Boxee TV's Unlimited Cloud-based DVR Holds Users Hostage To Monthly Fees 174
An anonymous reader writes "Boxee has announced the game-changing Boxee TV, offering live streaming TV via two on-board tuners and an industry-first 'No Limit' DVR service that allows users to record as much TV content as they want, and access it from virtually anywhere. The problem is that the unit, which records directly to the cloud, does not allow recording to a local drive, meaning users are stuck with Boxee for as long as they want to access their stored content — potentially hundreds or thousands of hours – to the tune of $14.99 per month until Boxee ups the ante. CEPro.com suggests, 'I suspect Boxee is offering unlimited storage to make users especially beholden to them. The more content you have, the less likely you are to drop the service.'"
Do any of these work with cablecards or SDV? (Score:4, Insightful)
With the exception of Tivo, I've yet to see any of these new DVR's I keep hearing about lately even mention if they work with cablecards or switched digital video. If not, what the hell would I buy one for?!? My cableco and all of the satellite networks encrypt pretty much ALL their channels now (and my cableco uses SDV extensively too). WTF good does a DVR do me if all I can get on it are a handful of over-the-air channels?
And as far as connecting to online services, big fucking deal. My Xbox, TV, and even blu-ray player already do that. And even if this wasn't a standard feature on pretty much everything sold today (pretty sure it will be built into my next refrigerator too), I could buy a Roku box for $60 that will do that.
Can someone please tell me what market these things are aimed at (or if any of them beside Tivo *do* actually support cablecards and SDV)?
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
More than a decade ago, my ReplayTV had a IR transmitter to control my Dish TV box by faking remote control signals. I assume today's DVRs have something similar.
Re: (Score:2)
I suppose some boxes could still work similarly, but unless the box from your cable company has multiple outputs for each tuner, you'll be limited to recording a single program at a time.
Pay to rent more boxes (Score:4, Insightful)
unless the box from your cable company has multiple outputs for each tuner, you'll be limited to recording a single program at a time.
I think cable companies just want customers to pay to rent more boxes in order to record more simultaneous channels.
Re: (Score:2)
No. Cable companies want you to use a cable box, in particular, one that they provide so they can sell information about you. Like what channels you watch and when, what shows you record and if you watch them, and so on.
This stuff is WAY more valuable than Nielson info, because it's what you actually watch, not what you have written down/or logged on their separate device.
And if they can also get you to pay them for the privilege of tracking you [by forcing you to buy/rent the tracking device from them],
Re: (Score:2)
That was back before HD and encrypted HDMI. The cable box took the digital signal from the cable provider and it was converted to analog video in the. The TiVo/ReplayTV took the analog video and digitized it before storing on the hard drive. When watching it the DVR converted it back to analog video again. Not exactly the best approach for high fidelity viewing.
If you could control a new box today with an older DVR you might be able to do that, recording the analog output. ( provided it doesn't have cop
Re: (Score:2)
Yep. Sony VCRs had something called the "IR mouse" a long time ago.
Re: (Score:2)
hdhomerun
the pc cards
Re:Do any of these work with cablecards or SDV? (Score:4, Interesting)
Can someone please tell me what market these things are aimed at (or if any of them beside Tivo *do* actually support cablecards and SDV)?
Depending on the implementation it could allow to watch US TV from abroad as long as a US buddy is willing to help a bit...
Of course if I went out of my way to organize this so I could pay to watch US TV from Spain someone would still have the balls to call me a pirate. So preemptive fuck you.
Re: (Score:2)
My Verizon Fios encrypts nothing that I subscribe to.
Re: (Score:2)
Cablecard is currently an anti-feature (Score:4, Interesting)
It's all about framing. You say that, and I say "WTF good does cable/satellite TV do me, if I can't watch it on a DVR?"
I record OTA shows; that's about half my TV. The advertisers who pay to run ads during those shows, have some (though not all, I'll admit) of their ads seen. The advertisers who pay to run ads during shows that are only transmitted encrypted, are never seen because I watch all that stuff through ad-free torrents. (So if you have an ad to run, make sure you place your order with someone who can actually show your ad to people -- i.e. not cable or satellite channels.)
Cablecard is irrelevant, because no half-decent DVR will ever have the capacity to work with Cablecard. It's illegal and a contract violation to work with Cablecard while not sucking. Ergo, it's a negative bullet point on a DVR feature list, which tells everyone the DVR is crippled. Why would anyone say their product sucks?
If you are frustrated by the lack of tools that work with your cableco, there is an answer: cancel your subscription. Stop paying them. If they ever decide they want your money, they will step forward and promise a plaintext service. Then everyone (viewers, cablecos, advertisers) will win. For now, the time is not right, because you're still paying them. You lose, advertisers lose, and cableco wins.
Re: (Score:2)
It's illegal and a contract violation to work with Cablecard while not sucking.
And yet, strangely enough, Verizon, Comcast, etc have not sued TiVo into the ground.
So which cable company's payroll are you on?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
> It's illegal and a contract violation to work with Cablecard while not sucking.
Hands down, this wins my favorite line of the week award.
In your area (Score:2)
I use a Ceton InfiniTV 4 CableCARD tuner and SageTV (using SageDCT to control the tuner), and am able to record any program that's flagged Copy Freely, which in my area is all of the Extended Basic channels (which is all I want, anyways).
Not everybody lives in your area. I remember reading comments to previous Slashdot articles claiming that cable TV operators in some areas flag extended basic cable restrictively.
Recourse (Score:2)
Yeah, and it sucks to be them; their cable operator is screwing them over.
What recourse do people whom it sucks to be have against the cable operator who is screwing them over?
But the point was that CableCARD CAN and IS a useful feature, without it being "illegal" or a "contract violation".
I will grant that it can be and is a useful feature for people who can afford to move away from a cable operator who is screwing them over.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
So it actually pays attention to the flag? That's DRM.
Re:Do any of these work with cablecards or SDV? (Score:4, Informative)
No. ATSC only or Clear QAM, which as of this week is going away. the FCC is allowing Cable providers to encrypt everything to keep the scumbag customers from recording with unauthorized devices.
Re: (Score:2)
Out of the gate it's Clear QAM (which is going away) and OTA. However, this summer Comcast and Boxee filed a proposal with the FCC to deliver basic tier programming via E-DTA via a DLNA. I would have liked to see E-DTA looped into this.
Re: (Score:2)
Now that the FCC has approved the cable companies to encrypt the retransmitted over the air signals, I suspect you won't even be able to get that anymore very soon.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It still doesn't matter. The fact that you can "steal" cable is irrelevant. If they are OTA channels, then they should be available to anyone anyways as a matter of public interest.
Any argument that starts with 'but we have to prevent you from watching OTA channels off of our cable" is inherently bogus.
Re: (Score:2)
One of the things keeping me from cutting cable is DVR access. Right now, I have a DVR that I use to record a bunch of shows for my kids, my wife, and me. We all then watch these shows at our leisure. If I were cutting the cord, I could get my local stations over the air, but then I'd be back in the "need to watch it when it is on" boat. I know I could build a MythTV or similar box, but I really don't have hundreds of dollars to drop on this. This also makes TiVo with a lifetime subscription less entic
Re: (Score:2)
Surely this should work like most cloud storage (Score:1)
That is: They record everything, and your 'Record' action is basically a bookmark.
Surely the redundancy is pointless.
I suppose one issue might be - your local community cable channels.
Re: (Score:1)
Bet it doesn't upload anything (Score:5, Insightful)
Most people have dreadful upload rates anyway ; the asymmetric connections we receive are very much tailored for us to be consumers, not servers.
I'll lay dollars to donuts that it doesn't upload what you record - they just have a master server which records *everything* and your Boxee just sets a row in a database that tells it what you asked it to record. This way they can offer "unlimited" storage - they just retain a single copy of each program that users record, and look to see whether they should offer it to you based on what you "recorded".
No doubt they hope this gets around the legal limitations that have been cropping up recently with other parties offering store-and-forward services.
Re: (Score:2)
Most people have dreadful upload rates anyway
For reasonable usage you don't need to upload in real time, you can just save locally and upload as the bandwidth allows.
I'll lay dollars to donuts that it doesn't upload what you record - they just have a master server which records *everything*
Well, everything for all markets? If you record a TV show in New York, play it later and you see some West Coast network logo you are going to notice for sure...
Re: (Score:2)
Well, everything for all markets?
Well, ONE of everything that was requested ... at least. It is better than 100,000 versions of Walking Dead being stored on their servers.
Re: (Score:3)
Well, everything for all markets?
Well, ONE of everything that was requested ... at least. It is better than 100,000 versions of Walking Dead being stored on their servers.
There's no such thing. There's lots of local programming, and even if we were talking of nationwide stations and shows, the commercials are different for example. My guess is that messing with commercials in any way would instantly lawyers smell blood...
Re: (Score:2)
For reasonable usage you don't need to upload in real time, you can just save locally and upload as the bandwidth allows.
For OTA HDTV, I get about 6GB/hour average when recording. With two tuners (like this box has), it wouldn't be at all unusual to record 4 hours of TV per day, which would be 24GB.
To be able to upload that without falling behind, you'd need to have a 1GB/hour upload rate, which works out to a steady stream of around 2.8Mbps. Yes, it can be done (and easily with FiOS, for example), but you must have a good provider and no caps to make it work. I've completely ignored the use case of a family with cable TV
Re: (Score:2)
I imagine that using proper de-duplication schemes, the vast majority of the show [...] can be recorded once
What sort of de-duplication are you talking about? Each cable provider encodes the video at slightly different settings, making typical SHA-256 based de-duplication fail to recognize streams that are substantially the same yet not pixel-for-pixel identical.
Re: (Score:3)
Having a single master copy might be difficult do in part of the "redistribute" part of copyright. It's one thing if John Q. Public records a show in his private home for later watching. It's another for John Q. Public then makes copies of that recording to distribute to friends/family/etc.
Also, local affiliates get ad money for local businesses so I'm sure that there would be a lot of push back on this.
What the Boxee probably does is store the recording on a small drive (40GB maybe) and then uploads it a
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
or they could just say the heck with it; 15.99 a month will buy a 2TB drive in 7 months. Figure 5 more months will buy some redundancy and a profit margin and they just have to expect folks won't record more than 2TB a year on average. Using DVD format you get about 2G/hour, so that's 1000 hours. Using a better compressor you can probably double that, which makes about 5.5 hours per day. That's probably a safe average, at least for now.
of course if they can come up with anything in the way of viable dedup
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
What the Boxee probably does is store the recording on a small drive (40GB maybe) and then uploads it as bandwidth allows.
As I mentioned in another post, having any local hard drive would basically mean that you're better off buying a full-fledged DVR with a 3TB drive in it, and then using something like Slingbox to watch on the go.
This is because it costs about $40 right now for any spinning hard drive/flash memory that will give you enough storage for upload cache, while it only costs $150 for a 3TB drive, which makes the price difference less than 5 months of service. 3TB is over 450 hours of the highest bitrate HD availab
Re: (Score:2)
Well you would hope so, otherwise there servers will be full of X thousands of identical versions of a handful of popular shows.
Re: (Score:2)
Most people have dreadful upload rates anyway ; the asymmetric connections we receive are very much tailored for us to be consumers, not servers.
I'll lay dollars to donuts that it doesn't upload what you record - they just have a master server which records *everything* and your Boxee just sets a row in a database that tells it what you asked it to record. This way they can offer "unlimited" storage - they just retain a single copy of each program that users record, and look to see whether they should offer it to you based on what you "recorded".
No doubt they hope this gets around the legal limitations that have been cropping up recently with other parties offering store-and-forward services.
While that is definitely an efficient model, the paid advertisers to those programs might have something to say about it. Right now, if you DVR something, you still get commercials. If Boxee grabs the live feed without commercials that won't work, nor will it work if they grab a local feed that is different than your locale. Advertisers pay good money for those time slots, it is unlikely that they will simply let that go.
Re: (Score:2)
Upload speeds and caps and this dont work that wel (Score:2)
Upload speeds and caps and this dont work that well.
And this is a problem because... ? (Score:3, Insightful)
How is this different than any other cloud storage provider, with the exception that the DVR content remains "at Boxee" and can't be copied?
This is just like any other subscription service, IMO. Why does everything have to be some damned sinister all the time?
Re: (Score:2)
How is this different than any other cloud storage provider, with the exception that the DVR content remains "at Boxee" and can't be copied?
This is just like any other subscription service, IMO. Why does everything have to be some damned sinister all the time?
Because if the summary doesn't make it sound sinister, nobody will read the article.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
In fact this is the same as the cable/satellite/telephone company's PVR system. They all stop working if you cancel your subscription too, even though the shows are stored locally you still can't get at them without paying hte monthly fee.
On a side note, I work for a telco who looked in to network based PVR features, the end result was that it was determined that it was a legal nightmare that we didn't dare touch, so instead we put a PVR in each customer's house. Customer's get most of the same functionalit
The nice thing about TV shows (Score:1)
The nice thing about TV shows is the fact that broadcasters often repeat them often and are available in other formats such as DVD's or online streaming services, so even if you were to cancel your service to Boxee the information isn't gone, just might be a slight time inconvenience if one wanted to watch it. Or one could just use a TV provider provided DVR box which records the digital stream directly to the box instead of to the "cloud", it just isn't "unlimited" .
However from personal experience a 500GB
Re: (Score:2)
I have months of shows on my 1TB MythTV box. that is a mix of HD and SD content... Mostly HD lately. you can compress the crap out of Cable/Sattelite TV HD and not notice because it's already compressed to hell and back. Each episode of The daily Show in HD is only taking 250mb of space at 720p (it's broadcast in 720p, so any more resolution is a waste) and it looks as good as the live broadcast does.
If you dont go insane and record 90 shows a day, 1 TB holds a little over 2 months of programming.
Re: (Score:2)
nitpick... is it broadcast at 720p or 1080i? I know at the telco I work for we receive all the feeds from the providers at 1080i with the exception of sports channel feeds which arrive at 720p. people have their choice of which resolution they want to set their digital boxes to, but that doesn't change how the providers send the feed, only how it's displayed on their TV.
Re: (Score:2)
Depends on the broadcaster. PBS here is 1080i at full bandwidth. ABC here is 720p at 1/2 bandwidth as they also insert another 4 SD channels. CBS around here is also 720p but 3/4 bandwidth as they have only 1 SD channel added...
Everything on CableTV and dish is 720p. it's all compressed heavily as well. at Comcast we smashed every channel down to 1.8Mbps for HD and 890Kbps for SD.
Re: (Score:2)
wow... that is a heck of a lot of compression, we have HD down to about 6Mbps and SD at about 1.8Mbps (can't remember the exact numbers, I'm a field tech, I don't do the back end stuff) We send it all over ADSL, so a customer with 15meg service is allowed 1HD stream and 2SD streams at a time (plus internet) at about 35meg service we allow 3HD, 1SD (plus internet)
If what you're reporting is common to the industry it explains why we constantly win in picture quality surveys....
Re: (Score:2)
Comcast does heavy compression, dynamic as well, some streams are dynamically delayed to match up the peaks and valleys so audio sync will have issues at times. The ad insertion guys go utterly insane because the commercial starts are random within a 3 second period. It is the only way to get all the services down the crap Coax that is in most cities. far cheaper to compress it to smudgy smears than to put in new cable.
Company Discovers... (Score:2, Funny)
The summary is incomplete (Score:5, Insightful)
It forgets to mention why I'm supposed to be outraged, or upset, or concerned, or... feel anything at all about this.
Ok, so Boxee deletes your recording if you stop paying. So what? Who cares? Don't sign up if that bothers you.
Re:The summary is incomplete (Score:5, Funny)
It forgets to mention why I'm supposed to be outraged, or upset, or concerned, or... feel anything at all about this.
Didn't you get the memo? Unless otherwise stated those are the default reactions to be assumed for any Slashdot story, along with "confused" and "horny."
Re: (Score:3)
Which, btw, has led to some very odd fetishes. To this day, I can't get off unless my wife reads SCO v. IBM legal briefs to me...
Re: (Score:2)
Or just wait til it gets hacked/jailbroken/modded to record locally.
Re: (Score:2)
I don't have a method to get recorded shows off of the HD Dish DVR in my living room, other than to play them out and record them (likely in standard def). It encrypts the files it records, I don't have a capture card that can capture raw HD, and since it's rented I would have to give it back if I quit the service.
Boxee is simply removing the box from my house and taking internet bandwidth in exchange for more tuners. Nothing radical from a security standpoint.
Re: (Score:2)
It forgets to mention why I'm supposed to be outraged, or upset, or concerned, or... feel anything at all about this.
Because this is the defacto power that all services hold over subscribers who store their data on servers they don't control. That this particular cloud service doesn't amount to anything particularly valuable isn't the point. The point is that the same thing will, and does, happen with all services that have exclusive control over someone else's data.
I've seen some really short-sighted responses to the tune of, "just store a copy of your data on the cloud, and keep a copy on your own server." That would
Outraged?? (Score:2)
You nailed it.
For crying out loud, it's TV shows.
What kind of pinhead is paying someone to store TV shows.
(It was a rhetorical question.)
Re: (Score:2)
Brilliant strategy (Score:2)
The strategy is brilliant as a way to lock people into your service for the long run. Especially when you consider that with de-dupe they are really only putting pointers to a given file in a database with your account. Like or not, this is the cloud doing what the cloud does best and is the way of the future.
Re: (Score:2)
Redirect the data? (Score:3, Interesting)
If the device has to go through your own network, can't you just redirect the upload address to one of your own choosing?
No draconian 1% cuts in the cloud! (Score:1)
> I suspect Boxee is offering unlimited storage to make users
> especially beholden to them. The more content you have, the
> less likely you are to drop the service.
Well, it works for governmemt, why shouldn't business adopt that business model? [instantrimshot.com]
Dumb headline (Score:3)
Amazon Cloud - Unlimited MP3 storage??? NOT! (Score:5, Interesting)
OK,
About a year and a half ago, I received an offer to store unlimited numbers of MP3s on Amazon Cloud services. I was under the understanding that this would be good for the duration of my account, a perk of being an early adopter of Amazon Cloud Player.
Then last month, I got a nasty email saying that my "trial" was over, that I was 20 GB over the new limit (200 "songs") and that I would have to pay every month for the service to keep the songs.
That's why no one should sign up w/ Boxee assuming their unlimited offer will always be there. One day they're going to wake up and either suffer more money or lose content.
itunes/play is cheaper (Score:2)
buy the show, watch it as many times as you want, download it to mobile devices, no need to worry about data usage if you're not on unlimited data
Fits a niche, would work for me (Score:1)
CableCo charges included? (Score:1)
Same model, different player... (Score:2)
Boxee is just doing what Amazon does now with their Prime service. Prime offers you access to watch tons of TV and movies at no additional cost (beyond the cost of the Prime membership). You can queue up shows and watch them at your leisure. But if you cancel Prime...poof...there goes all your TV shows and movies in the queue. So you can only watch it for as long as your membership is active. Boxee is doing exactly the same thing.
Cloud services are for people that are dumb and/or too lazy to figure out how
Re: (Score:2)
I pay for a music streaming service even though I could download or rip almost everything I want to listen to. Why? Because it is too damn convenient. I have no desire to mess with poor quality torrents or organizing my own music collection anymore. Hell, I used to spend more than $10 a month just buying CDs. And some of those I would get tired of pretty quickly. If you have a decent programming job/salary, $10 a month is not all that much.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I know you're sarcastic, but I used to spend way more than 8 minutes a month tagging mp3s and renaming music files... That is hours of my time saved in exchange for that 8 minutes.
Re: (Score:2)
But why? (Score:2)
I-Opener (Score:2)
They are just trying to avoid a repeat of the I-Openerdebacle, I assume.
http://osiris.978.org/~brianr/mirrors/www.i-opener-linux.net/ [978.org]
If you don't like their terms, don't use or pay for their service
Users need protection (Score:2)
Spotty support (Score:2)
well except... (Score:2)
Wow! I mean...wow! (Score:2)
Holy shit! A company provides a service and expects you to pay for it!!! This is an outrage! I'm calling my Congressmen!!!
Obviously its a slow news day at Slashdot.
Telus 'Optik' TV... (Score:2)
'Cloud' == 'Holds customer data hostage' (Score:2)
So what's new here? When you keep our data on someone else's server and then pay them for access to it, guess what you're doing?
I'm sure what I am saying now is has been repeated dozens of times above, but damn... obvious is obvious. The public needs to hear more about this issue.
Great idea (Score:2)
How is this different then the set top box? (Score:2)
What a stupid idea (Score:2)
Yeah I take uploading video to the cloud over transfering them to my local hard drive any day of the week. I mean its so much faster, with less problems and I end up paying for it time and time again with a monthly service, who needs local storage, jeez!!
Re: (Score:1)
Yep, fuck boxee!
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
For some stupid reasons (I needed a streaming player now) i also bought one.
I am much happier with my new RaspberryPi media center in the other room controlled via HEC,
Since they're not good guys, they could at least open up the older boxee boxes for custom (read XBMC) firmwares.
tried a Pi, ended up with a XIOS (Score:2)
I played around with a Raspberry Pi running XBMC, but found it a bit laggy and the IR receiver dongle I had acted like a mouse rather than as arrow keys, making navigation painful.
Rather than buying a Pi, case, memory card, and new IR dongle, I ended up getting a Pivos XIOS DS. Running their pure XBMC firmware it works pretty well and is noticeably faster than the Pi.
Re:Fuck Boxee (Score:5, Interesting)
I was an enthusiastic user of Boxee in their early days and ran it on top of Ubuntu. But the basically gave the finger to the entire community. I also bought a Boxee Box as I thought it could be a cheap way to easily stream movies off my main XBMC box. It's not good for that, either. File scraping is a nightmare. They add nothing to XBMC and, as a matter of fact, take a lot of stuff out that makes XBMC terrific. For instance Boxee's file scraping isn't good for anything other than straight mainstream viewers. If you like anime then you're SOL. You can only use their scraper.
There is *nothing* out there even remotely close to the quality of regular XBMC. When they get their Android version perfected there is going to be a flood of cheap XBMC boxes base don Android that really will be high quality. Boxee is not the way to go.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Probably because the would be a legal nightmare, where simply offering storage to people recording their own shows is not regulated.
Three reasons for schedules (Score:3)
It's like a bad hack to adapt 20th century TV schedules into 21st century content distribution. Why not just get rid of the stupid schedules completely?
Three reasons:
Re: (Score:3)
Normal use of service base commerce.
You have unlimited storage. Storage isn't free, unlimited means you may be storing a lot of stuff. So after you stop paying what options do you have.
1. Download you stuff... If that is an option you are going to be paying a lot of money for what? Old TV Shows?
2. They will offer all there stuff for free. Sure as a customer is is a good deal, however that means there is an infrastructure for you to access your old stuff. Now to offset they will need to either advertise.
3.
Re: (Score:2)
Sure, but that's the kind of treatment you expect when the Murdoch family is involved.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Next time you should probably read the fine print when you sign up to a service.
Re: (Score:2)