The Mini-ITX Project Revisited 117
An anonymous reader writes "From the article: "Once my original Mini-ITX project was completed I finally had a chance to sit back and use the computer. After a couple weeks of general internet browsing, emailing, and so forth, I was able to get a better understanding of the system and a feel for its design. Knowing how simple my needs were, the Mini-ITX project computer was orginally designed to be as basic and quiet as possible. This meant no hard drive, no extra accessories- just a stripped down system. While this suited my needs well at the time, its lack of versatility soon became an issue. This meant it was back to the drawing board for a retooling of the Mini-ITX project computer. The changes include a new case, operating system and boot device, along with improved cooling. The new system was tested using Slax and then MEPISLite." Even better link is the site itself which regularly carries mods.
Re:"The" Mini-ITX Project? (Score:2, Funny)
He also invented Basebale and then he hit the first Homerun! Yeah, that's the ticket!
I remember seeing cabinets, motherboards, etc. even partially assembled ones for sale at a local shop, a couple years ago. This may be interesting to anyone who hasn't built or bought one and is thinking about doing that. As for me I use my Big PC (Tiamat) to cool the apartment in the summer, w
slashdot SPAM! (Score:5, Informative)
Lame.
Re:slashdot SPAM! (Score:3, Funny)
I agree with you and feel your pain.
Now, send $5 to:
What are you talking about? (Score:1)
-matthew
Re:What are you talking about? (Score:1)
Layover/popup ads, which I find very obnoxious since they obscure part of the article. These are not popup windows, but some javascript/css over lays. They popup with an ad in them every time you move the mouse pointer over a link in the article. I guess it's possible your web browser doesn't support or has turned off the feature require for those obnoxious fuckers to work. Or maybe ads popping on text you are reading doesn't count as obnoxious to you - eac
Re:What are you talking about? (Score:2)
-matthew
Re:What are you talking about? (Score:1)
No, there are links embedded in content, dragging the mouse of those causes a overlay/popup. There are some other posts below complaining about the same thing. There where around a dozen of these links.
I'm only pushing this because I am curious about the technology used to push ads.
If you seriously can't see those really annoying ads, then maybe there are doing it to some people and not others. I got no enjoyment or information out of t
I really like how this NEXT (Score:5, Funny)
Showing off his awesome NEXT >>
Mini ITX NEXT >>
Computer NEXT >>
Re:I really like how this NEXT (Score:3, Funny)
Re:I really like how this NEXT (Score:1)
That is until I found that the AdBlock extension for Firefox can block them. All you have to do is look at the HTML code for the page (usually at the bottom) and add a blocking rule for the ad service they are using.
Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:5, Interesting)
We've put together a few dozen silent boxes based off of compact flash / IDE adapters and have been VERY pleased with the results.
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:2)
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:3, Interesting)
Epia Stability (Score:5, Informative)
I'm installing one with a DC-DC converter in my car this week. It looks high quality. We'll see...
Re:Epia Stability (Score:2)
Now I am going to get one without a fan, because fans *are* a pain in the butt. You can easilly ru
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:2)
-matthew
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:2)
mini-box.com has 'em.. you might need a cable to space it off the motherboard, but other than that, it should work fine.
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:1)
Re:Those dc/dc converter boards (Score:1)
Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
I agree that many ARE just plain ugly (yet, with Mini-ITX, they've usually still got some element that makes them interesting). However, some do look good.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:5, Insightful)
Well, that's not the fault of the Mac Mini-- it's the fault of Mini-ITX for charging such high prices. I would have built one of these things years ago, but the price was much too high for my needs.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1, Redundant)
Well, that's not the fault of the Mac Mini-- it's the fault of the Mini-ITX vendors for charging such high prices. I would have built one of these things years ago, but the price was much too high for my needs.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
I use a 1,6GHz centrino-based laptop & port replicator that I bought on eBay as a media center, with a Dazzle DVC 150 for video capturing. It is fanless 99% of the time, uses very little power, has its own backup battery and screen, can be used as a laptop after switching hardware config and taking it out of the port replicator, and it is fast enough. The only shortcoming of th
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:5, Insightful)
Put all this together, and I can hide the server in a closet and forget about it. Just need a power drop and two network connections.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
The portability is such that I can either have it in a closet, or have it with my other AV gear. (the closet comment was mostly to illustrate the "hands-off" aspect. set it and forget it, as it were).
Further, the Mac mini fan noise is a big issue [google.com], and makes it unsuitable for a home theater setting.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
If there was better PVR software for the Mini, I'd end up getting one instead a separate MythTV front-back end....
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
you got that impression from which part of the writeup. Was it the part where he says
"Anyways, if anyone has a hack where I can control the fan a bit more, I'd love to hear about it, because its bothersome when I'm playing WoW and the fan's going full-blast the entire time for very little reason - the same game on my Toshiba doesn't rev that engine nearly as much."
Now imagine how annoying
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
I should charge royalties on that comment.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1)
Industrial / automotive + mac mini == broken mini (Score:5, Insightful)
One BIG advantage to mini-ITX is that they are easily put into functional, solid enclosures with additional power supply protection you don't find in the mini. The boards themselves support booting off of flash, and it's very easy to purpose-build them with no hard drive attached.
You're not going to run a piece of industrial automation equipment off a mac mini. There's no reason you couldn't, I guess, but it's much easier to purpose-build something around the VIA board. A lot of the time, these things end up running DOS. There's no RTOS available for the mini I am aware of.
We've done a lot of work replacing old tower PC's with things that can bolt into telco utility closets next to the PBX. With the via board, these are just drop in replacements.
For the consumer that just wants a computer, the mac mini is very attractive. There's lots of other applications - like bolting a computer to a wall - where it doesn't make a lot of sense.
YMMV, of course.
the power supply on the Mac mini is external.. (Score:3, Informative)
It's just amazing to me that somone "in the business" would miss this.
Note to other posters below, yes, any Mac can be made to power up upon application of power. It's in the Energy Saver preferences panel, called "Restart automatically after a power failure."
I do wish the Mac mini had a Pentium-M in it instead of a G4. It'd be a lot faster than the current Mac mini or a VIA Mini-IT
No RTOS for Mini? (Score:1)
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1, Troll)
Server farms? (Score:3, Insightful)
Why don't you grow up and just buy a dual core server and stop trying to use Most-Inefficient-Means? Mini ITX server farm, that's a laugh...
Re:Server farms? (Score:2)
While I have a cluster of 10 24" rack mount units (each 2U, each holding two PCs) that are older than dirt, I cluster them for the sake of learning how. It's far cheaper than buying 10 xeon systems or what-not. In my case space is a non-issue, nor is performance. If you are serious about cluster computing then maybe you should consider something purpose built? As I see it, the mini-ITX is only good for front-ends to any given system.
-nB
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1)
http://www.squarebox.co.uk/thresholdFront.jpg [squarebox.co.uk]
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
Why do you Mac shills have to tout a Mac product for every slashdot story not matter how tangentally related?
The Mini-ITX is vastly more flexible then a Mac mini - and hence targets a different market.
Want to run a Mac Mini off DC? Sure, buy an inverter and hope to god it doesn't max out its 240W PSU.
Want to run a mini-ITX off DC? Sure! No problem, buy a carkit [elx.com.au] and away you go. 60W. No inverter needed. Power consumption more controllable.
I'm not saying the mac-minis are worse then a mini-itx (they'
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:1)
Not for everyone's needs, but: (Score:2)
I can think of a few applications where this combination would roxor a Mac-Mini, even if the 2 CPUs together have slightly lower flops than the Mac-mini's single CPU.
I was thinking of starting a company building special application machines based on these, but life got in the way.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:4, Insightful)
The real expense seems to be in the case. I can buy a decent looking ATX case for $ 20, but a real Mini-ITX case can cost a lot more. Then there's the PSU; I can get a silent ATX PSU that does the job for $ 15, but Mini-ITX fans often prefer PSUs that cost a lot more.
Finally, last time I checked, the cheapest hard drive I could find was 60 GB for about $ 50. I'd be happy to have even a quarter of the size if I could get it at a lower price, but no such luck. Hard drives are also one component I won't buy second hand, because I'm fearful of head crashes.
In the end, I ended up building a system with a VIA EPIA SP8000E, a nice looking black ATX case, a cheap QTec low-noise PSU, and an AOPEN DUW1608 DVD burner. It cost me about EUR 200 for the board, EUR 20 for the case, EUR 15 for the PSU, and EUR 50 for the burner. Less than EUR 300 in total; I reckon a bit over $ 300. I plugged in some old RAM I had lying around, and installed Debian over NFS.
The system I built can't compete with a Mac Mini in terms of performance, but it's good enough for me, and it's quite a bit cheaper; and it would still be cheaper if I had bought RAM and a hard drive with it.
I would think... (Score:2, Interesting)
Y
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:4, Insightful)
I don't know about other Mini-ITX modders out there, but to me if you factor in the time I spend dorking around with the mini-itx, it gets better. For me, at least, there was a positive feedback loop. I enjoyed mucking with the board. If I had the time and money right now, I'd do it again because of the recreational value I got from it. I still like to point out that my home server has a peak power draw of just under 25W - and that only occurs when the unit is powered on and the hard drives have to suck extra juice to spin up.
Re:Buy a MAC-Mini, call it good! (Score:2)
I disagree on the pricing. You should have no trouble putting together a complete miniITX sytem with a 1.2ghz CPU, 1gb RAM, 100gb HD, DVDROM, and cas
Advertisment (Score:5, Insightful)
Another Advertisement
More Advertisements
And here is how i put my mini-itx motherboard into a NEW case designed for it *BUY HERE*
------
This is news if you consider me taking a dump new...because its in a different toilet than usual.
Does this really deserve a frontpage article? (Score:5, Insightful)
Step 2: Assemble computer.
I have three of these things (silent, flashboot, netboot - the whole bit). Can I get a frontpage article for assembling commodity parts as well?
Re:Does this really deserve a frontpage article? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Does this really deserve a frontpage article? (Score:1)
Stuff That Matters? (Score:1, Redundant)
amateur hour (Score:1, Insightful)
seems like a lot of work... (Score:2, Informative)
Weeks? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Weeks? (Score:2)
Nano-ITX (Score:4, Interesting)
I have to agree with the other comments about how Mac minis are killing mini-ITX. I'm just waiting for a Pentium-M Mac mini so I can install Linux and use WINE. It'll make a great PVR/game console.
Re:Nano-ITX (Score:3, Informative)
They're not all that much smaller actually. The big one is that they integrated the DC/DC converter, so you just need to run 12V into the board. That's a big problem with mini-ITX if you want to put it in a small box.
Re:Nano-ITX (Score:1)
Also, check out these Pentium-M Mini-ITX boards [logicsupply.com]. Small form factor Pentium-M motherboards already exist!
Note: I'm not connected with that company. I just ordered something from them, so I was looking around
Re:Nano-ITX (Score:1)
Re:Nano-ITX (Score:2)
Re:Nano-ITX (Score:2)
If it doesn't have to be a Mac, then a Pentium M mini-clone is already available from VoodooPC [voodoopc.com] for about $900 w/o shipping (Pentium M 740, Intel 915GM chipset). Much cheaper options will be coming soon from AOpen [digitimes.com], which supplies that case/motherboard to VoodooPC.
Re:Fanless (Score:2)
Re:Fanless (Score:2)
Implies that the key requirement was not having a fan. Or should I extrapolate - "I'd take a PC without a fan, or a Mac with a fan in my small form factor choices"?
Re:Fanless (Score:1)
It's desirable, for instance in a music room. I too would be very interested in an economical fanless solution, but will settle for the quiet-ish alternatives I already have until there is a strong motivation to upgrade.
"Fanless" while still high performance enough to run software synths and multitrack recorders, would qualify as a strong motivation to upgrade, but not to crossgrade.
I do have a mini-itx experimental box which is fanless, and I find
Should have put more RAM in it if... (Score:2, Interesting)
Bet the guy is using IIS too.
Definitely a spam-tastic link btw, much as I like Mini-ITX stuff, if you we're going to link to an interesting recent mini-itx article, this one at http://www.linuxdevices.com/news/NS3032138730.html [linuxdevices.com] [linuxdevices.com]LinuxDevices is miles better, 64-way Linux mini-ITX cluster... and it's silent(ish) too!
Re:Should have put more RAM in it if... (Score:1)
However, so what.
1) You don't need the cluster to be in the classroom for people to use it to learn about clusters. That's why we have ssh.
2) If you want to talk about installing the software to build a cluster, two to four old cpus will serve the same purpose and you can just conveniently group students up by lab tables.
3) If you want to talk about experimenting with parallel architectures, you need more i/o capability for things like hypercubes
Mac Mini (Score:3, Interesting)
-matthew
Re:Mac Mini (Score:2)
The mini-ITX boards are only ~6.5 inches square while the Mac mini has a 6 inch square footprint.
A small DC->DC converter attached to the side, and a laptop style hard disk and CD/DVD drive could probably fit in not much more space than the Mac mini takes up.
Most of the very small cases still lay the power converter parallel with the motherboard, and right behind it. So instead of the 7x7-8 or so footprin
Re:Mac Mini (Score:2)
Also, not only do these mini-ITX cases have a larger footprint, but they are usually much taller than a Mac mini.
-matthew
Re:Mac Mini (Score:2)
The reason I think we see cables and not direct connections for the PSU is simply flexibility. If you wanted to mount the hard disk or slim line CD drive as close to the motherboard as possible (to reduce height) a 2-3 inch high PSU sticking up out of the motherboard would be an obsticle. A cable potentially gives you the flexibility to moun
Re:Mac Mini (Score:2)
Yeah but... (Score:4, Funny)
I'm waiting for the nano-ITX myself (Score:2)
Re:I'm waiting for the nano-ITX myself (Score:2)
I'm lost... (Score:3, Interesting)
Been there, done that, never again. (Score:5, Insightful)
They are not bad computers, if you realize that they are slow as all get out. When used in the right environments (embedded devices, simple robots, etc...) they probably work well. They are not good desktop machines, however. On a price to performance ratio they suck. They are absurdly expensive for what you get. Especially if you add in the tiny cases. You can easily spend as much or more than a Mac Mini would cost and still end up with a larger, noisier and less powerful computer.
If I decide to go down the tiny PC road again I'm going Mac Mini. It can sit there and stare in awe at my G5 Powermac.
Re:Been there, done that, never again. (Score:1)
*g* You haven't seen Stepford Wives lately, have you?
SCNR, no offence
I'm sure a cheap Dell laptop would do it. (Score:5, Interesting)
That's pretty much it for a 1.0 version. Later revs can include a DVD drive or any other peripheral that was in the original notebook. If you don't like the LCD screen just go out and buy the big screen you want and plug it into the SVGA port you already have on your anchovy-can PC.
Remember all the ports and connectors are already there and if you want to move or hide them you can do that with some simple extention cables inside the case. Because once you remove the keyboard, the screen, the case, the battery and the powersupply your pc is not that much bigger than 10" x 4" x 0.7" including the hard drive.
Re:I'm sure a cheap Dell laptop would do it. (Score:2)
Re:I'm sure a cheap Dell laptop would do it. (Score:1)
Sure, it depends. (Score:2)
Re:Sure, it depends. (Score:2)
Winter (Score:1)
But will it run MAME? (Score:2)
I would like to get another one to replace the system in my MAME cabinet. Before I subject the internet store I bought the last one from to another buy and return, can anyone tell me if an 800 MHz VIA EPIA C3 processor can play common MAME games smoothly? Woul
Mac Mini comparison? (Score:1)
Cluster (Score:2)