Bluetooth Ads Beamed from Billboards 231
dylanduck writes "Billboards in the UK have been using Bluetooth to beam media clips at passing cellular phones. The system has been dubbed Bluecasting and 17,000 people accepted the ads. When billboards know your name that's when to really worry."
Hmmm (Score:5, Funny)
That's how we can kill this (Score:5, Insightful)
Sit it next to a real coke bluecaster, and then half the time that people choose to "Accept connection from Coke?" they'll get the porn.
Bluetooth doesn't have a whole lot of authentication other than the name that the other node chooses.
It wont take many calls to a large companies complaint department about them dispatching porn before this whole dumb idea will go away.
BlueTooth Hacking billboards! (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:BlueTooth Hacking billboards! (Score:2)
Bob Huntley, try WWW.PORNO-GOOD.COM for the best pron. Find online pics and discreet phone service!!!
Re:BlueTooth Hacking billboards! (Score:5, Funny)
When billboards know your name...
Well, it is the UK, and when they give you something or say goodbye, they often say "Cheers." And that's where everyone knows your name, so it fits.
Okay, I'm leaving now.
Leaving so soon? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:BlueTooth Hacking billboards! (Score:2)
I guess Instead of afraid I'm just mad. I vow to never buy things advertised on billboards.
Trace people using bluetooth MAC (Score:2, Interesting)
a lot about Bluetooth and its protocols but I can
imagine that a device that sends a connection request might get a reply back of the like "I got your request to connect to application X, now hold on while I signal the user and ask her if it is okay". In this case the advertiser gets the MAC even though the user does not authorize the connectino.
Uh, Oh... (Score:2)
Re:Uh, Oh... (Score:2)
I haven't looked for it in a while, but I remember it being there as recently as April.
Great... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Great... (Score:5, Informative)
Funny how many comments got this wrong....
You must be... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Great... (Score:2)
Funny how many comments got this wrong....
1) Most posters are American
2) Most Americans have never even *seen* a train station [wikimedia.org]
Re:Great... (Score:2)
depends on what class of bluetooth you are using...
(more info at [wikipedia.org]) most phones I've seen real specs on say that they are class 2 devices, and as far as I know pairs of class 1 and class 2 devices are limited by the shorter transmission range...So lets say 10 meters (or metres)
Re:Great... (Score:5, Insightful)
That reminds me: we're at the beginning of this 'new frontier'. Right now, they're getting about a 1 in 6 acceptance ratio -- Today, it's a novel idea. A few months, or years, down the road, they'll be seeing those numbers drop preciptiously. Then they'll start resorting to all sorts of tricks to get people to 'accept' their garbage, and we'll have to start writing software to filter out thes ads, then they'll come up with work-arounds, and then....
Starting to sound like the spam wars??? There's a reason.
Please RFTA (Score:2)
I imagine roadside billboards would not be used, it's bad enough in the US with intrusive bill boards on road sides.
Enough Advertising already! (Score:2)
Re:Enough Advertising already! (Score:2, Funny)
A: No
http://www.justtoiletpaper.com/advertisenew.shtml [justtoiletpaper.com]
In the US (Score:3, Funny)
Re:In the US (Score:4, Funny)
I find if you quadruple ROT13 encrypt your name you'll get a little bit more protection.
Welcome Mr. Yakamoto (Score:2)
Re:Welcome Mr. Yakamoto (Score:3, Insightful)
Well... (Score:2)
Of course, how many /.'ers actually leave BT enabled on their phones/PDAs?
Re:Well... (Score:4, Interesting)
Me, for one. I've even got it broadcasting my name, so if someone around me finds it, they know who it belongs to.
I don't mind people saying "hi", in a matter of speaking. So far, it's been coworkers etc. who decide to send me files. When I start getting ads/spam on it, I will shut it off.
Re:Enabled? What about discoverable? (Score:2)
My wife's cellphone also has it enabled because that was the default and I didn't feel like explaining the potential security risks to her.
Besides, bluetooth is practically broken
Re:Enabled? What about discoverable? (Score:2, Funny)
Cabbage.
Sci-Fi (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Sci-Fi (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Sci-Fi (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Sci-Fi (Score:2)
Actually, a short story in 1956 [wikipedia.org].
bluetooth spam to your phone.. (Score:4, Insightful)
now we will have bluetooth spam everywhere we go..
just what we need..
Re:bluetooth spam to your phone.. (Score:5, Informative)
For goodness sake folks, just use the technology, it provides the tools for that.
Re:bluetooth spam to your phone.. (Score:2)
Re:bluetooth spam to your phone.. (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:bluetooth spam to your phone.. (Score:2)
If they'd let me do the asking... (Score:5, Insightful)
Otherwise, it's like a pop-up on your phone, asking if you'd like to see a pop-up ad.
Re:If they'd let me do the asking... (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:If they'd let me do the asking... (Score:2)
BlueTooth Ads?!? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:BlueTooth Ads?!? (Score:2)
You just might be onto something there though... a tool that "de-BlueSpams" your phone, "whitening" your Bluetooth. Get it?
Is this like L.A. Story? (Score:2)
Hmm, haven't seen these so far (Score:4, Interesting)
They concerned the use of unlicensed faux-minicabs to lure women into situations where they are abducted and often sexually abused.
The billboards allowed you to align your phone's IR receiver with a flashing icon to receive information on how to better protect yourself if you happen to be a woman.
I daresay Bluetooth seems rather more invasive as a means of delivering content - particularly commercial advertising rather than citizen's advice.
Re:Hmm, haven't seen these so far (Score:2)
Personally, the women in my life have been taught how the align their sights to better protect themselves from such activities.
That's a lot of acceptance, but not for long! (Score:4, Insightful)
So this is good advertising.... for now... =)
It's exactly the same as email spam (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:It's exactly the same as email spam (Score:2)
the miserable consumer a**hole has no rights.
incidentally, rule #2 is "goto rule #3"
and you might have guessed rule #3 thru #999...
Idea for advertising (Score:5, Funny)
With this, you can even choose with an analog dial, which emitters (let's call them "stations") to listen to the advertisers! Furthermore, why stop with advertising? Let's add content, like news or music, too!
Forget about podcasting, bluecasting. The future is "wavecasting"! It'll rock!
*Rushes to the patent office*
Re:Idea for advertising (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Idea for advertising (Score:2)
It's unfortunate that this "wavecasting" doesn't have a good Tivo-like service or device available for it. There are some time-shift wavecasting devices, but last I heard, they aren't very good.
Re:Idea for advertising (Score:2)
Content? You sir, are completely talking giberrish! The public would never accept such a thing.
Got my hopes up when this happened to me (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Got my hopes up when this happened to me (Score:3, Interesting)
Spam (Score:2, Insightful)
Is it spam or Will people stop using tech? (Score:2, Interesting)
Exactly. Low tech is the wave of the future.
In the Fremont neighborhood in Seattle, one of the most wired and tech neighborhoods, many of us no longer wear watches or carry cell phones, because they're a nuisance. We let loose the electronic leashes and savor the joy of life.
And then we go home and use our wireless laptops and high-speed cable/DSL/intern
Re:Spam (Score:2, Funny)
Some may have stopped already. Those of you who have stopped using technology altogether please reply to this post so we can count you.
But...but... (Score:5, Funny)
Oh, I don't know. Sometimes you want to go where everybody knows your name, and they're always glad you came. You want to be where you can see our troubles are all the same. You want to be where everybody knows your name.
Cheers,
Ian
Dubbed blueSPAMMING, not blueCASTING (Score:5, Interesting)
The real world calls it SPAM. If you have to get trendy, BlueSpamming. Or if you want to get really wild, based on IM SPAM = SPIM, you get BLUE SPAM = SPLUE.
We let them use Hacker for Cracker, and we let them take Digital Rights Management for Digital Restriction Mechanisms. We control the names, folks, not them. A dog does not lay bioreclaimable fertilizer on the path, it shits on the sidewalk. "BlueCasting" sounds like a neat 21st century hip thing. "Spam" is a nasty annoyance that Russians get beat to death for. Give it the correct name.
blueSPAMMING and DigitalRestrictionMechanisms (Score:2)
Good catch there. Since techies control the lingo, we determine the playing field.
BlueSpamming it is.
Re:blueSPAMMING and DigitalRestrictionMechanisms (Score:2)
Nope, it's SPUE (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Dubbed blueSPAMMING, not blueCASTING (Score:3, Funny)
Err... as you so eloquently pointed out, we don't
New technology (Score:2, Interesting)
I wonder if, for some people, disabling their phone/device from being discovered via bluetooth will be a viable option? Maybe they need that enabled for something? Too bad there isn't a "DO NOT RECEIVE ADVERTISEMENTS" setting.
Thank God. (Score:2, Insightful)
Thank God, bluetooth can be disabled.
--
Dreamhost [dreamhost.com] superb hosting.
Kunowalls!!! [kunowalls.host.sk] Random sexy wallpapers.
Re:Thank God. (Score:5, Informative)
Did you uninstall your browser because of advertisements? Did you stop riding the bus because they have posters inside advertising stuff? Did you give up all email because you got a spam? Did you throw your phone in disgust when AT&T sent you an SMS ad? Did you stop watching television because of commercials? (OK, bad example :-) No, you probably installed Adblock, or a filtering proxy like the proxomitron. You may have installed a spam filter on your email. You might have bought a TiVo or ReplayTV to avoid the commercials. And who knows, maybe you did give up public transit because of advertising.
Avoiding Bluespam is easier than any of the above. If you simply don't turn discovery "on" your machine won't answer their spamspitter. Period. And there really isn't a valid technical reason to turn discovery on and leave it on unless you're 'toothing' (looking for anonymous MOTAS.) As a matter of fact, Motorola doesn't even allow the option of leaving discovery on for more than 60 seconds, it's that unneeded. Saying "no Bluetooth because I might get an ad if I ever travel to London" is a completely over the top over-reaction.
As an aside, if you're looking for the best bluetooth functionality in a phone, go Sony-Ericsson. Motorola's bluetooth stack is very buggy and their functionality incomplete. I'm way unhappy with my new Razr.
just one word of warning (Score:2)
Horrible advertising of the future.. (Score:4, Insightful)
(I pick up 75 wireless access points on my 12 mile commute through what I thought was the countryside - so I can't imagine what this "bluecasting" will be like once it takes off in cities).
I can almost see the next step being advertisers pressuring phone makers to require always-on phones with always-on bluetooth so that they can't be "denied" the chance to spam your phone. You won't be able to switch the phone off, will only ever be able to switch to "silent mode" for a couple of hours at a time (like for going to a movie theater), and it'll automatically accept absolutely anything sent to it (and it'll simply keep the last 128MB [or however much storage the device has] of messages received). Just walking through the mall your phone will pick up 40 different advertising messages before you get to the store you wanted to go to - and when out driving, billboards and other cars will all repeatedly spam you.
And worst of all, they'll advertise this as being a "feature" of the phone ("get always-on bluecast so you're not left out! all the cool kids have it.. and you want to be cool.. don't you?") - and people will still buy it.
Re:Horrible advertising of the future.. (Score:2, Insightful)
Dunno. Why would you want an internet connection on your pc? Looks like phones are going the way of the average windows box, pretty soon 60% of its processing time will be spent on the firewall, antivirus and anti-spyware. Which leaves about 40% to animate that silly wallpaper. Every form of technology that allows communication will at one point or another be used for advertising. As long as advertising actually works, an
Scary Billboards (Score:2, Interesting)
17,000 or 17%? Willing? (Score:2, Insightful)
FTA - "The posters detected 87,000 Bluetooth phones over a two week period, of which about 17% were willing to download the clip, says Scott."
First 17% is more like 14,790. I couldn't find a reference to the 17,000 number. (Perhaps its somewhere on the corporate web site link.) But even ignoring this point I'd still question the "willing" statement. Does that mean people intentionlly enabled access to their cell phones. Or is it more like 17% of blue tooth cell phonesare left unsecured by their own
Re:17,000 or 17%? Willing? (Score:2)
Yea, I'm shocked that so many people were interested in ColdPlay, too /duck
In order to be detected, every single one of those 87k phones had their bluetooth enabled. 14k is the number who answered "Ok, send me the clip", I assume... a pretty high number. This has marketing dweebs wetting themselves, I'm sure.
Re:17,000 or 17%? Willing? (Score:2)
BlueTooth Spam (Score:3, Funny)
I will not read it, Sam I am.
I will not read it in the tube,
I will not read it even if it shows me a boob
I will not read it in my car
I will not read it in a bar
I do not like Bluetooth spam
I do not like it, Sam I am.
Hmm I wonder.... (Score:3, Interesting)
Over-marketing (Score:4, Insightful)
Is it possible to go anywhere or do anything these days without being advertised at? Seems you just can't get away from it anymore.
In any case, if I'm standing on a train platform looking at a billboard, I can just read the damn billboard. What is the point of sending me a message to tell me about what's on the billboard?
The MS Windows of protocols? (Score:2)
You think that's bad... (Score:2)
Won't work in Canda (Score:2, Interesting)
I could buy a phone from the US and get it hacked, but why should I lose a warranty and pay a couple hundred dollars when I should be able to get one for FREE or close to it ($99 at most).
How long has bluetooth b
Full-Service Advertising (Score:2)
"Just Say No" to invasive advertising. (Score:2)
*sigh* another reason to keep bluetooth disabled (Score:2, Interesting)
Riiiight.
I find the whole notion of this distasteful. Billboards are bad enough. This is adding spam to them. I don't use Bluetooth now (see no real benefit from it really) and if enabling Bluetooth is going to subject me to spam, no thanks . .
But, considering in 2000 the hot marketing gimmick was to mount Palm Pilot's around metropolitan areas (
What they really mean (Score:2)
Never mind that (Score:3, Interesting)
Imagine being somewhere like a casino (where you can bet they already or will soon will use face recognition on everyone). Cameras could be positioned in certain places to automatically recognise a person and change all the machines and signs within the proximity to be more appealing.
Hell, I bet a system could pitch different ads depending on whether a man, women, or kids were walking past based on their smell. For extra sophistication it could even detect BO & perfume as giveaways of the person's wealth and status.
Re:Cool (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Cool (Score:4, Informative)
Last I heard, there's no charge for bluetooth datatransfer. Bluetooth is like wifi, not like SMS.
Re:Cool (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Cool (Score:2, Informative)
Re:hmm (Score:5, Funny)
Re:hmm (Score:2)
With a PDA with a browser this might just be viable.
Re:hmm (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:hmm (Score:2)
Farmers have got around that to some extent by parking trucks in their fields close to the road with advertisements on them but they are few and far between and some distance from the road. To be honest with the speeds we drive it can't have anything much more than "Buy Food" on it otherwise we can't read it in time.
Most ro
Re:Thank God my Phone Isn't Bluetooth (Score:2)
My bluetooth radio is always on. That doesn't mean I'm discoverable. What it means is that things have to know I'm out there before they'll attempt to try and connect with me (This means that I'm paired). If you actually have a dependence upon being always discoverable, I'd like to hear it. Otherwise, there's no reason for it, imho.
I don't even think I can make my phone always discoverable..
Re:crazy (Score:5, Insightful)
Nah, just curious. The first time they do this, 17,000 people will accept the "blue-vert". Of those 17,000, the next time, only 7,000 people will accept. The third time, 700.
Eventually the new technology will penetrate the common consciousness and people will just start ignoring it, since it is, after all, thoroughly useless and annoying. The only thing it has going for it is its novelty. Once that's dried up, "blue-vertising" will go away and die.
Re:crazy (Score:2)
Oh, wait...
Re:crazy (Score:2)
what a fad that turned out to be.
well, it can get a lot more stupid.. (Score:2, Funny)
okay, we'll just call it podpulling from now on then..
Re:well, it can get a lot more stupid.. (Score:2)
I think podpulling could really catch on. Except in Duluth, where it's illegal to engage in public podpulling.
Re:well, it can get a lot more stupid.. (Score:2)
At least until you need glasses.
Re:stupid names on stupid names (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Another reason (Score:3, Interesting)
Nah! That's what voice mail is for. Actually among my friends SMS is by far the preferred way of communicating. Not actually speaking to one another. In fact, in order of use, phones are probably used for...
- SMS/Test messages
- Photos
- Providing data connections
- Voice calls.
If work wants to contact me they can buy me a blackberry. They haven't so far and I wont give them my private number.