AMD and Intel Notebooks Head to Head 204
An anonymous reader writes "The two chip giants go head-to-head in this review of notebook computers which features 10 different models." From the article: "To be blunt, sourcing high-performance AMD-based notebooks for this test was less difficult than extracting teeth from a fully grown chicken -- but only just. After much chasing, only two vendors submitted an AMD-powered product -- MSI and Asus. Interestingly, both vendors had their Intel-powered notebooks at the Lab with no chasing needed. We should point out that the rarity of AMD product is not the fault of AMD, rather vendors, in Australia at least, do not seem to stock adequate quantities of high-performance AMD-equipped notebooks. Acer, for example, has a humdinger of a notebook the Acer Ferrari 3400 that is equipped with a mobile Athlon 64 but the company was unable to ship a single unit to the lab during the entire month of May."
Its a conspiracy. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Its a conspiracy. (Score:2)
Of course they couldn't (Score:5, Funny)
Printer-friendly version (Score:5, Informative)
Fewer ads 'n' whatnot: Clicky. [zdnet.com.au]
Re:Printer-friendly version (Score:2)
One possible explenation (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:One possible explanation (Score:5, Interesting)
When I got my AMD64 notebook, eighteen months ago (yes, early adopter, I know) I was told it would be unreliable, run too hot, etc. etc. It has so far survived eighteen months of commuting and abuse, especially the abuse of using it as a test vehicle for a complete web server and development platform. It's still on the first HDD ("Won't last eight months...") And so far the only thing to go wrong is a little rubber foot came off (replaced with superglue.) Even though my other notebook is a P-M Thinkpad, I would recommend the AMD64 to anyone who actually needs performance.
Re:One possible explanation (Score:4, Funny)
Usually followed by the computer salesman's pitch for their extended warranty.
Re:One possible explanation (Score:2)
One theory is that the quality of manufacturing these days is so poor that "extended warranties" might not be such a stupid choice for major purchases. My ancient 15" no-name monitor lasted for 7 years or so. Both of my higher-end Mitsubishi CRTs ($500+ each) crapped out shortly after the 3 year warranty.
Re:One possible explanation (Score:2)
It is very interesting that the stupid/poor buy $400 trashputers that fry out in 3 months, because the powersupply can at peek produce 20 fewer watts than the system needs to properly intialize everything on board... and thus can actually use the extended warranty. except that they then get thier trashputer replaced with an equally trashy trashputer, that has been tried with various defective parts until it can boot up a
Re:One possible explanation (Score:2)
Re:One possible explanation (Score:2)
And I can see you have zero concept of how a computer works. Load is load, if it's running your fancy J2EEeeeek or if it's running a million instances of Tux Racer. Both consume the available resources (one for work, the other to meet Suns Marketing Department requirements).
Fodder for the lawsuit? (Score:3, Interesting)
More cannon fodder (Score:5, Funny)
Re:More cannon fodder (Score:2)
If that sort of low-volume enthusiast novelty hardware is typical of AMD64 notebooks, it hardly requires conspiracy theories about Intel to explain why vendors (in Australia, mind you!) don't have lots of them in stock.
Ferrari 4000 (Score:2)
Though if you're looking for Overkill, you can't beat the Clevo D900K [amdboard.com] series.
Re:Ferrari 4000 (Score:3, Funny)
On the other hand, the Tulip E-Go [amdboard.com] on that site is genuinely stunning. I don't know how many customers there are for a 64-bit laptop that looks like a tulip-covered handbag, though. And 283,000 Euros for the diamond-encrusted model is a bit steep -- maybe Lil' Kim would want one.
In any case, I bet you can't just call up and get a review mo
Well... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
5:51 for battery life is phenomenal, but you are buying integrated graphics and a 1024x768 display. But this thing is aimed at desktop work and scored above average for business content creation. I'm still shocked by a notebook computer that can manage nearly 6 hours from its batteries...
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Ohh, you're wrong about that. (Score:5, Insightful)
The fact is, I'm always where there's power available. I don't need to use the machine on an airplane for 6 hours. I don't need to use my computer on a park bench all day.
Most of the guys I work with do the same thing. Our machines don't have the best battery life but it's good enough for the long meetings or logging in to check e-mail from the road. That extra two or three hours time on the battery just wouldn't matter.
I'd rather have a really powerful notebook that I can use as a desktop replacement for work that I can take home with me then a slower unit that has longer batttery life.
I'm not the only one that feels this way.
Re:Ohh, you're wrong about that. (Score:3, Interesting)
If you can get the power requirements low enough, I'll take 10 years please
http://www.physorg.com/news4081.html [physorg.com]
screw the wall outlet I want a laptop where you have to replace the system before the battery dies
before someone say's 'but what about the radiation' if it's safe enough to put inside someone's pace maker, then it's can be designed safe enough to build into a laptop..
Re:Ohh, you're wrong about that. (Score:2)
10 years would be nice =)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
I would say a good fraction (possibly even a majority) of notebook users just want a small computer they can grab and move around easily. Most of these users really don't care about battery life at all.
I'd prefer an Intel laptop (Score:5, Funny)
No wonder an Intel unit was the winner (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:No wonder an Intel unit was the winner (Score:4, Interesting)
http://www.gamepc.com/labs/view_content.asp?id=a6
A PM @ 2.13GHz performs exactly the same as a A64 @ 2.4GHz, And it consumes a lot less power. PM's on the mobile side are just better chips. If you're doing media creation the scales tip towards AMD, but for business apps, and typical home consumer use it's the PM's battery life that makes it so popular.
-manno
Re:No wonder an Intel unit was the winner (Score:2)
Here is a head to head test with laptops.
http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/hardware/notebooks/0, 39001748,39242904-2,00.htm [cnet.com]
BAPCo MobileMark2002 battery life (in minutes)
Turion 2.0GHz: 197
P-M 2.0GHz: 203
3% battery life = "lot less"?
Pricing (Score:5, Insightful)
If you want to see more for yourself - look at:
http://www.newegg.com/ [newegg.com]
vs
http://www.auspcmarket.com.au/ [auspcmarket.com.au]
Re:Pricing (Score:5, Informative)
Australian dollars currently trade at $1.30AU for every $1US.
XFX Geforce 7800 at Newegg is:
$574 dollars2 E16814150100 [newegg.com]
Link: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N8
XFX Geforce 7800 at AusPCMarket is:
$924 dollarsh p?input%5Bproduct_code%5D=VI-11PVT70F-256&input%5B category_id%5D=1339 [auspcmarket.com.au]
Link: http://www.auspcmarket.com.au/show_product_info.p
$574 x 1.3 = $746.20
There is a markup, of about 20 percent. Not 150-200% as you have stated, however.
Re:Pricing (Score:2)
So the price you should be comparing to is the AU$840 one for a 12.5% markup.
Then there's a 5% import duty as well, but I think that's calculated based on what the importer paid for it not what they then resell it for - but lets pretend not. In which case $840 includes a 5% tariff and hence is really $800 for a 7.2% markup. Of couse the US probably has an
Re:Pricing (Score:2)
Of course you can just order from overseas, but if it's AU$500+ you'll get billed for the GST component before customs let you have it.
In the US you tend not to, since sales tax is state level so you avoid retailers in your own state and forget to include it on your state tax return - but in Australi
Re:Pricing (Score:2)
There also might be issues I'm unaware of such as higher shipping and a high tax on imports.
Re:Pricing (Score:4, Interesting)
Then again, the US is a far bigger purchaser of this sort of stuff, so they probably get a bulk purchase discount or something.
Better pricing (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Pricing (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Pricing (Score:2)
For example, Newegg has no warehouse in Colorado - so I don't pay any tax at all.
You're supposed to pay the "use tax", but no one does.
Re:Pricing (Score:2)
Re:Also compare with desktops (Score:2)
There are costs with making laptops that don't exist for desktops. Fabbing for power efficiency is more expensive. If it weren't more expensive, all those technologies would be in desktops too. Laptop drives have to be able to withstand many more starts and stops than desktop drives. The displays must be extremely thin, less than 1/4" thick and a lot more power efficient, so you can't just compare that c
Perhaps AMD-powered Notebooks have... (Score:4, Informative)
Then again, maybe the retailers in Australia just don't provide the same support for AMD as for Intel. Lawsuit, anyone? *removes tongue from cheek*
Wanted! (Score:2, Interesting)
In all likelyhood, I'll have to settle for an Apptel Powerbook and give up on Turion/NVidia. This assumes, of course, that they offer a new display on the 17". I just hope they make it out of something besides soft metal in the next revision.
Not quite that for which you asked, but it's close (Score:2)
I have one of them myself, and have been very happy with it so far.
Re:Not quite that for which you asked, but it's cl (Score:2)
Accepting ATI is not an option
Re:Not quite that for which you asked, but it's cl (Score:2)
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
What you want has been available in an Apple Powerbook for quite a while. And will soon be powered by an Intel CPU.
Is it the price of the current Powerbook that bothers you? If so then you should state that you are looking in a particular price range.
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
Plus, there are architectural apps with no equal in the Linux or Mac world that I use, and I also use QuickBooks.
Also, the powerbook does
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
You had me up till that point... I also want such a beast, but c'mon, a full numeric keypad on a *laptop*? (It's rare enough that I use the keypad on my full desktop keyboard.)
I've seen a few such beasts, and they're freakin' huge!
Now, I'd definitely go for a laptop that had full-size, rationally-placed arrow keys, pageup/pagedown, etc.... or even ones that are tucked away in odd places or reduced to half-size status (yes, I'm talking to YOU, Mr. Apple Powerbook Keyboard Designer Guy)
HP ZD series (Score:2)
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
I'd still prefer a dual-core Turion, but I don't believe those are out just yet. I don't want to be burdened with ATI's
Not my experience... (Score:2)
Take a sheet of thick aluminum (aircraft grade or not) and bang it with a hammer. It's going to dent, bend, and be nearly impossible to return to a flat surface without re-rolling it. Take a sheet of thick plastic, and bang on it for as long as you want to. It's going to maintain the sa
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
From my Mac OS experiences I can easily imagine why someone would like to do that *ducks*
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
I spent an age trying to get my Toshiba laptop working with an Orinoco PCMCIA card. In the end I had to give up on Gentoo (which I use for all my other machines) and install Ubuntu. But even that is more than a little bollocks. It works but I can't switch in and out of promiscuous at will. Once Kismet has been started I have to reboot to be able to connect to any networks. Plus I have bett
Re:Wanted! (Score:2)
Wow. That sounds like my exact situation as well. I can't afford a new laptop, so here is what I did: use the word "any" (all lowercase
Offtopic possibly, but I just have to say... (Score:5, Funny)
...serious bonus points for using the word "humdinger" in a tech review.
problems only applicable down under? (Score:3, Insightful)
Aesthetics? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Aesthetics? (Score:2, Interesting)
ASUS in Italy, not in USA (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:ASUS in Italy, not in USA (Score:2, Informative)
ASUS make iBooks? (Score:3, Interesting)
Wrong priorities (Score:3, Interesting)
HP makes Athlon64 notebooks... (Score:4, Informative)
Cheers,
Re:HP makes Athlon64 notebooks... (Score:2, Interesting)
Needless to say, she spent the requisite time getting the situation handled. First, she tried the "Live Chat" on HP's support page. The person who first had contact with her appea
I built an AMD 64 laptop-just two weeks ago (Score:2, Informative)
There was no shortage of bare AMD 64 laptops, the package arrived in one day.
I had lots of spare components, I only had to pay about $750 (CA Tax and shipping included). I did not have to buy a CPU,HD, DVD-writer or a wireless card, all these components existed already in our lab. I had no spare laptop
Re:I built an AMD 64 laptop-just two weeks ago (Score:2)
Just looked over at coboc.com, and didn't find any AMD Uniwill laptops, just Intel ones. Where and which one did you find?
Some hot temps there... (Score:5, Interesting)
One thing I'd like to see taken into account in these types of tests is how hot laptops such as this perform outside the lab. In Australia, 37C temps are not uncommon outdoors during summer. If this Tecra tested that high in a lab, how will it hold up outside in that kind of heat? I mean, half the benefit of having a laptop is being able to use it outside the nice, comfortably AC'ed office. If I got BSODs due to thermal problems, I'd be pissed.
It should be noted that these are not laptops... (Score:2)
http://hardware.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=1420
So, no, you wouldn't want this sitting in your lap, as they aren't laptops.
(Note also that the article only once mentions 'laptop', on the first page, in reference to typical application of a particular chipset.)
Re:Some hot temps there... (Score:2)
There are a lot of reasons why I would need something that operates in those temperatures (which I don't consider to be a big ask), and I doubt some of these hotter models are up to the task (some of the cooler ones might be). If all I could do with
Re:Some hot temps there... (Score:2)
Re:Some hot temps there... (Score:2)
Re:Some hot temps there... (Score:2)
Please note, I'm not an expert on notebook cooling, I was largely making a pointer to the Intel specs. However, if I had a notebook getting that hot, I'd probably take it back if still under warranty; otherwise, I'd probably have the cover off and use a calibrated probe. I'd wonder whether it's actually getting that hot... perhaps you could try tracking the temperature from a thermally cold start to see if the m
Tiny.com (Score:2, Informative)
i'd still (Score:3, Insightful)
Uh...? (Score:3, Informative)
HJ
Only vendor submitted laptops? (Score:5, Insightful)
So they only test laptops they are given? Why should we trust them to have an unbiased opinion or that they have actually done the best AMD/Intel comparision possible in that case? They should buy commercial laptops just like any individual or admin would do and test those, not just what they can get given to them by potential advertisers.
Re:Only vendor submitted laptops? (Score:2, Redundant)
I want my AMD. (Score:4, Interesting)
I'm never switching back, never, never, never. I need to get my hands on a PPC PowerBook soon, because the Intel jump at Apple concerns me...
Re:I want my AMD. (Score:2)
So, have you any reason to really attribute this to the CPU? Rather sounds like cheap stuff overall in your work box.
And, yes, my next desktop machine will probably be a dual-core AMD, just like I might stick to Pentium M-based stuff in laptops for a while. Those are nice, whil
My issue is with the little fans- not the power (Score:2)
The 80mm fans are quiet now for about 10 bucks.
The 120mm fans are dead quiet.
But the 50mm fans are very noisy and induce a lot of case vibration because they have to turn so fast. These are usually on the chip set. I have been unable to find a solution. Does anyone else have one?
Re:My issue is with the little fans- not the power (Score:2)
Re:My issue is with the little fans- not the power (Score:2)
My solution is to just shop around until you find a motherboard without the little chipset fan. I hate them - not only are they noisy but those little chipset and graphics card fans seem to be the most unreliable too.
An unaddressed option... (Score:2, Interesting)
Sure, it's warm, but it's also sitting on my coffee table, my kitchen table, my Panera table, my desk, or my m
Where's the Verb? (Score:2)
What for? A pissing contest?
Shameless Advertisement - Acer Ferrari 4005 (Score:2)
I haven't had a chance to play with a Ferrari yet, but I sell TravelMate's and Aspire's all the time. They're well built, have excellent LCD screens, and an extended warranty only costs you $99 for 2 years of additional coverage.
We don't sell outside of the United States, sorry Nigeria!
Here's a fun test: Call Dell (Score:4, Interesting)
Call Dell and ask for an AMD based machine.
You'll get a very scripted answer of how AMD suffers compatibility problems, overheating, and is slower than Intel.
I asked if AMD had any chips that were faster than Intel (you know like the 64 bit dual core CPU's which every gamer knows well).
The answer? "No, AMD is really a second rate product and is not reliable". He followed with "Nobody is looking for AMD. They are really very junky."
Amazing! "Junky!" One must wonder why then is Intel now copying AMD's "junky" architecture?
Apparently no one told this guy that HP, Sun Microsystems, Lenovo (Thinkpad), and Hitatchi all went AMD within days after the lawsuit was filed.
AMD Lawsuit (Score:2)
Prediction: Intel gets their ass handed to them over the AMD lawsuit. First in Europe, then (after another year of wrangling) in the U.S.
Just wait until Dell gets subpoenaed. That's when the real fun will begin.
The different AMD power specs (Score:2)
I must've looked through pretty much every single model from HP, Acer and Asus (and a few others) and could not find a single one with an MT processor - is there a reason for this, or did I just miss it? A couple of reviews mentioned that there isn't much of a price difference betw
Re:Pentium M processor good for desktop (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Pentium M processor good for desktop (Score:2)
Re:Pentium M processor good for desktop (Score:2)
Even if I do get a 3700 and overclock it, the boost would not be enough to make a whole new machine worthwile.
Re:Here's what I'm looking for... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I'm looking for... (Score:2)
Re:Here's what I'm looking for... (Score:2)
I'll second that.... I find the touchpads nearly unusable. Though, to be fair, trackpoints are also in the just-barely-usable range IMHO, so I end up carrying a mouse around most of the time...
I guess it's time for someone to invent a better laptop-oriented-mouse-substitute.
Re:Here's what I'm looking for... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Intel is better then AMD... for Linux. (Score:2)
Better how? If ease of locating and installing graphics drivers is your basis of evaluating CPU's then
But since my Linux box is (like most others I imagine) a server and not a game machine
For those looking for a faster CPU with superior architecture (typically how I like to evaluate a CPU) there's no contest.
AMD's 64-bit dual-core architecture spanks Intel.