Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Robotics Technology

Robot Lawnmowers Are Killing Hedgehogs (wired.com) 215

An anonymous reader shares a report: While Americans still wrangle their overgrown lawns by pushing or riding a lawnmower, many Europeans have handed off that responsibility to robots. These beefy, Roomba-like mowers loop their way around a yard, keeping grass trim and neat. To many of their users, the bots are endearing. Their owners give them names or cover them in decals of ladybugs or bumblebees. But the sentimentality only goes so far, because these blades-on-wheels have also been slicing up something other than grass: hedgehogs.

Erika Heller, a long-time hedgehog advocate with a Swiss nonprofit called Igelstation Winterthur, estimates that nearly half the hedgehogs brought to the group during the last couple years were injured by robot lawnmowers. These injuries include limb amputation, cut bellies, or even scalping. And that's not including the ones that have been killed outright. "The ones that have died we don't see, because they don't get brought here." In the United States, despite a wealth of children's toys and clothing featuring hedgehogs, the only live animals you're likely to see are in the zoo or, more controversially, kept as pets. But in Europe, wild hedgehogs are beloved. They're popular in European folklore; there's even a famous British poem about a hedgehog killed by a lawn mower.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Robot Lawnmowers Are Killing Hedgehogs

Comments Filter:
  • by FFOMelchior ( 979131 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:48PM (#57385046)
    before they move up to humans
    • Wow...I had no idea there were Roomba type robot lawnmowers on the market!?!?

      I've gotta look to see if this is available in the US...are they reliable and safe enough to use on your front lawn, so that you don't get sued by some kid getting hurt by one running into your yard, etc....

      I'll look into it, but man, unless these things are really GOOD....it seems a lawsuit magnet!!!

      It sure would be nice to quit paying the guy to cut my yard $30 every couple weeks....

      • by gnick ( 1211984 )

        I don't know what they cost, but my brother has one and loves it (here in the US). It plots out his big, rectangular yard and docks to charge when it's done. It's quiet enough that it runs every morning before anyone's awake.

        • What's the liability laws for something like that in the USA?

          • by ShanghaiBill ( 739463 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:44PM (#57385604)

            My neighbor has one, and they are slow, with small blades, and little power. The risk is way less than a human controlled powered lawn mower kicking up rocks or debris. I can't imagine it injuring anyone unless they purposely went up to it and stuck their toes into the blades, and that would be difficult since the blades are not exposed.

            The low power is not a problem: it can just take longer, since no human time is involved. It will periodically return to the docking station to recharge.

            I use a much better solution: I replaced my lawn with gravel, desert shrubs, and cacti. No grass to mow, and a 75% reduction in my water bill.

            • My neighbor has one, and they are slow, with small blades, and little power. The risk is way less than a human controlled powered lawn mower kicking up rocks or debris. I can't imagine it injuring anyone unless they purposely went up to it and stuck their toes into the blades, and that would be difficult since the blades are not exposed.

              Ok, that make sense.

              While I've heard of electric lawnmowers, I've never actually seen one for sale, much less one in use.

              When I heard lawnmower I immediately pictured a r

              • by mysidia ( 191772 )

                Nifty Idea, and I see it as the future, but unless you have the ideal yard type, wouldn't really be useful.

                I wonder how well it would work on a yard with terrain (bunch of sunken areas; some slanted areas; places with exposed roots of large trees; not flat) and MANY trees, bushes, and shrubs planted in the middle of the yard all over the place.... also, front yard, two side yards, and back yards, all of significant size with a bunch of garden beds, much larger than the yard you would find that

              • Well, this has been on sale for more than 10 years... I think most of the problems have been solved, maybe except theft.
            • I replaced my lawn with gravel

              "Hey you kids! Get off my gravel!

              No . . . that just doesn't sound right.

              desert shrubs, and cacti.

              "Did you say shrubberies?"

              "Yes, shrubberies are my trade. I am a shrubber. My name is ShanghaiBill the Shrubber. I arrange, design, and sell shrubberies."

              "Ni!"

            • by rtb61 ( 674572 )

              I allowed evolution to take over my lawn, only the strongest plants survive with out any artificial watering and every know and again I reduce excessive growth, depending upon rainfall, with an electric mower. I prefer the overgrown look, it's environmentally soothing. I keep hoping the galahs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org] will do a better job of eating the grass but they are not very even lawn trimmers.

          • What's the liability laws for something like that in the USA?

            I'm not your lawyer or your insurance agent, but the risk is probably low enough that it would be covered the same as any other way someone might get injured on your property. I think, if I remember correctly, that accidental injuries like that are covered by typical homeowner's insurance.

          • You're totally liable for any harm it does on your property, but after you get sued you can probably sue the manufacturer to try to get some of that back. Minus legal fees, of course.

            If your home insurance covers it, then they would deal with all that, but the lawsuits would still be in your name.

      • Here you go: https://www.amazon.com/Husqvar... [amazon.com]

        > would be nice to quit paying the guy to cut my yard $30

        In California our local government is paying us to remove outrlawns. Many people now have wildflowers and desert-type plants. Advantage: Very little maintenance required, saves water, saves fossil fuel, reduces pollution, saves $30/week

      • are they reliable and safe enough to use on your front lawn

        Never mind reliable and safe - it would get stolen from a US front yard before it could break down or hurt anyone. At most one of these could do a back yard hidden away from the street.

        • Never mind reliable and safe - it would get stolen from a US front yard before it could break down or hurt anyone. At most one of these could do a back yard hidden away from the street.

          You need to find a better place to live. A large percentage of places in the USA with yards large enough to mow are relatively safe to leave stuff out. I have a grill and a couple bikes I leave outside and have never had a problem. Many houses in my neighborhood have similar stuff left outside. I also would think that if I had a mower like this that I would likely give it a doggie door to use so it would only be out for a few hours a week at most.

        • by Malenx ( 1453851 )

          They're trying pretty hard to prevent that. The one I was considering purchasing had to be re-activated every 30 days or so otherwise it would stop working. Only the factory could reset it. If someone stole it they were essentially stealing a paper weight.

          • by mysidia ( 191772 )

            The potential crooks and the people they might try to sell the stolen unit off to don't know that though.
            Finally; If nothing else, there's probably some scrap value for the electronic components.

      • I've gotta look to see if this is available in the US...are they reliable and safe enough to use on your front lawn, so that you don't get sued by some kid getting hurt by one running into your yard, etc....

        Hmmm . . . that's why I might get one . . . I won't need to yell at the kids to get off my lawn anymore . . . the RoombaMower will keep them away . . . or make Soylent Green Mulch out of them.

        If I remember correctly, US law differentiates between "unsolicited" visitors and "solicited" visitors. If the mailman, a "solicited" visitor, trips and breaks his leg on your doorstep . . . he can sue you.

        If a neighborhood kid, an "unsolicited" visitor, tries to pick a fight with your lawnmower . . . he can't sue y

        • If I remember correctly, US law differentiates between "unsolicited" visitors and "solicited" visitors. If the mailman, a "solicited" visitor, trips and breaks his leg on your doorstep . . . he can sue you.

          If a neighborhood kid, an "unsolicited" visitor, tries to pick a fight with your lawnmower . . . he can't sue you.

          Is it a blanket law across the whole country- or does it vary by state and county. That's the kind of thing I wouldn't be surprised to learn is different depending on state. Kinda like, in most states you will get in trouble for shooting someone robbing your home but in Texas you can shoot anyone on your property as long as you offer them a three step headstart.

          • Kinda like, in most states you will get in trouble for shooting someone robbing your home but in Texas you can shoot anyone on your property as long as you offer them a three step headstart.

            That must only be most of the NE states...

            In the S and SE, if someone has broken into your house, you can blow that fucker away, pretty much no questions asked, as it should be.

            Hell, in New Orleans, I've heard of someone shooting a criminal in their house, and the person making it out the door to die in the front yard

        • by lgw ( 121541 )

          If I remember correctly, US law differentiates between "unsolicited" visitors and "solicited" visitors. If the mailman, a "solicited" visitor, trips and breaks his leg on your doorstep . . . he can sue you.

          I know someone who was successfully sued by a burgler who walked through a plate glass window and injured himself badly. There's no accounting for juries. Liability insurance is a must whether you rent or own.

        • If a neighborhood kid, an "unsolicited" visitor, tries to pick a fight with your lawnmower . . . he can't sue you.

          I don't believe that is true...

          I mean, if you have a swimming pool in your back yard, fenced in, locked, etc.....and some damned neighborhood kid climbs your fence, gets in and gets hurt or drowned...YOU are definitely in for a lawsuit you will likely use at the VERY least.....and might even have criminal charges thrown your way these days....

        • An autonomous lawn mower might be considered an attractive nuisance. Like a swimming pool, if you don't make access to it difficult, you leave yourself open to charges of negligence.
      • Honda sells one but it cuts at a max height of 2.5 inches I believe
    • Comment removed based on user account deletion
  • Hurting hedgehogs should be punished by triple execution: Lethal injection, firing squad, and hanging all simultaneously.

    • I'm disappointed there's no link to the "famous poem".

  • by alvinrod ( 889928 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:50PM (#57385080)
    Are robot lawnmowers actually the popular in Europe? Also, how many hedgehogs get run over by human operators, because to me it seems like robot lawnmowers should be relatively rare even if they are popular. Do hedgehogs not flee from a mower (or what is causing them to get hit) because it stands to reason that if they don't try to get out of the way that humans would probably run over them just as often.

    There has to be some basic piece of information that I'm missing here, because this story doesn't seem to make sense to me. I'm not familiar with hedgehogs at all, so maybe they're just stupid when it comes to lawnmowers in the same way that rabbits are when it comes to vehicles at night. Otherwise, this just seems overblown to me.
    • by dargaud ( 518470 )
      Hedgehog are slow and gentle. When I see one I play with them and kids and tell them about it. They're nice to have in the garden.

      So how hard would it be to add IR sensors on the lawn mower to avoid killing anything at body temperature ? Not hard I reckon.

      • So the lawnmower won't cut the lawn when it is 96-100 degrees? And that is assuming all animals have the same body temperature as humans.

      • This story actually upsets me. They are cute. Unfortunately, I didn't get to see one when I was in England last month and we stayed with friends who have a nice house and garden too.
        Which also reminds me, a robot mower might not be such a good option for the US: a lot of backyard properties in the US are much larger than your typical suburban English garden, one might need an army of robo-mowers.

        • This story actually upsets me. They are cute. Unfortunately, I didn't get to see one when I was in England last month and we stayed with friends who have a nice house and garden too.
          Which also reminds me, a robot mower might not be such a good option for the US: a lot of backyard properties in the US are much larger than your typical suburban English garden, one might need an army of robo-mowers.

          Indeed, the lawn I had growing up was considered enormous by all my friends in England. It would be considered small in the US.

    • by Vulch ( 221502 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:07PM (#57385254)

      Hedgehogs are nocturnal. Humans mowing lawns tend to do so in daylight so few problems, but I suspect people may set the robot mowers to run overnight when the hedgies are out and about foraging.

      • but I suspect people may set the robot mowers to run overnight when the hedgies are out and about foraging.

        No way. In Switzerland (where this non-profit is based), it is illegal to make noise between 22.00 and 06.00.
        You aren't even allowed to take out your trash to the recycling bin (glass is noisy when you throw it in the collector bin).
        Anyone programming their Robomow / Husqvarna to mow during night time is going to be in for a fine.

        Hedghog's problems come from three source :
        - Hedgehogs don't use (swiss-) watches. They are very frequently out also in the morning or early evening/late afternoon. (Which

  • Normally while mowing, I am usually more focused on going in a straight line to keep my lawn neat, unfortunately any animals that are not moving and are in the range of the blades may get hit. I am not heartless If I see them, Ill avoid it, but animals seemed to evolve to be hard to see in nature, will unfortunately be hit by mowing. Snakes, Bugs, Toads, Moles, Mice... If they don't get out of the way, they can get hit.

    • by gnick ( 1211984 )

      If they don't get out of the way, they can get hit.

      George Castanza's failed deal with the pigeons comes to mind.

  • by Comrade Ogilvy ( 1719488 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:53PM (#57385110)

    First the robots came for the hedgehogs, but I did not speak out because I was not a hedgehog.

  • This is a "thing"?
    Get a job and go talk to real humans....
  • When windmills were first brought to Ontario, there were a number of bird deaths but after a while these decreased to zero and now you'll see birds fly between the blades of windmills, playing with them. Deer that aren't around humans are easier targets for hunters. Shouldn't the same thing happen with hedgehogs and lawnmowers?

    It's a form of (un)natural selection, the hedgehogs's environment has changed and the ones that are more cautious and wary of the lawnmowers will become the ones that survive and mo

    • When a species has successfully evolved to remain unbuggered and hasn't been buggered at all, it takes quite a few generations to re-start the evolution process....

    • by Oswald McWeany ( 2428506 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:24PM (#57385426)

      When windmills were first brought to Ontario, there were a number of bird deaths but after a while these decreased to zero and now you'll see birds fly between the blades of windmills, playing with them. Deer that aren't around humans are easier targets for hunters. Shouldn't the same thing happen with hedgehogs and lawnmowers?

      It's a form of (un)natural selection, the hedgehogs's environment has changed and the ones that are more cautious and wary of the lawnmowers will become the ones that survive and move forwards.

      When hedgehogs perceive danger they roll up in a ball.

      If they evolved to run instead, they might become more vulnerable to predators such as foxes and badgers because they can get past the spines easier.

    • by dgatwood ( 11270 )

      Deer that aren't around humans are easier targets for hunters.

      By that, I assume you mean that deer that aren't around hunters are easier targets for hunters. Deer that get used to being around (non-hunter) humans would be trivial targets for hunters. You wouldn't even need a gun.

      For example, up at UC Santa Cruz, deer often graze in the grassy areas in and around the music center parking lot at about 6:30 at night. I've literally walked to within just a few feet of both fawns and does and photographed the

      • It's UC Santa Cruz, that ain't 'grass' they're eating. The deer are stoned.

        Hint: UC Santa Cruz stoners identify themselves to each other by simply saying 'I lived in/at Ivy'. Know the secret codes...

        For myself, I just assume they're stoners when I learn to went to Santa Cruz. Like Perverts from Berlin, you'll rarely be wrong.

        • by dgatwood ( 11270 )

          For myself, I just assume they're stoners when I learn to went to Santa Cruz. Like Perverts from Berlin, you'll rarely be wrong.

          You'd be shocked to know that UCSC is a smoke-free campus now.

          But yeah, it does have that reputation.

  • by 140Mandak262Jamuna ( 970587 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:56PM (#57385136) Journal
    First, Let me be the first to welcome our robotic lawn mowing overlords

    The fitness landscape is constantly changing, and they are evolving. Their generation times are not long. Pretty soon they will learn to avoid robotic lawn mowers.

    Just last week I saw a deer look both directions before crossing the road. Really. The only natural predator left for these rats on hooves are the the genus Automobilia species sedanis, suvis, truckis and truckis. Now they are evolving to avoid them, it is going to be impossible to contain the epidemic.

    • by sjames ( 1099 )

      But beware, if you've ever seen a Toyota after a moose encounter you'll know that sometimes nature wins.

    • by dgatwood ( 11270 )

      Just last week I saw a deer look both directions before crossing the road. Really.

      Dude. I've watched the deer up at UCSC actually cross at the crosswalks. They observe humans and learn more than most people might think. :-)

    • Some animals appear not to have the ability to learn to avoid cars. Squirrels have had 100 years to gain this ability, and still the roads are spotted with squirrel parts.
  • If a robot mower (or regular mower) hit a woodchuck, I think major repairs would be required.

    I've been known for stopping the mower for praying mantis(es) and voles.

    • If a robot mower (or regular mower) hit a woodchuck, I think major repairs would be required.

          Yes, but have you priced out woodchuck brain surgery lately?

    • If a robot mower (or regular mower) hit a woodchuck, I think major repairs would be required.

      How much woodchuck would a lawnmower chuck, if a lawnmower could chuck woodchuck?

      • How much woodchuck would a lawnmower chuck, if a lawnmower could chuck woodchuck?

        Congrats, you win the internet today!

  • Was there a naked man on all fours following the mower, eating the grass and hedgehog carcasses?

    If so, don't call the cops - go with "God bless the grass."

  • Why are they only complaining about the autonomous "robot" lawnmowers? A lawnmower pushed or piloted by a human is going to bisect that hedgehog just as much as one driven by a computer. Anyone who's ever piloted a riding mower through tall grass knows that you're not going to see an object in the grass -- whether it's a small animal or an inanimate object (kids toys etc) -- until after the blades have busted it up.
    • Why are they only complaining about the autonomous "robot" lawnmowers? A lawnmower pushed or piloted by a human is going to bisect that hedgehog just as much as one driven by a computer. Anyone who's ever piloted a riding mower through tall grass knows that you're not going to see an object in the grass -- whether it's a small animal or an inanimate object (kids toys etc) -- until after the blades have busted it up.

      Yeah, but you're not likely to mow your lawn in the dark when Hedgehogs are wandering across them.

    • by Junta ( 36770 )

      Among other things, I would assume the manually operated mowers also happen to usually be gasoline, and as such louder.

      Even for electric mowers, a manually operated electric mower is going to have a relatively huge mowing deck and will be loud operating still, the robot mowers have about 1/3rd the size mowing deck, and even more strives for quiet operation in various ways that would be intolerable if a human were busy operating it.

    • No, with a push mower as a teenager I ran over a snake, and it made me unhappy, so I started looking where I was going, and even in tall grass I'd be able to see the snake trying to run away, and avoid it. It also helps in avoiding rocks, sprinkler heads that didn't retract properly, and even just uneven patches of ground. Generally, paying close attention improves the quality of the work, in addition to saving lives.

      A computer that doesn't have any systems to avoid a snake that is trying to escape in a non

  • by fluffernutter ( 1411889 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:15PM (#57385332)
    I know people don't generally care about animals, because people generally consider themselves more important; but I can see that the 'automation' craze is going to be the worse thing for wildlife and pets ever. What is the motivation for an automated car company to spend time tuning their vehicles to avoid animals? It will be loads more difficult than the main objective of avoiding humans, and I am just not confident anything that isn't big enough to harm the vehicle will be noticed at all.
    • Hell, this is a good point. I have to go out of my way not to hit squirrels. While squirrels might be the hardest to avoid over here, I sure as hell don't want robot vehicles hitting my cats!!!

  • Comment removed based on user account deletion
    • by lgw ( 121541 )

      There was a sonic level where he was chased by an angry 18-wheeler through the whole level, knocking down walls and whatnot. A lawnmower seems a bit anti-climatic.

  • The "famous poem" which was surely written by someone "special" was written in 2001. And it describes a human using a lawnmower and he kills a hedgehog. So now we have automated lawn mowers and they are doing the same thing. Why is this even news?

    Anyone here ever eaten one? A hedgehog I mean, not an automated lawn mower. Wonder what they taste like?
  • by Arzaboa ( 2804779 ) on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:59PM (#57386220)

    "In the United States, despite a wealth of children's toys and clothing featuring hedgehogs, the only live animals you're likely to see are in the zoo or, more controversially, kept as pets. But in Europe, wild hedgehogs are beloved."

    She really needs to actually visit the United States. I can show her a wealth of what we call prairie dogs, along with the biological equivalent of these "scalpers". We call them, hawks.

    --
    "Adopt the pace of nature: Her secret is patience" -- Ralph Waldo Emerson

  • Cuz there are way too many SJWs around nowdays, and the world would be better off if we could cull them somehow.

    / I'm gonna pay for this :(

To be is to program.

Working...