Modular PC Handtop Review 94
captainJam writes "The Modular PC (MPC) is a device with a simple concept centering around one 'core' that can be used in a variety of 'shells'. While the use of any laptop, tablet or desktop is immediately limited by the design of its components, the MPC can expand on its functionality with the introduction of new shells to house the core which contains the CPU, GPU, etc. Handtops.com has a review of the device and touches on its strengths and weaknesses. Overall, it is a great concept and decently executed, but the price will be prohibitive for most."
Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:5, Insightful)
Portable storage is dirt cheap and convenient. So I'm not sure what I would gain. If it were difficult to move data between those types of devices I could really see the appeal. But it's not hard to do anymore. I'd rather just buy the full blown version of each component for quite a bit less (if you got the same processor, etc.).
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:1)
Maybe for company with some employees in the office, some on the road, this and that, they can buy a few shells and share among staff?
So the sales guy with his core will take a PDA shell out, and when he's back to the office, he can plug his core into a desktop shell and work immediately without the need to sync data, especially if it is sync'ing into somebody else's desktop.
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:3, Insightful)
A laptop with a docking station covers 90% of what this would do without all that cost. In fact you can get a more powerful laptop for less than the core alone.
The idea seems to have grown from a need that just doesn't exist any
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:2)
What would really be nice (Score:2)
Re:What would really be nice (Score:2)
I don't move around so much anymore, but if I did I would probably put it on my mp3 player now, which I always have with me and functions as a usb drive. The new iPod shuffle and its clones we'll be seeing is e
U3 alliance (Score:2)
http://news.softpedia.com/news/Smart-USB-7
Users were promised the capability of launching applications directly from the Flash drive, besides the storage feature. Drive-owners would be capable of transporting a full application while keeping access to all history, personal settings and contacts associated with that software solution.
Re:What would really be nice (Score:2)
You probably don't want to hear this, but you can do this with Linux. It's a little more complicated than just sticking the USB drive in (you have to mount it) but I carry my preferences and quite a few apps and files around on one and can use it with pretty much any Linux PC that has Gnome or KDE. If it's a Windows PC then I can just reboot it with a Knoppix disc.
What I'm looking for is one of the damn small Linux variants (bootable, less than 50Mb, fits on a business card size CD), and a way to run the X
Re:What would really be nice (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:2)
the price is to much currently and I'm not sure it has mass market appeal. But for the likes of me it would be a great idea. Especially if it had a mips or powerpc module.
Currently I have a noisy half rack of near identical machines except for the cpu
Smart idea, but need open spec (Score:2)
But this idea is brilliant, and will be a success - if they will open specyfication and set some kind of standard. If you could buy several different laptop modules (from subnotebook size to ruggadized toughbook-likes), handheld modules etc _and_ different core units from different vendors you will have almost endless upgrade options. That may be true only on on very compet
Re:Smart idea, but need open spec (Score:2)
1) no more vendor lock in.
2) everything is bigger since it has to be properly componentized (ever look at the insides of a laptop)?
3) more expensive no matter how you play it - if for no other reason than it's a support nightmare.
and yes, I am their target - I'm the early adopter gadget type. In the past I've owned two MD players, imported a Sony bluetooth memoryst
Re:Smart idea, but need open spec (Score:2)
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:2)
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:3, Interesting)
But think ahead, after a few years of R&D, the general idea is you get a nice little PDA that you dock and have a full-blown computer. You work in your home you have all your apps/files/etc, you get on the train and you have all the same apps/files/etc, and you get to w
Re:Not Just Prohibitive - Foolish (Score:2)
The latest iPAQs etc
Early adopters only, at this point (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Early adopters only, at this point (Score:2)
Let's be fair now... It's a 1Ghz Laptop powered by a now defunct Transmeta chip. So it's really not 1Ghz, it's not being made anymore, and it's still expensive as hell.
Re:Early adopters only, at this point (Score:2)
Smokey the Bear says... (Score:5, Funny)
Remember what Smokey the Bear says. Only you can prevent your Modular PC Handtop from starting a forest fire.
High Priced Because of Demand (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:High Priced Because of Demand (Score:2)
For the business traveller, well, having both a desktop and a laptop next to each other on the desk is really awesome
Re:High Priced Because of Demand (Score:2)
Three words: Sun Ray Station
As long as you can get access to the server (which can now be done
Re:High Priced Because of Demand (Score:1)
Mr Prezident? I'd like to be the firzt to welcome you to Zlazhdot, zir. Hope you get over your cold zoon.
New shell in the works (Score:4, Funny)
Re:New shell in the works (Score:2)
Now, excuse me, there's a guy offering me pudding pops for my laptop...
Multi! (Score:4, Funny)
Did I hear somebody say:
BEST. BIGGEST. MULTI-FUNCTION. REMOTE. EVER.
With that price, why even post? (Score:5, Insightful)
Better to accept an Ask Slashdot question such as "The MPC is an interesting idea with a stupid pricing scheme. How might one construct something like this on their own?"
Re:With that price, why even post? (Score:2)
Because it's 'news for nerds'?
If prohibitive price was the deciding factor, the iPod wouldn't have been covered on Slashdot until it became popular.
Experiencing the evolution of the paradigm shift (Score:2)
Very soon now computers will be so small and cheap the form factor of the CPU will be irrelevant; think sewn into clothing or even disposable. Combined with wireless broadband and increased battery life wearable computers are going to transform the industry. What sort of new uses will computers be put to when
Re:With that price, why even post? (Score:1)
Re:With that price, why even post? (Score:1)
Re:With that price, why even post? (Score:2)
Open Source Patent Giveaway !!!! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Open Source Patent Giveaway !!!! (Score:2)
Re:Open Source Patent Giveaway !!!! (Score:2)
It looks cool and all, but (Score:1, Redundant)
Why?
A cool stopgap measure maybe,,,,, (Score:1, Interesting)
The days of (consciously) lugging around your computer are numbered. But then I'm an incurable optimist ;-)
Re:A cool stopgap measure maybe,,,,, (Score:2)
The idea is kind of nice, though -- instead of having the whole computer in one huge solid chunk, you could seperate it into modules that could be distributed around the body. It would be more like carrying several iPods in seperate pockets, instead of a CharmIT or laptop in a bag.
Re:A cool stopgap measure maybe,,,,, (Score:2)
Besides, even with electr
Re:A cool stopgap measure maybe,,,,, (Score:2)
Re:Better idea for game consoles... (Score:4, Funny)
I'd like to be able to replace crap like the DVD player when it acts up, or allow developers to
throw in some cutting edge games without buying a whole new machine
I've heard of such a device. I think it's called a PC. Can't find any info on it, though. Anyone know anything about "PC's"?
Panda Computers all over again (Score:4, Interesting)
The custom connectors they developped alone were horribly expensive. And with the price of motherboards and peripherals constantly dropping, there was little point in replacing just the CPU of a machine.
Unless the prices come down dramatically, I see little incentive in adopting this technology.
OQO? (Score:4, Interesting)
Nothing to see here, move along.
Re:OQO? (Score:1)
Oh boy! (Score:2)
I don't get it (Score:1)
Something for the future? (Score:1)
Just wondering (Score:1)
Re:Just wondering (Score:2)
Re:Just wondering (Score:1)
What are they shooting for? (Score:4, Interesting)
At one end of the spectrum is the laptop, where you lug around darn near everything. You have to replicate some things, like printers and wall sockets, and often wind up replicating other things like a big monitor and comfortable keyboard, but for the most part it's an entirely integrated unit.
On the other end of the scale is the thumb drive. Nothing more than a highly portable storage device for all of those things you can't replicate. You can jack one of these babies into any full system that has an adequate set of tools and be on your way. It's small enough that you can attach it to your keychain and forget it exists.
This product seems to be somewhere in the limbo between those two. For any concept like this to work, you have to be fairly certain that you can find the components that you don't carry around with you wherever you go. With a laptop, this is easy because you need so little. Portable storage in the form of floppies and CD's have made the other end quite available.
As it stands, there doesn't exist adequate infrastructure to make this device useful. Oh, and did I mention that it's preposterously expensive for what it provides?
Silly idea (Score:1)
... a neat idea, but ... (Score:2)
I like the idea of shells, but I'm not sure how much I like the idea of having to use the same processor & memory in each shell. Why not keep the processor & memory in the shell, so that the processor is appropriate to what you're trying to do? If I'm walking around j
Performance (Score:4, Interesting)
Shell = Swiss Army Knife (Score:2)
This 'Shell' concept is like the Swiss Army Knife: in theory, it can do everything; in reality, it doesn't work well enough at any single task to replace cheaper, specialized instruments. The last time you cut a steak or used a toothpick, did you reach for your Swiss Army knife, or for your steak knife and your toothpick?
My cellphone does things my desktop couldn't do 10 years ago, and it's cheap enough that when it breaks, I don't bother repairing it; I just donate it to a charity. Laptops are getting th
Steps to the first mass mfg DIY laptop? (Score:1)
Great Idea, Horrible Price (Score:2)
This sounds like a decent idea. At least, I've long wanted something very similar to this. I carry an iPod with me everywhere, and I'd love to be able to plug a keyboard into it and use it to enter notes on the go.
Or better yet, I've always thought that the best setup would be an iPod with the UI of a Palm device (I call this a "PalmPod", when I occasionally rant about all the stuff I carry around). You could do basic stuff with just the PalmPod, but it would sync and be a decent-sized hard drive.
Too
RE: Modular PC Handtop Review (Score:1)
Very old idea of modular (Score:2)
Something like this machine, but when you plug it into a desktop docking station that station has additional RAM, a better video card, more processors and additional storage.
Runs hot and slow (Score:5, Informative)
Let me tell you that this thing ran *hot*. After working with it for a few minutes in the handheld, my hands became so sweaty that I worried it was going to slip out of them. Also, since it's sensitive to heat, it would throttle the CPU back to 300MHz, and Windows XP would slow to a crawl. I found that I could lock the CPU in a 1000MHz frequency, but then it just got even hotter.
The desktop docking station was no better. I tried playing a DivX movie in both modes, and the playback ran at about 1 frame per second. I would expect a 1000MHz CPU to do better. Obviously, this thing has other bottlenecks.
Even for regular productivity applications, like MS Word and friends (err, enemies, this *is*
In short, this thing is a great idea in concept, but failed to pan out in reality for me.
Modular (Score:2)
What I would like to see is small modules:
A cpu module, a ram module, a VPU module, an HD module.
Then you could connect them all together using some sort of standardtized connectors.
Want to have more memory? Just add another memory module.
Want more CPU power? Add or replace a CPU module.
Each module will include various general connectors:
Data with various bandwidths, power, some sort of cooling solut
Re:Modular (Score:2)
They should also be connected by a high-speed serial connection (firewire?) in order to reduce cable bulk. It's important that they should be able to
Great idea (Score:1)
The perfect concept, but backwards (Score:5, Insightful)
How about this:
And then - price the basic box at under $500. Make it the Soekris of portable and desktop computing.
Re:The perfect concept, but backwards (Score:1)
nice idea, bad execution... (Score:3, Interesting)
rather then having the base unit just being a dumb box it should be a pda on top of a HD. but when plugged into laptop or desktop config the config should bring with it more cpu ram and so on so that the "pda" turns into a storage device.
so if you need to take notes, break out the laptop and plug in the pda (maybe allow the laptop to fold into tablet form). just need to add a meeting? no need to bring out the entire laptop.
need some graphical or other horsepower, plug it into the desktop config and get to work.
maybe allow the laptop and desktop configs to work as thin clients (bootable over a network connection) if the pda isnt docked.
one should allso be able to dock more then one pda so that one can access files on all of them at the same time. therefor the dock should basicly be usb or firewire, maybe even wifi. i may be streching the term docking here tho...
the thing is, no part of the setup should be dead weight without any other part.
Good idea, poorly done... (Score:2)
Personally, I'd like to see customizable portable computers at the other extreme... Instead of one core where you can replace everything, I'd like to see a Laptop with almost everything, where you can replace the keyboard, mouse, etc. Establish standard dimentions for keybo
There is a purpose for this type of device... (Score:1)
alternatively,..mobilize your data (Score:1)
Seperated at Birth? (Score:2)
Lets see, an incredibly esoteric product from an esoteric company with little business experience?
They've got three things in common, it'll be four to four if their CEO pops up on the news in a coke bust.
Ultraportables (Score:2, Interesting)
Good Idea - Here is an alternative... (Score:1)