Video Raspberry Pi $25 Linux Computer Now In Production (Video) 196
Video no longer available.
Timothy Lord caught up with Raspberry Pi product leader Eben Upton at CES. The long-awaited $25 Linux single-board computers are finally being shipped from the Chinese factory where they're being assembled and will be available for sale in just a few weeks. Eben talks not only about the Raspberry Pi boards and the add-on Gertboard, but about the eBay auction that helped finance Raspberry Pi. Timothy says he considers Eben Upton one of his "personal tech-world heroes." After watching this video, maybe he'll be one of yours, too. Read on below to watch.
Warning ! (Score:5, Informative)
Remember, the 1st batch of 10000 Raspberry Pi boards will ONLY be available from http://www.raspberrypi.com/ [raspberrypi.com] (you can order some nice stickers in the meantime)
Be aware that scam sites (like http://www.systemsofhull.co.uk/raspberry-model-p-261.html [systemsofhull.co.uk]) have begun to pop-up. :-(
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
My analysis of web analytics shows that given a link, someone percentage of people will click it.
Even if you explicitly say it's a scam, some people will click that link, AND fall for it.
And this even goes for sites with allegedly intelligent and tech savy demographics.
Re:Warning ! (Score:4, Funny)
Whoopsie.
Do NOT click the 2nd link, people !
Re:Warning ! (Score:5, Funny)
Do NOT click the 2nd link, people !
Great, now I HAVE to click it! Stupid reverse psychology...
Re: (Score:2)
Do NOT click the 2nd link, people !
Great, now I HAVE to click it! Stupid reverse psychology...
It's only a boring old electronics shop. No goat, no bathtub, no lemons, no nothing. Please move along.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Seems to work ok here.
Re: (Score:3)
Seems to work ok here.
Yeah, it works if I allow scripts globally. I don't see any particular source that I should be including and the list of blocked sources is a list I would like to stay blocked.
When I allowed scripts globally (for a few seconds) An Amazon tab I had open went nuts.
Blocked sites (12) are from google, amazon, ebay, facebook, openmedia.ca (?) visualwebsiteoptimizer.com (possibly the culprit), stumbleupon, and twitter.
Anyway, I'll give creating an account another try sometime in the future. Maybe they wi
Re: (Score:2)
I don't allow global and it worked for me. I allow most of google, ebay, and amazon though.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
The main problem is that the SoC is difficult/impossible to buy in anything other than enormous quantities. Some of the Raspberry Pi people work at Broadcom, so they're in a slightly better negotiating position than everyone else.
Re: (Score:2)
They have talked about releasing them but I don't think they have actually done so yet.
Plus as the AC says broadcom don't like dealing with small operations (the pi guys are getting a break because they have a guy on the inside) so even when released they will be of limited utility.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I just did a search for "raspberry pi gerbers" and all I found was one low res image of the complete stack (with lower layers mostly obscured and tracks run together by the resoloution limit) which would be completely useless for actually making the thing.
If it's successful it will probablly be cloned eventually regardless of if the gerbers are released or not but it will be by a company with connections and expertise, most likely in the far east. Not by some guy in an appartment complex in hull and unless
Re: (Score:3)
With something like the Arduino, there was definitely room for a bunch of 3rd-party spins: the original was pretty expensive, included a l
Re:Warning ! (Score:5, Informative)
Mr. Andrew Lamb (trading as Systems Of Hull),
Read the announcements on the official Raspberry Pi site - they have NOT made any deals with any resellers.
Also on the forum thread discussing this particular scam - the phone number given it's disconnected and the address of the presumed shop it's for an appartment complex.
Next time you try to scam people, at least be more beliveable.
Re:Warning ! (Score:5, Informative)
God you Slashdotters really are paranoid nutjobs, aren't you? Yes, I AM ANDREW LAMB. Moron. Thanks for proving my whole "crying wolf when he gets confused" theory beyond a doubt.
Funny, I thought the Raspberry Pi design was open-source. Funny kind of open-source if you all call "scam" on anyone who builds & sells them himself ... but hey, you found out his business address is his home address. Damn garage operations, they should all be closed down in favour of corporations.
If you are Andrew Lamb, you're hardly going to get customers with an attitude like that.
You should demonstrate how you're going to fulfil orders. The thread on the forums [raspberrypi.org] points out the problems -- why not respond to them?
Here's the best post from that thread:
1) He claims to be VAT registered but doesn't seem to want to state his VAT number. That is a bit strange. I think I will ring up HMRC and check he is registered. I hope he is otherwise he is committing tax fraud.
2) In his terms and conditions he states "All items are covered by a manufacturers 12 month warranty. If an item develops a fault it is best to request an RMA directly with the manufacturer." WRONG!. UK consumer law makes it crystal clear the seller is responsible for goods sold not the manufacturer. It is the sellers duty to mess about with the manufacturer.
3) He is advertising a product he can not honestly expect to have in stock. I suspect he will take people's money and simply tread water until he can get his hands on enough units to send out to people. This could take months and months.
4) He is selling products based on the PI that don't exist yet. I suspect he will simply grab the first "in-car entertainment" project that comes along and sell that. Nice.
5) He is profiting on a charity selling devices. He is doing nothing than attempting to make £4 for doing nothing other than adding delay and bureaucracy.
Even Cheaper DIY? (Score:3)
They're assembling these in Chinese factories. Which are cheap, but not $0. They're shipped from there to the consumers in EU and US (and others), which also costs more than $0 each.
If hobbyists could assemble them ourselves, they could be even cheaper than $25. And it's primarily hobbyists who are their market. How about it?
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
If you are going to bitch about the customs issue please at least learn what you are talking about. Customs duty is a percentage not a per-item fee.
The problem is that the percentage varies by "type of goods", the complete assembly falls under a category that attracts no duty whereas at least some of the component parts fall under categories that do attract duty.
Unfortunately because the Pi guys haven't released either thier BOM or the quotes they got for construction it's kinda hard to tell how significant
Re:Even Cheaper DIY? (Score:5, Informative)
I think you miss the point -
It costs less to create and assemble the full product elsewhere and send it to the EU/US than it would do to buy the parts in the EU/US or have it assembled in the EU/US.
There's a post on their blog about this exact issue with regards to tax. Components taxed, finished product untaxed, with regards to importing things from abroad.
And unless the difference was HUGE, it wouldn't be worth doing it even if you could - people would expect a reduced price if they are DIY, but you wouldn't be able to ONLY reduce it by as much as it costs to assemble (because that's literally pence on an assembly line in a factory doing them all day). You really want to DIY it for $0.50 cheaper than buying a finished product? The admin costs alone would make it less profitable already. Most of the cost is in the components.
This is pretty much why China makes 99% of the stuff we see in the shops. For crazy tax reasons, and the fact that they produce in bulk, quicker (did you not see that the UK production would take 2-3 months instead of 2-3 weeks?) and cheaper, it's easier to send designs to China, have them source components, assemble them, test them and ship them to EU/US than it ever would be to do even one part of the process in the EU/US.
If you don't believe me, have a look at the OpenPandora project - still about 2-3 years behind schedule and the price has rocketed because they didn't bother to keep tabs on a large US company they used (which resulted in higher costs, poor reliability, thousands of PCB's sitting idle and rottiing before they could be soldered, etc.) and they had to switch to Germany to finish off the very first batch still and things are *STILL* taking months. But the components from the Chinese companies they used have been available since day one (putting aside stupid project management issues like expecting a Chinese factory to make thousands of cables from a unique design after a 3-year wait with no word from the OP team, and expecting the same price to do so as you were quoted at the start).
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
They are basically impossible for hobbyists to assemble without specialised equipment. Soldering is done by reflow - the company would need to supply a solder mask stencil to every purchaser. These are usually made from stainless steel, are reused hundreds or thousands of times, and can be more expensive to produce than a single circuit board. For highest reliability, most components require specific temperature profile curves to be followed in a programmable reflow oven. If you mess up the soldering of a B
Re: (Score:2)
They're assembling these in Chinese factories. Which are cheap, but not $0. They're shipped from there to the consumers in EU and US (and others), which also costs more than $0 each.
If hobbyists could assemble them ourselves, they could be even cheaper than $25. And it's primarily hobbyists who are their market. How about it?
I think they've addressed this on the Pi website... BGA soldering is not much of a hobbyist endeavour. Also, you'd be surprised how import duties applied per component add up when buying a parts kit compared to a single board - contact your local lawmaker about the idiocy of that particular law and what it's doing for local manufacturing (of course, some bright politician probably thinks it's better for the country to offshore all that filthy manufacturing and let the peasants go back to mining coal or wha
Re: (Score:2)
You can solder BGA chips? then you are better than 99% of all home electronics people.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's not actually that hard. I've hand soldered fine pitch SMD devices (0.4mm pitch LQFP, 0.5mm TQFP / TSSOP etc) with just a normal soldering iron with a normal pointy tip, and many people are hand soldering QFN (leadless). BGA is a bit more of a challenge, but the people who make the Schmartboard have tutorials on how to solder BGAs to their boards and it doesn't look all that hard. The real problem with BGA is re-work - you can't inspect them, and if there's a bad solder joint, you can't fix it without r
Re: (Score:2)
You are talented enough at soldiering that you can do the work for the CPU, SD card, and hdmi port? Damn your good.
Sheesh, you kids today... it ain't hard. And why do you want to damn my good?
Auctioning versus selling, optimum pricing (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Auctioning versus selling, optimum pricing (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:3)
They could have sold 10,000 early access/ developer boards at $50 a piece, maybe even doing a 'buy one give one' promotion like the OLPC project. It does kind of defeat the purpose of computers for all, but it'd also helped them guarantee future production...
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Auctioning versus selling, optimum pricing (Score:5, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Auctioning versus selling, optimum pricing (Score:4, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
And two, their real mistake is building demand before they can supply it. You get one big wave of free publicity and enthusiasm. By the time this thing is actually available in significant numbers, it may already have saturated the market of hard core basement dwellers, and us merely Pi-curious types will be at the "Big fat meh, that vapourware again?" stage.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Flamebait)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
First batch to be the $35 version (Score:5, Informative)
Solar powered? (Score:3)
Out of curiosity, I'm wondering whether it would be possible to hook a Raspberry Pi up to a 10'' LCD display and make it solar powered? There is a lot of sun where I live.
How large would the solar panels have to be to provide the power on an ordinary sunny day?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I think the specs say it'll run on 5v, which is four AA batteries.
Volts is not a unit of power.
Amps * Volts = Watts.
These things draw 2.5 watts. You might get half a day out of 4 alkaline AA's.
You will need a solar panel similar to one of these [ccrane.com] just to sustain it, as well as provide an adapter to covert to 5v.
It seems a bit strange... (Score:2)
...to have to read the FAQ to find the specifications or to figure out how to place an order.
Re:Ardino competitor? (Score:4, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
That's what you have with the Pi - a full GNU/Linux system. There's demos of it doing all kinds of crazy stuff, e.g. running Quake.
About the only thing it does not come with is an enclosure.
And if you are confused about price variations - that's because there are two model.
I can't wait to get my hands on one.
Re: (Score:2)
That's what you have with the Pi - a full GNU/Linux system.
I don't know about "full"...I suspect that having limited RAM and running off an SD card will blunt the user experience a bit.
Re: (Score:2)
Composite or HDMI monitor.
Unfortunatelly Raspberry Pi does not have VGA output - the Broadcom SoC used it's a "mobile phone" version and it has only HDMI, Composite & DSI outputs (for direct LCD flat-panel connection)
The SoCs with VGA output were unfortunatelly too expensive.
Re: (Score:2)
...or DVI monitor, which is the same thing, except you probably won't be able to do HDCP. (whew, almost typed DHCP there. acronym soup, oh it hurts.) I have two 19" LCDs I got for $10 a piece just sitting around waiting for a project like this. I also have a 20" LCD which I occasionally use as a second monitor which has component, s-video, vga, and dvi... and a USB hub. Pairing it with a R-Pi would make it fairly complete and there might even be room for the little one inside, but you could still connect a
Re: (Score:2)
HDCP is not HDMI only. In fact it predated HDMI. Any half decent DVI monitor has HDCP. Yeah, there are some lame ones without.
Re: (Score:2)
HDCP can be done via DVI too.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's not an Arduino competitor but runs a normal, general purpose Linux distro of your choice.
However, you also have to provide an enclosure, a SD card and a 5V charger with USB plug for power.
Re: (Score:2)
If it's not fully assembled on my receipt, I'd like to assemble it myself and save even more money with an even cheaper device. Why pay for Chinese assemblers and shipping through China?
Re: (Score:2)
I suspect that it's actually far cheaper and easier to ship you an assembled board than an unassembled board. Shipping stuff like this over from China in a container is really cheap. Also, to disrupt the manufacturing process and ship a bag of bits would add extra cost because that's actually harder to automate.
If you get the Gert board that they mention (a break-out board that gives you lots of IO options for hardware projects) you do get to assemble that yourself :)
Re: (Score:3)
If you are able to solder by yourself BGA package-on-package components, congratulations. Over 99.9% of the potential buyers are not, so it will only come pre-assembled.
You DO have to reach for the soldering iron if you want to use the GPIO,SPI,I2C & UART pins to connect a 1.27mm pitch header to the board.
Re: (Score:3)
Then why pay for the board at all? First, you get your hands on some silicon...
Re: (Score:2)
The primary chip on this thing is a mobile phone chip in a fine pitch (think it's probablly 0.5mm) BGA with ram mounted on-top in a POP configuration. I'd think the number of hobbyists who could reliablly solder such a thing is tiny and all the failures would make a customer service nightmare.
Plus broadcom don't seem to like letting the general public have thier chips for some reason.
Re: (Score:2)
Apart from the price, the overlap with Arduino is pretty small.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It is.
Not all small, bare PCB embedded devices are Arduino's. The two are completely different animals.
Re: (Score:2)
"So, this is basically an Ardino competitor?"
This thing will kick the arduinos ass to the moon and back and then curb stomp it so hard it's not funny.
Arduino is a 3rd graders toy compared to this.
Re: (Score:2)
Different devices/different purposes.
I have an arduino, and I am still getting this. The PI is useful as a general "computer" device. The arduino is better for direct control of hardware etc. Put the two together, either via USB/Serial, or SPI/I2C, and you have a mean thing going.
Re: (Score:2)
Main problem with building it in the UK is that:
It would be $10-$15 more expensive
and you'd have to wait 2-3 Months to get one rather than 2-3 weeks!!
Re:What would have been the cost to be UK-built? (Score:5, Interesting)
and you'd have to wait 2-3 Months to get one rather than 2-3 weeks!!
There's some precedent for this in the UK. Some of the original Sinclair systems were sold for almost exactly the cost of production. They'd take the money, put it in the bank for a month, then buy the parts and build the machine for you. The interest that the money earned in that month was their profit margin.
Re: (Score:2)
Main problem with building it in the UK is that:
It would be $10-$15 more expensive
and you'd have to wait 2-3 Months to get one rather than 2-3 weeks!!
That, _after_ the thing has shipped 7000 KM from "the far east". 40% more expensive and 400% more time to deliver, if the product is assembled locally in the UK. Need I draw conclusions?
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
You've ignored two reasons why it would be more expensive if made in the UK.
Firstly, we don't make all the require components in the UK, so they'd have to be shipped in anyhow. This attracts an import tax.
Secondly, and more relevantly, the import tax law is flawed; you don't have to pay tax on the items which pre-assembled, even if they are made from the same components which, seperately, would be taxed.
Re: (Score:2)
Shipping is cheap if you can fill a container. Depending on the size of the box it might be a penny to a nickel per unit.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
There was a mention on the blog that importing the parts was more expensive that importing the completed device, for some odd reason. Seems the UK tax system is geared towards placating the City these days.
Re:What would have been the cost to be UK-built? (Score:5, Informative)
this is the blog post: http://www.raspberrypi.org/archives/509 [raspberrypi.org]
Re: (Score:3)
for some odd reason.
The problem is that duty levels are set to placate certain interests not to make the system make sense as a whole.
Also afaict customs dutys are set by the EU as a whole not by indvidual countries which means there is even more beuracracy.
Re: (Score:2)
It doesn't take an hour to assemble one, and even in the UK assemblers of these kinds of parts don't make $15 an hour. And don't have 4-5x the latency of products shipped from a planet's width away.
Re: (Score:2)
It doesn't take an hour to assemble one, and even in the UK assemblers of these kinds of parts don't make $15 an hour.
PCB assembler [electronicsweekly.com], £7-7.15/hour, i.e. about $11/hour. (Minimum wage in the UK is £6.08/hour). Add in some overheads (cost of factory buildings and equipment, etc)...
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
If you think someone will hand solder them you are nuts.
Those boards are machine placed, paste solder globs placed and then oven reflow baked to make the BGA processor stick to the board.
The only part that is hand assembled is putting the boards in a box after placing in the testing jig.
Re: (Score:2)
And don't have 4-5x the latency of products shipped from a planet's width away.
It only takes a few days to fedex a package from china. When talking about timescales tomake and assemble a batch of 10K boards a few days is insignificant and it's not like the pi is big or heavy.
Re: (Score:2)
To sum up the post on the official site: ... it's cheaper in China as the end product (computer board) has 0 customs tax according to EU laws.
- Small UK companies were offering faster assembly & low prices but a very low volume (hundreds per week)
- Big UK companies were either not interested for runs under 100k or offered outrageously high quotes and demanded a huge wait time.
Adding the component customs tax to this
Re: (Score:2)
According to the guys at R-Pi, After the import tax, the actual cost of producing the boards would add at least and extra £5 ($7.50) to the cost of each board.
So i over estimated a tad... ^_^
Re: (Score:2)
Well, For UK it will be $25 + VAT + Royal Mail =~ £25 :-)
US buyers will not pay VAT and only slightly more for P&P so they will get it cheaper
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
local electronics labourers don't get paid much at all (~£7/hour for SMT work)
And electronics labourers in China get paid about £0.40/hour. About 5% of the cost of the British guy. It would be nice to having a manufacturing base in the West, but economically it isn't realistic anymore.
Re: (Score:2)
What does an ordinary Alarm Clock cost? Economics says no, you're spot-on.
On a practical side, I'd want some kind of audio-out in parallel with the TV, or at least a way for the Pi to turn the TV on so you're not burning 70W all night long for the backlight to heat up a black screen.
Re: (Score:2)
"or at least a way for the Pi to turn the TV on so you're not burning 70W all night long for the backlight to heat up a black screen."
Funny, my 32" LCD burns 7 watts for the LED backlight, buy a more modern TV for the project if power is a high concern.
The other problem is that it would be a giant night light. even at the lowest setting and a black scene it drops more light in the room than a typical nightlight.
Finally, why the TV? Gut a PSone screen for the composite out and use that in a all in one co
Re: (Score:3)
Yeah, my 3.5 year old 42" LCD backlit TV is an ancient artifact, should really scrap it for that 63W power draw difference, except, wait, at $0.11/kwh, it's only costing $63 per year extra to run it 24/7/365, and it will take 10 years for the electricity costs to have any hope of covering the cost of a new screen. Maybe I should hang onto it until the next generation of tech comes out and makes LED backlighting look like striking sparks from flint.
BTW, I've got a Chumby, sorry to say, it sucks. I still us
Re: (Score:2)
I was going to slap a Bluetooth dongle and maybe a 3G dongle on it (via a USB hub) and turn it into a car-GPS-monitoring system (like I've been trying to build for ages with a Mini-ITX system and never really enjoyed the hardware side of getting it to work / fit in a small case and run off the car sensibly).
The software is easy on Linux, the interfacing isn't too tricky, and being able to text your car and get its location for less than the price of the locked-in GPS monitoring devices I've seen sounds like
Re: (Score:3)
>> being able to text your car and get its location
My car never seems to go anywhere on its own.
Re: (Score:3)
Nice that you live in a nice area. ;-)
My purpose would be a) security monitoring (I text the car, it tells me where it is), b) location awareness (car "knows" if it's moving and sends me a text), c) Finding my car in a strange town (I'm very forgetful and lost my car for over an hour once in Hannover).
Re: (Score:2)
Arduino+GSM shield with Gps = what you want that is easier to build and far more efficient.
Been there, done that. I still have the T-shirt. Based it on one of the projects that balooning people posted.
Re: (Score:3)
Arduino GSM /GPRS / GPS-Shield: 126,05 â
optional GSM Antenna âoeAT-TG.09.0113â : 9,92 â
optional Power Supply: 8,40 â
Arduino GSM / GPRS / GPS-Shield â" Kit : 158,82 â
excl. VAT. plus Postage.
Not including the £/â 50 to buy an Arduino (and VAT is about 20% at the moment).
It would cost me less to buy a small netbook than it would to buy the shield on its own! Or five Raspberry Pi's. Or one Raspberry Pi, a bluetooth USB adaptor, a blu
Re:HD Alarm clock... (Score:4, Insightful)
Ah, Slashdot. The only post-2000 website that can't understand Euro symbols or British pound-signs.
Re: (Score:2)
Holy crap, an arduino is 50 pounds?
last two I bought were $19.00US or about 11 pounds. You guys are getting screwed bad on arduino hardware prices.
Re: (Score:2)
So you're going to leave your TV on all night just so you have an alarm clock display? Have you thought of the power consumption costs?
Re: (Score:2)
Won't work - The Raspberry Pi USB ports are host-only.
But you can have one on a switch (with Rev.B)
Re: (Score:2)
Flash or non-flash, the slashdot videos are not viewable from behind corporate firewalls allowing only ports 80 & 443 :(
Re: (Score:2)
Don't feel bad, even on Win 7 with Flash 11, having added ooyala.com to my URL Filter whitelist, I still can't see the video either... At least now I see the black box so I know there's something I'm missing!
Re: (Score:3)
"Media" SoCs in general(Broadcom certainly no exception) tend to combine a reasonably normal, open, well-understood ARM or MIPs general-purpose CPU with a GPU and/or hardware video decode unit. If you are lucky, these will be supported in some way(I think the BCM part here has a ~15mb blob of mystery powering the graphics bit); but they tend to be excitingly locked down because the manufacturers want to be able to sell them as set-top boxes and other areas where