Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Portables Hardware Entertainment Games

NYT: The New Breed of Gaming Laptops Get Serious 312

securitas writes "The New York Times' Seth Schiesel writes about hardcore gamers and the growing trend toward high-performance gaming laptops. Traditional enterprise computer manufacturers like Dell and HP are entering the gaming markets dominated by VoodooPC and Alienware, with the specialty high-end PC makers going the other way and breaking into corporate markets. There are some accompanying graphics and quotes from hardcore gamers about the Alienware Area 51m, Dell Inspiron XPS, and VoodooPC Envy m:750."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

NYT: The New Breed of Gaming Laptops Get Serious

Comments Filter:
  • eMachines too... (Score:5, Informative)

    by kcb93x ( 562075 ) <kcbnac@MONETbnac.biz minus painter> on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:20PM (#8748422) Homepage
    I know some of you are going to roll your eyes and go 'eMachines? POS'

    However, let me tell you...my m6805 laptop is wonderful.

    AMD Athlon64 3000+ (1.8GHz)
    512DDR2700 (can upgrade to max of 2x1GB, one of which voids warranty, buried in case)
    60GB 4200RPM (Probably upgrade to faster HD soon, this is the only downside)
    ATI Radeon 9600 Mobile 64MB (9600 standard, same speeds, only 64MB)
    15.4" Widescreen
    DVD/CD-RW
    10/100 LAN
    802.11b/g

    This thing works just as well as my desktop almost, except for load times. That's got an Athlon 2800+ with 512MB and a 9600XT. Halo I just have to turn down like one more setting on the laptop.

    I'm honestly contemplating selling my desktop and upgrading my laptop more, it's that powerful.

    Plus, the warranty is great. Battery died two days ago (don't know why, totally failed) I called it in shortly after that, and they overnighted it for free to me. So 24 hour turnaround on battery replacement.
  • Recommend (Score:5, Informative)

    by Kushy ( 225928 ) <<kush> <at> <marakush.com>> on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:22PM (#8748446) Homepage
    When someone asks me for a good gaming machine, I suggest a custom rig... Put it together yourself and have many less problems then any thing you get from Dell...

    But for those that need me to come by and install a USB mouse for them I suggest, Alienware, hell yea it cost more... but worth every penny if you can't/won't/don't want to build your own rig...

  • by seanpecor ( 627534 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:25PM (#8748481)
    is a relabeled and marked up Asian notebook that is also available from http://www.pro-star.com and at a cheaper price. I own the ProStar 4774 and it's the second ProStar I've bought. They're extremely reliable. It's ten pounds of gaming goodness! Sean.
  • by micradigitalis ( 708492 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:25PM (#8748482)
    They are upgradeable-- "Upgradeable Video Modules" [alienware.com]
  • Re:I don't know... (Score:5, Informative)

    by kcb93x ( 562075 ) <kcbnac@MONETbnac.biz minus painter> on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:34PM (#8748580) Homepage
    High Latency? Nope...we play {Halo,Quake III,HL/Steam} at college, on 802.11b, with pings of 20-50, which is not noticible (except when the slow laptop hosts)

    Low Brightness? Not a problem, unless I'm outside with the sun in my face or on the screen.

    Low color quality? Good enough for me, I can't see the difference in my games versus a CRT, I've ditched the CRTs altogether, but then again, I'm not addicted to having 350,203,234,234^10 colors either. (Yes, I'm exaggerating)

    We seriously game on our laptops because they're mobile, powerful and capable. Sure, we have slightly longer load times, but mine (eMachines 6805) gets ~3 hours normally, 1-1 1/2 gaming. And that's with a Desktop Replacement designed laptop.
  • Re:heavy and thick (Score:3, Informative)

    by Txiasaeia ( 581598 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:37PM (#8748608)
    Two Words: IBM T-Series.

    Less than an inch thick, some come with 64MB VRam, most have battery life of 4 hours + (higher end with better batteries are 9 hr +).

  • by Nuclear Elephant ( 700938 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:46PM (#8748708) Homepage
    My Pentium-4M laptop runs at 2Ghz, an gives me about 2 1/2 hours of battery life.
  • by chosen_my_foot ( 677867 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @02:55PM (#8748812)
    My University requires engineering students to purchase a laptop. It is OK to have a desktop, but a laptop is required. The reasoning is the engineering labs are limited and have aging computers, so by requiring the students to have their own laptop, labs that don't have computers/have computers below requirements become available.

    It seems like a dirty cost-cutting measure, but there is one large advantage. My largest CS lab had 8 people in it. This meant the TA was able to provide individual assistance easily. My Microprocessors lab was a different story. To perform well you needed an oscilloscope. Scopes were limited, so the lab sections had about 25-30 students per section. I was often in the lab for 45 minutes before the TA could get around to checking my prelab so I could start on the lab itself. (Often the prelab involved a circuit you would tear apart during the lab, so working ahead was out of the question).

    Anyway, I haven't been able to play the newer games for a year or so now. I even have problems with older games like Quake III. Due to the financial strains of the university and the internships I'm doing, a new desktop is a luxury I cannot afford. I would have loved the choice of a performance laptop when I was looking for one.

    Plus, a laptop is sometimes more convenient. In the small kitchen of our dorm, four of my friends had a small LAN party at one table using their laptops and a switch. This would not have been possible with their desktops, as they would have had no room. Playing from the rooms was unacceptable; the network seemed designed to thwart gaming. So there are a few reasons people want to game from a laptop. Some people do not have the luxury of a desktop AND a laptop, and must use a laptop for both work and play.
  • Re:Monster laptop (Score:2, Informative)

    by SpoonDog_SVT ( 691767 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @03:06PM (#8748925)
    One of my HS Seniors just got one (two, actually, but one was a mistake) as an upcoming graduation/start of college present. He says it's a desktop replacement machine for him. I'm happy for the guy, but I wouldn't want to lug that beast around on a daily basis.
  • If you're really into LAN parties, lugging around a huge tower and a CRT is definitely a pain in the butt. Even when you're not lugging them around, those beasts eat up a lot of space and usually look ugly. (Let's face it- even if you don't agree, looks are an issue for PCs, especially if they're in your living room, especially if you happen to have a wife/girlfriend) But I still don't see the appeal of a laptop here. Why not compromise and buy a tiny Shuttle PC? They're cheap, easy to build, and you're sacrificing ZERO power/upgradability compared to "normal" desktops, unless you realllllly need more than three drive bays or have a poopload of PCI cards. 5.1 audio, acceptable video, USB2, and firewire are built right into the motherboard. And most models have an AGP slot for a "real" video card. And you could build one for a fraction of the cost of a "performance" laptop. $220 for a Shuttle w/ nforce2 chipset $70 for an Athlon2500 that you can easily run at 3200 speeds $80 for 512MB of 400mhz ram $200 for a Radeon9800pro $300 for a 15" lcd $80 for a hard disk $50 for an optical drive That's only $1000 for something that not even a $3000 laptop could beat, gaming-wise. And it still fits in a backpack. Of course, the system I just described isn't really that useful for taking notes in class. :P
  • by Druss.the.legend ( 701439 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @03:41PM (#8749237)
    Personalyl I have a 5680 Sager and its a brilliant machine - the cooling system and the UXGA screen are the two best things about the machine. While heavy 3d gaming my laptop never gets about 52Deg C
  • Re:LAN parties (Score:5, Informative)

    by Naffer ( 720686 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @03:56PM (#8749435) Journal
    Sigh... [100fps.com]
  • by Kyaphas ( 30519 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @04:01PM (#8749513)
    Student pilot here as well. The reason you're not supposed to use cell phones from the air (and this is from another pilot I met who works for Nextel and gets mighty upset when people say it doesn't matter) is that you hit too many cell towers when at altitude. On the ground, your range is greatly reduced by all the obstructions.
  • If you think Alienwares are the only company that does this, you're sadly mistaken.

    In fact, that alienware laptop wasn't Sager's. It was Clevo's. Clevo is the name of a laptop manufacturer, probably the biggest one there is. Dell, HP, Compaq, IBM*, Sager, Alienware, Voodoo, and others all buy from clevo, stick in ram, a hard drive, and a logo and then sell for profit. Sager's model was cheaper than AW's because it was not as well known

    Apple and IBM* are the only major companies who make their own laptops. Period.

    *Some thinkpads are made by IBM and some are made by Clevo. Depends on the model.
  • by KarmaOverDogma ( 681451 ) on Friday April 02, 2004 @04:46PM (#8750057) Homepage Journal
    The sager 8790
    http://pctorque.com/8790.php
    kicks the pants off of any Alienware notebook and costs several hundreds (if not a thousand) less.

    Though the gpu is not upgradeable, at least you have the option of not paying the Microsoft tax if you want to use one of the Linux Flavors.

So... did you ever wonder, do garbagemen take showers before they go to work?

Working...