Wireless Security By The Gallon 216
prostoalex writes "The next effort to improve wireless security might involve a trip to Home Depot. Force Field Wireless sells buckets of aluminum and copped-laced paint designed to prevent the 802.11 packets from escaping the building, Information Week reports. The article also talks about the Firce Field's pitch to the government in order to improve the homeland security, but the only governments that got interested in anti-Wi-Fi paint were from the Middle East. According to the products page, they also sell the brush sets." Easier than wallpaper, or moving into an old house.
Works great on the scalp! (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Works great on the scalp! (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Works great on the scalp! (Score:2)
What good is that then?
Re:Works great on the scalp! (Score:2)
Pssst! Wanna buy some aluminium siding?
No need for hats anymore (Score:2)
Re:No need for hats anymore (Score:2)
Re:Works great on the scalp! (Score:2)
Re:Works great on the scalp! (Score:3, Funny)
Boy... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Boy... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Boy... (Score:2)
What's it relating to?
Re:Boy... (Score:5, Informative)
"TEMPEST was "invented" in 1918 when Herbert Yardley and his staff of the Black Chamber were engaged by the U.S. Army to develop methods to detect, intercept, and exploit combat telephones and covert radio transmitters. The initial research identified that "normal unmodified equipment" was allowing classified information to be passed to the enemy through a variety of technical weaknesses. A classified program was then created to develop methods to suppress these "compromising emanations". However, the actual acronym known as TEMPEST was only coined in the late 60's and early 70's (and is now considered an obsolete term, which has since, been replaced by the phrase "Emissions Security" or EMSEC).
TEMPEST and it's associated disciplines involve designing circuits to minimize the amount of "compromising emanations" and to apply appropriate shielding, grounding, and bonding. These disciplines also include methods of radiation screening, alarms, isolation circuits/devices, and similar areas of equipment engineering.
TEMPEST disciplines typically involve eliminating or reducing the transients caused by a communication signal and the resulting harmonics. These signals and their harmonics could allow the original signal to be reconstructed and analyzed."
Link:
http://www.tscm.com/TSCM101tempest.html
The idea is that EM fields generated my, say, your monitor can be intercepted and used to reconstruct what's being displayed on the screen.
Re:Boy... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Boy... (what is TEMPEST?) (Score:3, Interesting)
It is a countermeasure to "Van Ek Phreaking", the blow-'em-away demonstration of which was a cart with a monitor and $100 worth of Radio-Shack parts that displayed the pictures that were on monitors in the curtained-off "non-disclosure-only" areas at a trade show, as it was wheeled by the booths.
Re:Boy... (Score:2)
Home Depot (Score:5, Funny)
The next effort to improve wireless security might involve a trip to Home Depot. Force Field Wireless sells buckets of aluminum and copped-laced paint designed to prevent the 802.11 packets from escaping the building,
Lowe's [journalnow.com] should consider carrying that product.
Re:Home Depot (Score:2)
Lowe's should consider USING that product. Or for that matter, any better security than WEP.
TSS Covered It Last Month... (Score:3, Interesting)
Also, I hope they meant copper-laced paint, otherwise some police officers might want to speak with them. Hell, the bobbies may STILL want a word...
GTRacer
- It's lame joke day
Re:TSS Covered It Last Month... (Score:3, Funny)
Perhaps someone was sniffing a little of this paint, hmmm?
Re:TSS Covered It Last Month... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:TSS Covered It Last Month... (Score:2)
I was thinking of the exact same episode as soon as I saw the article. Didn't Alex get some of the paint on his hand after he read all the precautions on the can? Plus considering the amount of paint needed to cover your entire house with that goo, it was pretty pricy for a barely working product.
Good Old Fashioned Fix (Score:3, Funny)
Ok... wow... misread (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Ok... wow... misread (Score:3, Funny)
-the Slink
"One Ring to Rule them all..."
Re:Ok... wow... misread (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Ok... wow... misread (Score:2, Funny)
New book: Hacking Wireless Security by Gollum -"What have you got in your packets???"
What else does it block? (Score:5, Interesting)
This might me more of a pain than a solution
Re:What else does it block? (Score:2)
Oh, and who the hell modded the parent post "off-topic"???
Re:What else does it block? (Score:4, Informative)
Re:What else does it block? (Score:2)
(I'm not the bearer of that sig.)
Thats a good question. Should karma reward only insightful posts or should it reward people who start insightful discussions as well?
Honestly, 50% of the trolls never get a response, and probably 50% of the responses are likewise trollish and don't get modded up.
Re:What else does it block? (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:What else does it block? (Score:5, Interesting)
I've heard cellphones that beep repeatedly to let you know you're out of service range.
Of course, in a theatre situation, maybe that would remind the person to shut it off, or at least provide a homing beacon for those that want to shut it off for him before the movie starts.
Good old.. (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Fellow Citizen could you help (Score:2)
Please report to the nearest termination terminal and remember, the Computer is your friend.
Be happy or be deemed a traitor to the Computer you Commie mutant!
Well... (Score:5, Insightful)
Not to mention that even to most fancy cable management system will be less work and cost than painting all walls+ceiling (and what about the floor if you arent in the basement?)...
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Like you said, though... far easier to install some cat5.
Re:Well... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Well... (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Do you also want to prevent others from talking in a foreign language while in the restaurant? If not, some places can ask people to keep silent or talk quietly, but otherwise a phone call is no different from talking to someone in person.
Re:Well... (Score:2)
Many have started to use 'cell phone jammers [google.com]', which are illegal in the U.S. [newhousenews.com] and I believe that it's a good law, but I do respect people's wish to create 'quite zones' on their private property. The previously
Re:Well... (Score:5, Interesting)
Using Cat5 over wireless is a massive security improvement in itself, also available from the Home Depot. Cable ends and crimpers are available too, and at a cost far less than the paint. I suspect the paint is for suckering in people who think 802.11 is the only thing there is. The rest of us who actually care and want to save some money will continue to run cables.
Every time I see something about "wireless security" I always wonder why people spend so damn much money (like the paint) and effort (new encryption schemes) on it when if you really cared about security you wouldn't be using it in the first place. "Wireless security" is good to stop someone from casually using your access point, but is no substitution for real security and encryption.
Even then, people pick stupid or easy to remember passwords for their base stations, or open the window of their wireless-defeating painted room, thereby making it all a moot point.
Re:Well... (Score:2)
This paint would also reduce the threat of someone sneaking a Wifi access point into the building to spy on you from a distance even if you only have a wired network.
Re:Well... (Score:2)
I use Cat5 over wireless, not run it over wireless.
Although a local grammar Nazi would be able to tell if my use of the phrase "Using Cat5 over wireless" instead of "Using Cat5 instead of wireless" is correct. I meant the word "over" in the former to be used as a preposition.
Re:Well... (Score:2)
It's a great crapfilter.
Re:Well... (Score:2)
They should put a Faraday Cage over Slashdot
And what about windows? (Score:2)
You'd still be better off with grounded wire mesh and plaster in an older house if you wanted to imitate your tin foil hat.
Re:And what about windows? (Score:2)
We just this summer got a new sliding glass door installed. As the guy was giving us his pitch he was telling us about its resistance to heating up a room due to sunlight. One thing he mentiond was there were aluminium flecks in the glass to bounce off sunlight, I made him repeat that part. I have always wanted to try wifi across it and see what would happen. So in answer to your question : buy new windows?
Sera
Re:And what about windows? (Score:2)
Stating the obvious (Score:2)
Can you put an RFID tag on a product such as this? What if someone painted over the RFID/antitheft tags with this paint?
-ted
or fill the wall cavities (Score:2)
Paint Chips (Score:2)
Re:Paint Chips (Score:2)
Dong, Where is my automobile? (Score:2, Insightful)
Uh, it is kind of paranoid.
And it's surely no substitute for a robust encryption scheme.
Since it's commercial in nature, how many modern offices can really do without cell phones and pagers?
Oh, and 64 bucks seems ridiculously expensive for latex paint with aluminum and copper filings mixed in.
This seems like one of those "theres a sucker born
... Hmmmm ... (Score:3, Insightful)
The burning question I have (and hopefully a smarter-person-than-I can clue me in) is how is this going to affect my AM/FM/SW radio reception inside my house? It almost seems like a rooftop antenna would become a must-have, assuming that the blockage of signal would keep all those friendly informational radio waves from getting INTO my house.
Re:... Hmmmm ... (Score:2)
Which is to say, this isn't much more difficult to do than stapling up wire mesh. Heck, if one puts up wall-paper, then putting wire-mesh behind it shouldn't be too much more difficult and would be much cheaper than this "paint."
Or, go the extra step: what happens when one tires of the faraday cage and wants to allow signals in from the outside/let signal out? What would one do THEN?!?
But as other
Wrong idea (Score:5, Funny)
"It was my concept along with my colleague, Diane Lopez," says Wray, a former network engineer with Networks Associates. "We knew of people inundated with interference on their wireless systems. In fact, Diane, in her apartment, could find eight wireless networks around her. She needed to shield herself."
No, she needed to stop wasting money on broadband and mooch off her neighbors.
fire hazard (Score:2, Insightful)
Legal to sell in some states? (Score:5, Interesting)
non-toxic? (Score:2)
Re:non-toxic? (Score:2)
of course it's toxic when it's still wet!! but after it dries it's encapsulated and safe for everyday use.
Environmental Effects (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Environmental Effects (Score:2)
Could be useful (Score:2)
That said, this could be a useful way of protecting against unintentional transmissions. Our computers are doing an awful lot of radiating, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if there was enough leakage to provide an effective cryptographic side-channel.
You have questions, I have answers. (Score:5, Informative)
A. Yes, to some extent. The metalic paint does effectively impede radio signals however, it is not 100% effective. Some signal may still leak through the paint also, untreated windows and doors will allow the signal to leak. None the less, signal propagation is greatly reduced by the paint, which was the primary reason for its development.
Q. What about cordless phones?
A. This paint will affect most radio signals including corless and cell phones, AM/FM radio, broadcast TV and more. The overall effect will vary depending on paint application quality, signal frequency and strength, as well as other factors.
Q. Is this paint a health risk?
A. Copper based paint, commonly used in marine applications, is a known health risk and environmental hazard. While there is little data available for aluminum based paints, there do not appear to be significant health risks at this time. This does not mean that there aren't health risks associated with aluminum based paints.
Re:You have questions, I have answers. (Score:2, Informative)
Re:You have questions, I have answers. (Score:2)
Just ask the deodorant manufacturers about the potential link between their product and early-onset Alzheimer disease (the majority of such products include aluminum, one exception is Old Spice). Otherwise, we know aluminum is neurotoxic in animal models. I'm not saying there's a definite problem, but current studies have provided some controversial results (so what's new).
already in effect where I work (Score:2)
Prolly won't work (Score:2)
There'll be some attenuation, sure, but don't forget the signal you get after going through one of these painted-on Faraday cages also depends on how strong the original signal was. Even if you put steel plates up if you blast the signal strongly enough something will get through.
Case in point: a few weeks ago I took a regular ol' D-Link 802.11b router, took its antenna off, and threw it in a steel toolbox. Closed the lid, weighed it down. I was still able to get a halfway decent signal from more than
Re:Prolly won't work (Score:2)
Re:Prolly won't work (Score:2)
Something like that. :)
I wanted to try and keep the signal leakage down, and I was worried that the lid would keep open a crack with the power cable sticking out of it. Weighting it helped keep the lid tight and (I think) helped reduce leakage through the toolbox.Is it as good as Stucco and plaster? (Score:2, Interesting)
My neighborhood, a in a new development, is full of houses made from sticks, vinyl and wallboard. I can easily reach anywhere from 6 to 10 APs from just about anywhere in my house (and only 2 are mine.)
Re:Is it as good as Stucco and plaster? (Score:4, Informative)
If you ever see it installed, they (usually) first staple up a thick metal mesh, which holds the plaster in place. Wood lath was the status quo in the really olden days, before steel became cheaper than hardwood strips.
Norm Abrahms goes wardriving in this weeks episode of This Old House!
Re:Is it as good as Stucco and plaster? (Score:2)
Like this ol Linksys here on the receptionists desk we use for a paper weight. Can't connect to it unless your laptop is with in 10' of it.
Same laptop has no probs connecting to other WAPS at quite nice distances (parking lot 3 floors down as one)
OT: glowing letters (Score:3, Interesting)
A few years ago I had a metallic paint pen. If you burnt the paper that had markings from this pen on it, the ink would glow brightly for a brief time before going out. It was a neat effect, glowing words.
Now I'm trying to re-create this effect for a film project, and I've had no luck. I've bought out the pen section at staples, tried various metallic paint pens, and none of them do this.
The idea is to have the credits written on a piece of paper, totally unlit, so all you see is darkness. As the flame creeps across the page, the letters will glow as the flame hits them. How could I do this?
Re:OT: glowing letters (Score:3, Funny)
Easy fix if security is an issue. (Score:2)
Lead Paint Anyone? (Score:2)
Sir. The radar, sir. It appears to be... jammed. (Score:2)
But he'll sure as hell let the U.S. drop it on them. I foresee a new wave on non-lethal radar seeking missiles with latex payloads.
Got an ICBM headed at you? No problem, just spray the area of its path with a fine latex mist. These guys just put the Bush missile-de
Good (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Good (Score:2)
Seems dopey to me (Score:2)
Aluminum siding? (Score:2)
A wee paint layer with some metal in it won't do diddly if my 50s aluminum siding doesn't.
Too much *and* too little (Score:3, Insightful)
This is too much protection for Joe Casual User who will pissed at bad cellphone reception, bad TV reception, bad coreless phone. Or downright ineffectiveness if they don't also paint the ceiling, floor and windows. (Note on business plan: Shit! Windows???!? What are we going to do about windows? )
Thumbs down.
Re:Too much *and* too little (Score:2)
Surely they must be safe, they're digitally signed and everything...
Safety.. (Score:2)
Why not just build sheetrock with a wire mesh built into it?
Directional Antennae? (Score:2)
G4 Tech TV (Score:2)
Didn't Screensavers pre-redesign do a bit on this?
Alex was a loose cannon, slamming advertisers. Note that the new version has no studio audience and no woo-hoo guys.
So... (Score:2)
Fiber Optics (Score:2)
Other options (Score:5, Informative)
There's Hospital Quality [rfi-ind.com.au] shielding done with aluminum foil, and more serious shielding [rfi-ind.com.au] of both E and H fields for MRI machines. I won't even go into the RF-sealed doors...
If you're concerned about magnetic fields, then Mu Metal [google.com] is the stuff. Just don't bend any of the Hydrogen-annealed variety. You can get sheet and tape [lessemf.com] in small quantifies from these folks, who by the way also offer "Personal Protection Devices [lessemf.com] (silver-impregnated fiber baseball caps, not tinfoil hats, please)
For sealing over the gaps, don't forget 3M 1181 Copper Tape [google.com], which features electrically-conducting adhesive, but only specifies 80dB isolation at 30MHz-1GHz.
But my favorite so far is Metal Foam [metalfoam.net], which reminds me of the almost weightless foamed glass Aerogel [nasa.gov] that was a announced a few years ago... Foamed aluminum is available commercially in 2x2ft sheets from from Austria, Alulight [alulight.com]. They claim 40dB isolation [alulight.com] in the 2Ghz range and over 100dB to 140dB [alulight.com] in the 10Mhz-1GHz range, plus excellent sound isolation, structural, and fire safety properties. What's not to like? Anybody know where the get this stuff in the US? Reade [reade.com] seems out of my range, but I'll ask them.
Paradigm shift: Secure networks not shield them (Score:2, Interesting)
Instead of blocking 802.11b/g frequencies with wall paint (along with cell-phones, radios and key-less car remotes) can't we use what's in place? You can design a router to restrict traffic based on hardware MAC address and design your DHCP servers to assign by MAC address. Create some scripts to synchronize your ro
Sensitive buildings are already shielded (Score:2)
but the only governments that got interested in anti-Wi-Fi paint were from the Middle East.
This is because at least in the US (and probably in most civilized countries) buildings with sensitive information are already shielded and have been for decades. I've been in a couple of those by virtue of living in the DC area - sucks when your cell phone doesn't work.
Homeowners be very careful with this (Score:2, Informative)
Asbestos was banned when fiberglass was available as an alternate solution to insulation. Fiberglass has been listed as a carcinogen in California. But I'll bet it won't be listed as a carcinogen in the rest of the US until a suitable replacement for it is found.
That's how environmental law generally works. When you have a replacement, you ban the old stuff.
Re:Homeowners be very careful with this (Score:4, Informative)
fyi, Old Spice is aluminum free.
Fire! (Score:2, Insightful)
Spelling? (Score:2)
Seriously, how hard is it to simply spell correctly, or if you can't, to proof your post before submitting it?
Re:Does this work at all? (Score:2, Informative)
Check out the story of Sir John Franklin, who tried to lead an expedition in Canada to find the northwest passage, back in the olden days. They found the party dead, having abandoned their ship, but they took ridiculous items with them, like an old dresser, instead of food and supplies that could have kept them alive.
The story goes they all went insane from the lead used in the canned food they were eating.
Re:Freedom (Score:2)
Re:USA Government has already dealt with this (Score:2)
I'd think the biggest purchasers of this paint would be stores and movie theaters... That'd be a cruel/cool trick to play on moviegoers rather than jamming the signals, just paint the walls with