Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 


Forgot your password?
Close
typodupeerror
×
Businesses Robotics

Amazon Begins Using 'Sidewalk Robots' In Seattle Delivery Tests (fortune.com) 58

Posted by EditorDavid from the robo-shop dept.
An anonymous reader quotes Fortune: The future is now: Starting this week, Amazon is testing autonomous package delivery with adorable little robot vehicles in a northern Seattle suburb. Six of the Amazon Scouts, the company announced yesterday, are now delivering packages in Snohomish County in a trial run that complements its existing delivery options... The six-wheeled vehicles are fully electric and will move at "walking pace," for the time being only during daylight hours on weekdays while accompanied by Amazon employees for safety's sake.... [C]onsidering the drone delivery Prime Air program never got off the ground, Amazon Scout already seems like a more sensible solution to the last-mile problem: the time-intensive activity of getting packages from distribution centers to homes.

Wired points out some particular problems, though: "A delivery robot can't open gates without hands, and it can't climb steps to get right to your door. And if the robot requires the customer to enter a PIN to get the package out, how can the robot leave the package if you're not home?" And compared to the orderly structure of roads, sidewalks are pure chaos, with people, pets and objects sharing the space. Whether autonomous delivery vehicles are allowed to share the sidewalks varies by state and by city too; San Francisco has severely restricted them since 2017. Amazon's road test in Seattle may determine whether the delivery method finally arrives.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Amazon Begins Using 'Sidewalk Robots' In Seattle Delivery Tests More

Amazon Begins Using 'Sidewalk Robots' In Seattle Delivery Tests

Comments Filter:

  • Private Taking of a Public Good (Score:5, Interesting)

    by Sir Holo ( 531007 ) on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:07PM (#58026554)

    Using robots to deliver packages via sidewalks is a private taking of a public good (sidewalk). It is illegal.

    And for good reason. Just imagine the swarms of these things that could be in everyone's way –– these things that are motorized vehicles. Oh, most places, operating a motorized vehicle along a pedestrian right-of-way is illegal, too.

    Neither of these will be enforced, unless a large group of individuals sues and wins.

    • A human walking to their job is technically the same. The private business is using the public sidewalk to get their profit generating resources on site. Should this be outlawed also?
    • Humans have used sidewalks to deliver goods forever. Was that private taking of a public good also illegal? You might have a point regarding the legality of operating a motorized vehicle on sidewalks, but if people find robotic deliveries convenient and desire them, they'll have no problem making an exception for robotic delivery vehicles.

      • Humans have used sidewalks to deliver goods forever. Was that private taking of a public good also illegal?

        False dichotomy. The key term in my post was "robots," by which I meant "autonomous vehicles" using sidewalks. It is a different thing than a delivery person using the sidewalk.

        People put up with FedEx/UPS parking in red parking zones all over cities, or at least the cops do; they do not let them drive or park on the sidewalk, as the delivery trucks are vehicles.

        ..., but if people find robotic deliveries convenient and desire them, they'll have no problem making an exception for robotic delivery vehicles.

        Perhaps. There will be discussion. I was describing the situation as it stands today, not in some future year. In any case, the myriad ways p

        • vandalism? three strikes law

        • Re: (Score:2)

          by tlhIngan ( 30335 )

          People put up with FedEx/UPS parking in red parking zones all over cities, or at least the cops do; they do not let them drive or park on the sidewalk, as the delivery trucks are vehicles.

          Incorrect. Practical cops may choose to not ticket the vehicles, but delivery vehicles get ticketed on a regular basis. In general, because they're there for only a few minutes, it's not worth ticketing but if someone feels they are parked in a manner that is causing a danger to traffic or blocking the sidewalk causing ped

    • Using robots to deliver packages via sidewalks is a private taking of a public good (sidewalk). It is illegal.

      How did this nonsense get modded up? Are you going to tell me that UPS and FedEx delivery trucks are illegal too because they drive on public roads? I imagine freight air transport or even passenger transport is illegal, since the airways are a publicly-owned resource?

      Generally speaking, private companies can use public access. At worst, they made need a license to do so in the case of local ordinances.

      • Trucks often pay a significant fee for their use of highways. This is necessary because a truck causes over a thousand times more road damage than a car. So yeah, that particular example is not so great. They should definitely be paying much, much more than cars to use public roadways.

        • Trucks often pay a significant fee for their use of highways.

          Not unless it’s a tollway, they don’t.

          FedEx trucks don’t get pulled over as they cross state or local boundaries to pay fees. They might get pulled over for inspections, and there may be fines for not abiding by regulations, and there may be taxes on the sale or ownership of vehicles in different jurisdictions, but no one is paying a usage fee for public highways. That isn’t a thing anywhere in the US. Nor is it illegal for them to be using public resources, which is what the OP was

  • bad idea (Score:5, Funny)

    by PopeRatzo ( 965947 ) on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:14PM (#58026574) Journal

    Does Amazon not understand how much people are going to fuck with these sidewalk robots? First, they'll be covered with gang graffiti in about five minutes, or festooned with sex toys. Local bands will cover them with stickers. Then, it will become a viral prank to kidnap these things with a panel van and steal their stuff and "customize" them. They will be hacked and used in public robot fights. Eventually, they'll be turned out and used for prostitution.

       

    • After reading this, I'm even more in favor of this idea. Public fights between dildo covered, graffiti strewn delivery bots sounds more fun than Chuck E. Cheese's on weed.
  • These things are going to be smashed, kicked, set on fire, superglued, chewing gummed, cardboard boxed, tossed into dumpsters and all the rest. And even if they're unmolested they'll get stuck, get hit by vehicles, impede pedestrians, run through dogshit and generally be a nuisance. It won't be long before cities start taxing these things for using the sidewalk, and impounding them the way they do for scooters.

    Knowing Bezos he's probably micromanaged all this and even if it saves him cents, he'll still do

  • What if there aren't sidewalks? In Columbia MD and nearby Ellicott City, there are entire neighborhoods without any sidewalks at all. I'm not talking trailer parks. These are upscale neighborhoods where the homes are worth $600K and up. I think the developer, James Rouse, had a vision where everyone had a car [washingtonpost.com] and drove to the shopping mall [themallincolumbia.com] that was the "center" of the development. Trivia answer: actor Edward Norton is a grandson of James Rouse.

  • lets see (Score:3)

    by renegade600 ( 204461 ) on Saturday January 26, 2019 @04:13PM (#58026770)

    amazon is around a trillion dollar company. I will be walking down a street with one of those robots, maybe if it tripped me or run over my foot, I can get some of their cash...accidents happen :-)

  • "how can the robot leave the package if you're not home?"

    I hate having purchases left unprotected on the doorstep. There's a lot of theft of parcels from doorsteps. Since like most people I work during the day, I prefer to have my purchases sent directly to a local post office for pickup. Then I don't need to worry about security, and just stop by on my way home from work.

    I also prefer the post office over FedEx or UPS because if they do try to deliver to your house and you aren't there, they will leave a card directing you to the post office (that will be only a

    • I am sure you can track online your package until you see the "Out for Delivery"; then likely there is a way for you to physically go and pick-up (when the item is not in the van and back at their office).
      Also amazon has something called lockers (name?) where you can enter a code/PIN and get your item. If you are ready to do the driving, there must be many ways to get your package.

  • I can see why. They'd come back with their tires covered in human shit. Win/Win

  • then the robots ought to gently extend 30mm diameter rods from their bodies at intersections so as to help the elderly cross the street. Having delivery robots do automated vending to people having the app used at the Go stores has got to be part of the plan for their future.

Slashdot Top Deals

Keep up the good work! But please don't ask me to help.

Close