Verizon's Wireless Road Warriors 219
Joey Patterson writes "CNN has an article about how Verizon Wireless uses technicians who drive around the country in station wagons filled with wireless gear to look for holes in the company's cell phone network and analyze the service of its competitors. This program isn't cheap (the cars cost $270,000 and $15/mile to operate), but it definitely helps Verizon find out where they stand relative to their competitors."
The new campaign... (Score:1)
This what companies should do! (Score:1)
Hargun
Re:This what companies should do! (Score:1)
Microsoft has spent billions of dollars in research, and they have helped their customers. It's just that they don't care about all the open source fans. According to MS, we shouldn't know how an OS works or what source code is.
Re:This what companies should do! (Score:1)
I think that the problem is that the average Joe BagofDonuts doesn't want the same thing that all of us geeks want.
Re:This what companies should do! (Score:2)
Good (Score:2)
Ad campaign (Score:3, Funny)
pretty cool to know that those guys are out there.
Pretty much everywhere I've been in the US (and parts
of Canada, I've rarely lost signal. (Paid a lot of
roaming fees, but that's my fault for not having a
national plan, I guess)
then again, they need to get a few of them off the
road and into my office building, reception's awful
in there.
Re:Ad campaign (Score:1, Offtopic)
Re:Ad campaign (Score:1)
Re:Ad campaign (Score:2)
Doesn't have to (Score:2)
But my company cell phone was always fine in the same apartment. That phone is on Verizon.
Re:Doesn't have to (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Doesn't have to (Score:2)
AT&T uses 800MHz TDMA in most markets, 1900MHz GSM and TDMA in others. Verizon uses 800MHz CDMA in some markets.
To lose the signal, head West, young man... (Score:1, Insightful)
Can't get Cable modem, because there's no cable.
Can't get DSL -- too far from the phone company's POP.
Can't get better than 34.4 modem connection, because the lines are sooo old.
Can't get cell covereage, because there's no cell towers.
Can't get cell towers, because there's no customers.
Can't get customers, because there's no cell coverage.
Look at:
http://www1.sprintpcs.com/media/Assets/Maps/
and see just how much uncovered area there is out west.
Re:To lose the signal, head West, young man... (Score:1)
Re:To lose the signal, head West, young man... (Score:2)
Fixed link (Score:1)
http://www1.sprintpcs.com/media/Assets/Maps/usmap
Re:Ad campaign (Score:2)
I wish they'd ratchet down the power on the tower that's maybe 200-300 yards from my office. My phone's service is through AT&T Wireless, but the signal from Verizon's tower swamps it out so badly that when I went across the street for lunch one day (where the only thing between the tower and my phone was a window), my service was cut off completely and the display switched from "AT&T" to "ROAM." I called 611 when it did that and found that the tower that was interfering with my phone belongs to Verizon.
Verizon and roaming (Score:1)
Re:Verizon and roaming (Score:2)
Coverage is NOT the end-all for cell companies (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Coverage is NOT the end-all for cell companies (Score:5, Funny)
"Love you, bye bye"
"I love you too, c'ya later"
"You're still there. I love you"
"You hangup first, I love you more"
My VZW experience (Score:4, Insightful)
Basically, the coverage is excellent -- I've been covered from San Francisco to Rocky Point (Sonora) to Toronto to Boston. Basically the only time I lose coverage altogether is underground. I used to have analog-only in southwest Michigan, but a quick roaming-software upgrade fixed that; I think now they're piggybacking on sprint's network here, whereas they weren't before.
That said, Verizon leaves a TON to be desired in the customer service department. The reason I bought my phone is because I've truly been traveling across the country for the last year. Trying to change billing addresses is a HUGE hassle; Verizon was cobbled together from 3-4 disparate wireless companies across the country, and it still shows. You have to get a totally new account number when you move, and sometimes you get double-billed for up to a month.
That, and you're basically not allowed to move out of their "preferred market" areas. My new address was about 20 miles south of the Verizon market limits in SW Michigan, same area code and everything, and they were adamant about not allowing me to change my address to that "uncovered" location (note: digital service works just fine here). Long story short, I ended up using a friend's address and paying all my bills online; it's not perfect, but I'm getting along.
So, yeah. it doesn't surprise me that verizon has all these techs in trucks all over the country; their coverage shows it. Now if only they'd hire that clever IBM basketball team to integrate their billing across the nation.
Re:My VZW experience (Score:3, Informative)
And this didn't cost anything, just monitoring whether it could receive signals. I admit it doesn't give a full analysis of quality, drop rate, etc, but a lousy signal is better than no signal and that road (being the best road between Phoenix and Las Vegas) gets a lot of travel. I'm surprised cell service sucks so bad along it.
Speaking of Sprint PCS, I've always considered their "100% digital ads" to be something to be ashamed of, not brag about. If I can't get a digital signal, I'd much rather have an old-fashined A or B side analog network to fall back on....
Re:My VZW experience (Score:2)
Eventually, after some escalation with customer service and tech support, I got them to admit it was their tower; however, they refused to fix the problem. I refused to take the phone in to them as it works on all other cells around. Ultimately, I insisted that they cancel the service contract and refund a month of service, as well as my deposit. They caved in and mailed me a check (just a short three months later.) I'll never use Verizon again.
I sold the phone to another Verizon customer who still uses it today and never had a problem with it (different cell.)
Re:My VZW experience (Score:1)
Dont focus so much on the competitors! (Score:3, Insightful)
You'd think they would be able to do this from their home office - except for the part about testing each of their competitors signal at the same point. Do they really need to do that though? What they should be doing is comparing signal strengh to usage, and concentrate on making the high usage areas have a good signal, regardless of their competitors.
When I commuted across the Bay Bridge, there was a gap in the Sprint services on the bridge that lasted no more than 50 yards, but it would always drop your call. I'm sure that's one of the heaviest populated gaps in service in the country, yet it went uncovered for years.
Re:Dont focus so much on the competitors! (Score:1)
I understand this reasoning, but the most important reason for me to have a cellphone to begin with is for emergencies. And those tend to happen in lonely, deserted parts of the highway or dangerous parts of town. Neither of these may be high usage areas, but if they're green on the coverage map, I'll be mightily pissed if my phone doesn't work there after I break down. And I'll let them know afterward, if I live.
Re:X sucks anyhow (Score:1)
I'm not really understanding what you mean by that "be able to do this from their home office." The point is to make sure people on their network, using a phone from where people use the phones from: on the ground. How would they be able to make sure the signal strength is good enough from their office.
Maybe you are referring to when the network is overloaded, the article mentioned that, but even if they could tell that from their office, I'm pretty sure the point of their testing is primarily to make sure that their signal is good enough for people to make phone calls with acceptable quality (no cutting out for a few secs) and that the calls don't get dropped for no good reason.
I'm pretty sure they are working to make sure that high usage areas have good coverage, hence all the rush hour traffic the guy says he gets stuck in. I've never seen one of those cars drive up my side street here.
Re:Dont focus so much on the competitors! (Score:1)
That's like saying "Hey I can pull up the page using the loopback address 127.0.0.1, so I guess our clients can view the website now."
You're forgetting DNS, IP address assignment, routing issues, packet loss, ping times, and all the other issues that can affect web browsing.
Sometimes there's just no substitute for actually physically doing the test.
Re:Dont focus so much on the competitors! (Score:1)
Yes, they do need to do that... you're forgetting one of the most important concepts in competition (or war):
Know your enemy as well as you know yourself.
Re: Competitors will pick up the signal (Score:1)
(1). The customer isn't happy because they have to pay roaming charges in their supposed home area and
(2). Your carrier isn't happy because they have to pay their competitors for you using their service.
So it is definately beneficial for them to check on their competitors, because the wireless carrier wants to keep as much traffic as it can on it's home network, not on the competitors.
This is why it's not government. (Score:1)
To contrast, the competition in the cellphone market is forcing companies like Verizon to make sure that their service is good so that customers don't leave. The end result: more for the consumers at less cost.
I'm not saying capitalism fixes all problems. Certainly, it doesn't, especially the problem that many markets tend to move towards a monopolistic market, but it has some MAJOR advantages, and this is one of them.
Re:This is why it's not government. (Score:1)
A university isn't McDonalds, and you're not a customer. You're a student. While you might be catered to a little bit more in a private institution, unless you're quite rich, you won't be paying the entire cost of your education there, either.
For your tuition, you're entitled to be treated fairly, and to have the opportunity to get an education (you can get a degree without getting an education). You're not entitled to fawning "customer" treatment everywhere you go on campus. If private institutions are so much better, you're free to transfer.
Re:This is why it's not government. (Score:2)
Oh, wait... those companies would fight tooth and nail to keep those subsidies, in spite of the fact that they're no longer needed. The telcos have more than enough money to expand, yet we're still paying those fees.
Yeah, capitalism works well in this country.
Captialism still doesn't totally work... (Score:2)
If my time is worth $200/hr, I should be able to pay an extra $10/mo (for example) for sane, decent customer service. (e.g. that which Diner's Club provides: instant customer service phone call pickup and competant service, all for $80/yr)
Bottom line on cell phones: I'm switching to Verizon for the coverage and unlimited off-peak time, but I don't expect better customer service, due to the gov't regulated monopoly...
Verizon Wireless vs. SprintPCS (Score:1)
My friend let me borrow his Verizon Wireless phone and I was able to call the person back and get perfect reception.
Also, my friend's Verizon Wireless phone works in the elevators at work, where as my SprintPCS phone reception is gone the second the elevator doors shut.
I'll be switching to Verizon Wireless very soon.
Anyways, just my
Have a great day!
Re:Verizon Wireless vs. SprintPCS (Score:2)
Re:Verizon Wireless vs. SprintPCS (Score:2)
Of course, AT&T handling all the barracks telephone services may get them an advantage with the military allowing them to set up towers on the bases, and close them entirely to other providers...
High paying job (Score:1)
I thought it was just the one guy on a cell phone and a friend on the other end saying "Yup. Still hear ya'" Man, how I do get that gig?
Re:High paying job (Score:2)
Re:High paying job (Score:2)
For a fraction of the cost... (Score:1)
Re:For a fraction of the cost... (Score:2)
Some cell phones are supposed to have little gps receivers in them and all phones have signal metering. Seems pretty easy to program the phones to record the position and the signal strength just prior to losing the signal and then transmit that data when the signal is restored. Then they could analyze the performance of different phones over a large area. (Of course all this should be optional for the customer to opt out of)
I wonder if 2 million phones continually doing data aquisition would be as valuable as 1 $270K station wagon at $15/mile.
I always thought it would be funny if... (Score:4, Funny)
adam
Re:I always thought it would be funny if... (Score:3, Funny)
And one more thing they forgot to mention. (Score:1)
Re:And one more thing they forgot to mention. (Score:2)
A more interesting part of the article was this:
"Observes" 1 billion calls? How the hell do they do that? And what is "observing"? Is that like recording? OK, they're probably just recording the signal strength, but still. This is a paranoid's dream come true!Base station must know when a call is dropped (Score:1)
And, it wouldn't be that tough to figure out where: call enters a cell from another cell, there aren't many roads that allow that to happen. So they can figure the probabilities of calls being dropped on particular roads.
Alternatively, they could ask customers. Their service drives me crazy: there are spots on every one of the freeways I use where calls are ALWAYS dropped.
Dumbasses (Score:1)
There are similar holes in Mountain View of all places - near the old Sun Campus. I reported this one to them about 2.5 years ago. They've done a lot about it so far
Re:Dumbasses (Score:2, Informative)
Select "I have a question about Network/Coverage" as the subject
and "How do I report a network service or coverage issue?" as the question.
Re:Dumbasses (Score:1)
Standing. (Score:2)
Why, the same place they stand relative to their employees, of course. Right on the windpipe.
--saint
AT&T does it too (Score:4, Informative)
Re:AT&T does it too (Score:3, Insightful)
Hey Verizon! (Score:1)
something Bell Atlantic and Nynex never seemed able to do.
"Now you've had enough... bitch."
Re:Hey Verizon! (Score:2)
Multiple times Verizon Wireless has filed for an IPO, but so far has not done so.
As to spending your money on projects that turn a profit, broadband is considerably lower profits than Wireless.
Verizon Wireless has consistently been the highest profit margin business unit in Verizon Communications.
Re:Hey Verizon! (Score:1)
BTW, they don't offer me DSL yet either.
Commercials mislead the public about coverage (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Commercials mislead the public about coverage (Score:2)
nothing like firing up a 5 watt 2-meter rig and hitting the autopatch when the damn cell phones don't work, though. 73.
Re:Commercials mislead the public about coverage (Score:2, Insightful)
There is no replacement for people trained in first aid and proper supplies.
The last thing I would ever take into the backcountry with me is my cell phone. That is one of the reasons I go *to* the backcountry - to get away from all of that stuff.
I am also trying to figure out why you were backpacking with a ham radio, but I suppose that is just me.
Re:Commercials mislead the public about coverage (Score:2)
I do this. (Score:2)
Thankfully, I don't do it full time. I do do it several hours a week when troubleshooting.
It's pretty boring. But it does make for some impressive phonebills.
Our local paper had an article about the person in Minneapolis that does this for Verizon. She doesn't sound like she knows what she's talking about, but unless you're interpreting the data, basically anyone can do the driving.
http://www.startribune.com/stories/535/2260767.
Re:I do this. (Score:2)
Sounds like you have a cool part time job.
Next up... (Score:4, Funny)
"Enemy cell tower, 9 o'clock! He's transmitting!"
"Goose switch to active jamming!"
"But what about that other tower!?"
"Don't worry about the tower, you just keep those fighter off..." Um, Nevermind.
seriously? (Score:2)
3 Things. (Score:3, Interesting)
1. Every wireless company does this.
2. In britain, wireless companies have been sued by employees when the employee contracted a tumour, which doctors believed was caused by the large amounts of electromagnetic radiation that he was exposed to day in day out by useing a cell phone almost constantly to check signal.
3. This whole article is fairly redundant, and seems more like some kind of "yay for verizon, they do something everyone else does, but look, theres an article on slashdot about them, they must be something special. yay"
thankyou.
Can you hear me now? (Score:2)
The initial connection was a bit too quiet for them to hear each other, so after tweaking the volume setting on his end, the Verizon rep offhandedly said, "Can you hear me now?"
The whole room burst into laughter for a good 30 seconds.
Re:Can you hear me now? (Score:2)
Did the PCMCIS card have Linux support?
This is nothing new (Score:2, Informative)
They also use this data to help generate the coverage maps you see in shops
Verizon Internet. (Score:1, Redundant)
When I had DSL the service absolutely blew. 1000+ms pings everywhere and only 70k/s for 768/128.
I don't own a cell phone, none of that shit is important to me. They need to fix other problems first.
Re:Verizon Internet. (Score:2)
We put $8 billion into our network in the past two years," she said. "We want to know where we stand in every market."
Re:Verizon Internet. (Score:2)
Odd (Score:2)
reception in buildings (Score:1)
case 1: in car, need help
well, this case is rather trivial
case 2: you are at a meeting inside a building and need to call someone
the solution to that one is not quite as obvious. it is very inconvenient to have to walk outside in order to get good reception or attach a 6' antenna. perhaps if your whole BODY could act as one, (the phone connected to body) and some wires... just an idea
QED
Re:reception in buildings (Score:1)
QED.
aggggghhhh (Score:4, Funny)
or perhaps the maytag repairman can fix them, he has nothing to do anyway...
What's the point? (Score:1)
find out the service sucks. When I've called in
complaining that people call me and the calls go
to voicemail since they can't find my phone, they
say its because they don't have a tower close me
me (even though the phone is on, and says it has a signal). They said they planned to have towers added, but in over a year, nothings changed.
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
Of course, they want the best cell reception money can buy, but don't you dare irradiate my kids with your lousy towers!
Sheesh. Study the numbers. Each foot you move away from the transmitter, the RF output goes down _exponentially_.
Of course, these same NIMBY's are the ones who have _lots_ of time on their hands and go to the planning board meetings, so you don't get your cell coverage.
Blame them --- they're what stop the cellco's more than anything
--NBVB
Bizarrely good customer service (Score:1)
I'm on a $120/month plan with tax (for home/office/roaming, 900 minutes, nationwide). Perhaps I'm escalated into a better support category. But still.
The other day, I was off to Canada for a few days, and I called Verizon to see if I could get a Canada roaming plan. Not only did they have one ($10/month) but they would pro-rate it just for when I needed it and automatically turn it off. Zounds.
Something went wrong, though, and it was applied for just three days instead of two weeks. I called up, they found the record, apologized profusely, added another note to their system, and said there was no way I'd be charged anything extra.
Amazing. Weird. It's not the customer's fault. What a strange idea.
Re:Bizarrely good customer service (Score:2)
-- freelance journalist for Wired, New York Times, Seattle Times, and other earnest publications
Um, I think we've found out why you got good service :)
Dr Fish
Re:Bizarrely good customer service (Score:2)
If you want someone to fawn over your every word on the phone who don't give a shit and can't actually solve your problems, you can get that for $3.99 a min.
Excuse me... (Score:2, Informative)
Feel free to mod me down\flame me\whatever, but thats how it looks from here.
the cars cost $270,000 and... (Score:1)
..Which dwindles in comparison to my gas guzzling '72 Buick Riviera with the 455ci engine.
north lake tahoe (Score:1)
Re:north lake tahoe (Score:2)
They're spending BIG BUCKS...not (Score:3, Insightful)
They're spending a whopping 0.025% of their revenue (67.2 billion) or $0.52 per customer (31 million wireless customers) to see whether their customers are actually getting what are paying for.
Be still my heart!
(Say, I wonder how much they spent on the television advertising showing those technicians?)
Load of Crap! (Score:2)
Happily, AT&T gives me a much better signal - never a drop or a fade-out. So I dropped Verizon (after they dropped my calls dozens of times), and picked up AT&T.
Drive around the country all you want. But if you can't service one of your biggest metro areas well, then get out of the business.
Plus they changed their off peak from 8pm to 9pm. Who need their crap. AT&T rocks for me.
That big dead spot in Irvine, CA... (Score:2)
The South is still way underserved... (Score:2)
Re:The South is still way underserved... (Score:2)
Analog sucks... really! (Score:2)
AYBABT Verizon? (Score:3, Funny)
Customer: "What you say!!!"
Customer: "Main screen turn on!"
Sprint PCS guy "How are you gentlemen??"
eh, you know the story...
Naivette (Score:2)
Obviously the trucks don't test reception... (Score:2)
Re:$15/mile (Score:1)
I believe that's factoring in the cost of making constant calls using every other provider as well. Add gas, amoritized car repairs resulting from driving hundreds of miles a day, insurance costs, lodging or meals if they're doing an actual cross-country trip, training costs, etc... and you're getting up there.
And are you really going to have someone driving around a $275K piece of equipment and pay them minimum wage? Are you nuts?
Re:Sweatshop (Score:1)
on the phones doing tech support?
Re:Coverage is only one part (Score:3, Interesting)
Another reason why GSM phones work. Go to europe. Check it out.
You buy an open GSM phone.
You want a phone number, you go buy a new sim card.
You want more time? Easy.. buy a card, recharge the phone. reasonable rates.
Full services included. voicemail. data. etc. It's not crippled.
It's anonymous.
You want a new phone? Get a new phone, put your sim card in, away you go. All your stored numbers, your phone number, etcetera.
Sorry, shouldn't have bought a Nextel (Score:2)
Maybe you get crappy service and pay out your ass but as long as you can "Bleep" people and annoy everyone around you with obnoxious tones it's all good.
Tim
Re:Thank Goodness! (Score:2)