the HandSpring Visor, you wouldn't have to juggle around modules, being able to use only one at
Segway hook?! (Score:1)
http://www.engadget.com/entry/6213312554476399/
Wow. Just...wow.
Re:Segway hook?! (Score:1)
http://www.engadget.com/entry/6213312554476399/ [engadget.com]
Before you think about buying this... (Score:5, Interesting)
Regards,
Steve
I'd like to be a fan of Danger, but... (Score:5, Informative)
You see, the manufacturers that Danger contracted to build the first sidekick sucked. They sucked bad. My first Sidekick's keyboard began to bail on me within months: a few keys became almost impossible to press and the E key stopped working entirely. Then the scroll wheel and Back button (yes, the BACK button) started to go out. So, I called up on the phone and spent a few days negotiating with T-Mobile's people to get a replacement. They were originally going to charge me $70 (gee, what a cheap price to replace a faulty product), but I convinced them to give me the replacement for free, since I wasn't the only person having problems.
So, anyway, fast forward a few weeks. I've got my replacement sidekick (by a new manufacturer), and all is well.
Not. The new one has dust inside the screen casing, and the Menu button has absolutely no resistance so it's possible to press it just by breathing on it.
I don't have any experience with the Color sidekick or the Sidekick 2, obviously, so I hope that the manufacturing problems have been solved. But manufacturing problems were just the beginning for me...
See, one of the major reasons I decided to get a Sidekick was for the devkit. I wanted to be able to write little apps to use on the phone, so I could carry some notes and info around with me. I also wanted to be able to keep my address book on the phone in sync with the one on my desktop. That's not too much to ask, right? You can do that with most J2ME phones nowadays.
Well, apparently it is too much to ask. Practically from the day the original Sidekick was released, Danger promised that there would be sync software so you could keep your phone's data in sync with your desktop. From the day I got my phone to the day I cancelled the service on my second one, Danger never released any sync software, and the only way to get your data off your phone was to use their flimsy, slow, buggy web interface, and manually copy-and-paste information from the textboxes on the webpage - one address book entry at a time.
And the devkit, of course. I signed the NDA, etc. Installed the dev tools, read the docs, messed around. Even wrote a small program just to get the hang of things.
Then I discovered that the API was horrible. Vague/incorrect documentation, slow performance, and an obscene lack of basic features. It was well below the standard set by J2ME 1.0 (and that's saying a lot, considering that J2ME 1.0 is one of the worst APIs I've ever had the misfortune of using). The dev tools were flimsy as well. For example, the Hiptop and its development tools would crash when fed PNGs that didn't match its exact format specifications. Apparently Danger has never heard of libpng, because you had to make sure to feed every PNG file you created through pngcrush with a specific set of options before Danger's software would even touch it.
Resources were also a pain. In J2ME, your app's resources are stored in a JAR file (basically a ZIP plus a manifest). You can store files of any type you wish in there, and easily load them up at runtime and read them. Not so with the Hiptop. All data, whether it be a string, an image, or an arbitrary block of bytes, had to have a unique integer identifier, and be compiled into a proprietary resource format by their horrible resource editor. Once it was compiled, you had to copy those identifier constants into your application somewhere, and use a switch statement or something to load up that data at runtime. Not only did this make hiptop development a pain, but it meant that it was extremely difficult to port J2ME applications to the Hiptop or develop an application for both platforms at once.
And of course, once you had your application written, the fun truly began. First you had to download a buggy, unsupported USB driver for
Preach on! (Score:1, Informative)
Re:I'd like to be a fan of Danger, but... (Score:3, Interesting)
First let's get rid of the plain old wrong assertions you make:
1) You can't save apps you made to the phone. Duh, type % loader save. Boom, things are saved over reboots. Been that way forever, guess you didn't dig very deep.
2) Resources. Oh what a crybaby, admitedly the drc system they use isn't the most streamline in the world, but if you can't handle defining a
Cracked or boycotted by slashdot ? (Score:3, Insightful)
Can customers upload their own ringtones?
No. There’s an effort by the industry to make people pay for the content on these devices.
Even though we’re 1 percent of T-Mobile’s installed base right now, we generate 10 percent of their data revenue.
What about allowing developers to create user-installable applications for the Sidekick?
Not user-installable. We’re a gatekeeper in that sense. they use our developer kit, they reach an agreement with us, and then through us they can have access to our user base.
Re:Cracked or boycotted by slashdot ? (Score:2)
Eventually, that will change, just like it always does with things like this. The first product to break out of the propriet
what a sidestep! (Score:1)
A: No. There's an effort by the industry to make people pay for the content on these devices.
It's not us! It's the "INDUSTRY"!
We would *love* for our customers to upload their own ringtones...but the "INDUSTRY" won't let us!
What bullshit!
Re:what a sidestep! (Score:3, Informative)
We would *love* for our customers to upload their own ringtones...but the "INDUSTRY" won't let us!
What bullshit!
It's not bullshit. Danger's hiptop in some markets allow for the creation and importing of your own ringtones. T-Mobile wanted this feature removed from the OS so they could charge people for ringtones. I agree, that it's "bullshit" in that sense, but don't blame Danger for it. This is T-Mobile milking the cow. What he means by "industry" is the phone service p
Re:Cracked or boycotted by slashdot ? (Score:2)
And how exactly are their developers supposed to make money?
Why would I want to write a program for the Sidekick, exactly, given that Danger could cut off my access to it, or decide to not give me access at all?
I'd love to kno
Fuck, I'm behind the times.. (Score:1)
Re:Fuck, I'm behind the times.. (Score:2, Funny)
Still a drug dealer sales model... (Score:4, Insightful)
Can customers upload their own ringtones?
No. There's an effort by the industry to make people pay for the content on these devices.
And people wonder why I just want a dumb cell phone and a separate handheld for *my* stuff that I can control.
Re:Terminal Monkey - Where does encryption begin? (Score:1)
My question is, where is the encrytion done?
Does the SideKick encrypt?
Or does it communicate with a server that does the encryption?
Terribly misleading if it is the latter! How would we know?
Re:Terminal Monkey (Score:1)
Re:Terminal Monkey (Score:1)
Derek and Paris? (Score:3, Insightful)
No, I don't. Paris Hilton is a basketcase attention whore who redefines the term "spoiled rich brat", and Derek Jeter is an asshole on and off the field; he beat the shit out of a Special Ed teacher moonlighting as a Fenway groundskeeper, and had some rather unsympathetic things to say about the Devil Rays when they chose to stay in Florida until their families were out of the path of the hurricane.
Furthermore, I'm not stupid enough to fall for celebrity endorsements, because I actually have a brain. This is also why I want a cell phone that doesn't have a camera. Just bluetooth, good signal, good address book, quality construction, and a simple, easy to use interface.
Before you mod me off-topic or flamebait, consider that the article was one giant piece of astroturf- as another poster noted, the story submitter has never made a single comment on slashdot.
Re:Derek and Paris? (Score:3)
Well, I don't know if he's an asshole, but I do know that Jeter wasn't anywhere near the brawl in the bullpen.
'jfb
Re:Derek and Paris? (Score:1, Insightful)
I'm no Yankees fan, not in the slightest, but to hear someone slander Derek Jeter just ain't right. The guy has heart. On and off the field.
This is from a born and raised Red Sox fan.
Sidekick is still kicking? (Score:2)
I bet Philippe Kahn is behind this
Ringing in the decline of civilization (Score:1)
Am I the only one who gets depressed thinking about all the money currently being spent on ring tones in the world? For crying out loud, $1.99 is what we should be paying for a top 40 CD, not a %
Re:Ringing in the decline of civilization (Score:2)
That's funny. I wouldn't even pay that much for a top 40 CD.
Boycott this thing! (Score:2, Funny)
Why?
Because that 'celebrity party' he talks about in the article took place at the Grove in Los Angeles, right next to my apartment building. This 'party' consisted of earth-shaking 'music' that kept my one- and two-year old children up till after 1:00 in the morning on a week night, listening to an amplified rapper yelling Mother-F**er again and again. This was audible a full city block away, with all of
Re:Boycott this thing! (Score:1)
It sounds like they managed to translate the essence of the Hiptop.com Forums [hiptop.com] into a real life experience...
no. no, i don't. (Score:2)
no, i don't. and why should i care what those douchebags are "totin' around town"?
The interview was Not Haf Bad... (Score:2)
(+1 Insulting someones time)
(-5 Poor job of the above)
10 questions to use email ? (Score:2)
You answer less than 10 questions to set up your email account
ok let's guess
1. incoming server
2. login
3. pass
(At this point, it should work)
4. email
(Now there's no reason not to send email)
5. name
6. delay between checks/alerts
7. dowload body ?
8. security protocol
I can't get to 10 or even 9. Ideas ?
umm shouldn't cingular also have the sidekick 2? (Score:1)