Sharp To Ship New HD-equipped Zaurus In Japan 181
ctid writes "On 10th November, Sharp will release its new Zaurus PDA. The SL-C3000 includes a 4GB hard drive, a 416MHz Intel XScale PXA270 CPU and 64MB of RAM. All of that in a package weighing 298g! There is no news as to whether Sharp will release this ludicrously desirable toy in the West, but I'm not hopeful personally. Maybe we can rely on suppliers like dynamism.com (in the USA) or shirtpocket.co.uk (in the UK) to help us out?"
no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:5, Interesting)
I don't understand their decision not to include wireless into the device. Yeah you could add it with a CF card but that's an added expense and something else to carry w/you. Plenty of businesses now offer wireless service (Old Chicago, Kinkos, coffee houses, and a bunch of bars come to mind) and I would certainly think that most people would consider wifi a necessary feature.
The base of the unit above the keyboard looks a bit thick. I wonder if it is meant to be held in your hands and you type w/your thumbs or if it is to sit on a surface and you type normally. Personally I prefer holding a device in my hands and typing but that's just me.
I am now, more than ever, interested in some sort of "palm top" device for use in my home. I love being able to walk around and do what I need to do online from wherever. Even a laptop seems too bulky for me these days. At a little over 10.5 ounces this would be the perfect device for that purpose.
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
As for the ergono
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
Note that it's not user-installable, so if you don't get it installed when you order the iBook you have to use a USB dongle.
Not everyone Wants Wifi (Score:5, Insightful)
Not *everyone* wants wifi.
Most people do. But there are some people who work in enviornments where they are prohibited from bringing wifi devices. So, there is a tradeoff there. Also, some people want a lower cost, and would like Wifi, but also want a lower cost device as well, and would be willing to buy the device now, and add wifi later.
From a manufacturer's perspective, it is better to have that customer buy your product, and then purchase Wifi later, then it is to lose that customer to some other manufacturer based on them having a lower cost device. If people really want Wifi, then, simply create a bundle that lets people purchase your PDA along with the CF card that gives them WIFI, and then the problem is solved. That way, you can market your product to both sets of people and straddle the two segments of customers.
It's a little kludgy. But, I don't think it's such a horrible strategy.
Randy
Re:Not everyone Wants Wifi (Score:2)
Well, you're prob
Re:Not everyone Wants Wifi (Score:2)
Who cares if some people don't want wifi? (Score:2)
Who cares if some people don't want wifi?
Wasn't this why they sold multiple versions of the SL-6000 in the first place?
I would rather see them release four near-identical devices... a version with/without wifi, and a version with/without Bluetooth.
And speaking of Bluetooth, the lack of that in a PDA really makes this so-called "new" Zaurus look pretty fucking old.
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:5, Insightful)
In Japan, many devices have both SD and CF slots. The CF slot can take memory, but its main purpose is to add connectivity. Wi-Fi limits one to sitting around in a hotspot. Japan has better solutions: all three major carriers have 3G cards with thoughputs of up to 2Mbps. DDI and bMobile offer PHS-based cellular solutions up to 384kbps at flat rates. Connected users expect far more in the way of ubiquitous connectivity than Wi-Fi allows. The majority of the population, for example, sends and receives most of its email via cellphone rather than computer.
So PCs have Wi-Fi, PDA users tend to go with one of the cellular solutions.
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
This is why I wonder not so much about the lack of wifi, but I wonder why there is no Bluetooth. Why should I have to slot in a card, when I could be doing the communication wirelessly to the phone I already have in my pocket?
And better yet, because you only have two card slots, if you want both Bluetooth and wifi, such as was available in the Zaurus SL-6000W, you get to choose: either (a) take up both slots, or (b) switch cards constantly and lose one of your CF cards.
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:3, Informative)
How about (assuming you mean 802.11*): desire to have battery life longer than fifteen minutes? There's just not enough room in the tiny little thing for a big enough battery to make wifi useful.
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
Re:no wifi? Bummer. But 10.5 ounces! Woo! (Score:2)
I call bullshit on your assertion.
Welcome to 2002! (Score:5, Interesting)
"...416MHz Intel XScale PXA270 processor backed by 64MB of SDRAM and 16MB of Flash ROM."
64 ram and 16 rom??? No Wi-fi or Bluetooth built in? How many of us actually use infrared on a regular basis?
Sorry, Sharp; you're doing all of us a disservice by not promoting Linux as a device that can compete with comparable Windows Mobile-based devices.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Not being Japanese it's hard for me to comment on how well this fits into their perception of a modern device on the wireless angle. But, I think the 4G of storage needs to be considered since much of our perception of the storage space on a PDA is related to all the data stored in that RAM for current products. If the 64M RAM and 16 M ROM is just OS and swap, this is more than enough for a Linux based device. I'm sure many readers have run a network E
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Sure it is. I had a 5 GB PCMCIA HD in my Jornada 720 PDA back in 2002. And the whole package- Jornada 720 and 5 GB HD didn't cost the $750 USD that this Zaurus does in Japan.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
I was shopping for a PDA recently and I seriously considered a Zaurus. But the lack of wireless, the high price and the lack of sales / support in Europe put me right off the idea.
I bought an iPaq (which I don't like for other reasons), but it cost half the price of a Zaurus and does bluetooth and wireless. I even expect to be able to make it run Linux one day. But first and foremost it is my PDA, which includes doing
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
I would have upgraded my Vx to another Palm if one had a comparable feature set, but none does.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:5, Insightful)
Sharp Japan is doing the Japanese market a big service by not including WiFi, allowing Japanese users to buy their own cellular data cards (AirH, PHS, etc, with data rates at something like $20/month for 128 kbit) which are already subscribed to a cellular service.
Sharp USA will probably make different decisions. Sharp Japan has the Japanese market to think about. Please respect them for that.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Yay for Sharp USA.
Nonsense (Score:2)
Please think of the children... exactly what the hell are you talking about? Respect them for not serving their customers in the US? Decisions for the Japanese market are mutually exclusive to decisions in the US market. Sharp is either being stupid or bribed by M$ to stay out of the market. Either way, it's anti-consumer.
Re:Nonsense (Score:2)
Good god man, you think companies exist solely to serve your every whim and that they have a responsibility to do so? Grow up! If Sharp thought there were a lot of profit to be made in
Re:Nonsense (Score:2)
Grow up yourself and stop telling people to grow up! You are trying to make the argument that companies selling consumer products should not try to please consumers? This makes no sense.
The fact is that any PDA without Wifi and BlueTooth is a day late and dollar short in Japan or in the US.
I think you should really grow up and stop acting like a two year old!
Re:Nonsense (Score:2)
Err...no. The point was that the Japanese division is releasing the product in Japan to best serve that market. If Japan has multiple standards for Wi-Fi, it would make *NO* sense to lock the product into a single standard and close out the others. The PDA does support Wi-Fi; it just doesn't include Wi-Fi.
A further point was that most Japanese electronics companies release in Japan well bef
Say no to redundancy. (Score:2)
"Allowing" people to buy their own data cards is great... that way you suck a few tens of thousands more yen out of the consumer. Way to go, Sharp.
I would much rather be using a built-in Bluetooth radio to communicate with my perfectly good phone.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:1)
I've owned:
Palm IIIc
Handspring Visor
Apple Newton
One of the first HP Jornadas
I'm currently using an Audiovox PPC4100 smartphone.
I've also used a friend's Zaurus many times... works great for what it did, but hopelessly out of date today.
I'd say I'm educated enough to know what I'm talking about. If you think Mobile 2003 is bloated, you're just uneducated.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Indeed, smart and efficient programming can work wonders.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:1)
There's no reason Sharp couldn't have made a better device that supported wi-fi, bluetooth, etc., in a similarly-sized package.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
It does support wi-fi and bluetooth, just not out of the box.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:4, Interesting)
The Sony Clie I purchased not too long in order that I could actually use the damn thing without having to charge it every other day, and which paid for itself by having a fully working bluetooth implementation that was only marginally more expensive than a supported (by third party projects) bluetooth expansion card itself, is miles better. Sadly they're discontinued, but I'd still buy a Palm machine over either of these, Linux or not.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:4, Informative)
Crappy software? I wouldn't know, I've never used Sharp's Zaurus stuff (they have Opera? Since when?). I use pdaXrom [pdaxrom.org], although OpenZaurus [openzaurus.org] looks interesting if they ever port it to mine (SL-C860)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
According to the OpenZaurus page [openzaurus.org] their new 3.5.1 release works with your PDA:
If I were you, I'd read the release notes before upgrading. There were enough unresolved issues that I'm choosing to wait to upgrade from OZ 3.3.5.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Indeed. You may have a later revision than the parent did. Your experience echoes mine (with standard PDA use, I can go for one or two weeks without a recharge; I get about 8h if I'm playing mp3s with the screen off).
That said, that's all with the 3.10 ROM (I have an SL-5500). The 2.28 or whatever it was ROM left the wifi card on all the time, and was also just not nearly as power-conscious as the 3.10 ROM (which is standard in the
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Everyone with a C760 and C860 that I've known on #zaurus on freenode gets 4-5 hours of battery life.
Though Opera for Qtopia is pretty nice. So is netFront.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
9 hours of continuous use is pretty good, I don't think your clie can manage that.
Ebay your SL-5500, plenty of people out there who would like one.
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
I get at least 8 hrs bettery life. It replaced a pocket2003 device and a fluke onetouch network assistant as well as recieves constand use, something that no other PDA I have ever owned (I had a newton when they were new!) could ever do. the hancom suite is fantastic if you take the time to update it, and the tons of apps out there as well as the insane simplicity of writing my own wit the qt::perl modules and Z perl installed I can whip up an app in minutes for data collection or
Re:Welcome to 2002! (Score:2)
http://www.zaurususergroup.com/forums/index.php?s= eb19d321bf6323a973dfc7a271fcd201&showtopic=762 5 [zaurususergroup.com]
Sticking with what's important..
Although this looks really good... (Score:4, Insightful)
Anyway, despite my quibbles this sounds like a pretty solid device. Why are they only releasing in Japan?
Re:Although this looks really good... (Score:5, Insightful)
On a PDA? You realize that that would increase the size/weight of the unit drastically right? Yeah, I understand that movies/music are important and that people want to start consolidating devices but personally I'd prefer to keep the device small and light.
Re:Although this looks really good... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Although this looks really good... (Score:2)
How about Mini-DVDs/CDs? At 1.4G/210M it might be a worthy addition - would kill the battery but....
Sera
Re:[OT] Your Sig (Score:2)
Re:[OT] Your Sig (Score:2)
Wow, I bet Sarek must have been really pissed at him when he was born.
Re:Although this looks really good... (Score:2)
Price? (Score:2)
Re:Price? (Score:2)
This has potential as a laptop (Score:5, Interesting)
Seriously, add an inexpensive docking station, and this would be the ultimate ultracompact laptop. You could use it as a normal PDA where ever you are, and at home or work you could plug it into the docking station and be on the network, use it for email and typing, and so on. For most people, this would make a practical second computer.
Lets just hope the price (including that cheap docking station) matches the size!
Re:This has potential as a laptop (Score:2)
Re:This has potential as a laptop (Score:3, Informative)
I used to do that with my Sigmarion 3. I used a VGA out card to display at 1024x768 on an external monitor, and an external USB keyboard and mouse. Just like using a desktop. The parts needed for this are: 1. a way to output VGA and 2. a USB host. The other PDA that can do
Re:This has potential as a laptop (Score:2)
Still, it is extremely nice to have when I don't want to lug a laptop ar
Re:This has potential as a laptop (Score:2)
Plus, it would be insanely cool to have a beefy workstation in a rack somewhere, and to just remotely connect into it from the beach through GPRS/UTMS and be
Re:This has potential as a laptop (Score:2)
You may have a cheaper solution with an old laptop or desktop running a VNC client and connecting to a VNC server on the Zaurus. A specially-engineered new docking station may cost more than older full-featured technology.
markets (Score:3, Interesting)
It will be interesting to see how devices like this (if released in the US) will compete with the OQO, etc. I am guessing the prices of PDAs with a HD will be close to $1000, so the cost/benefit analysis of each will be interesting indeed.
Weight (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
battery life? (Score:2)
4 GB Hard Disk? How about CF? (Score:2, Insightful)
dynamism is a ripoff (Score:2, Flamebait)
Nice bit of free advertising there.
No wonder they can charge $2500-$3500 for laptops that cost around $1500 in Japan.
$1000 is a pretty sweet profit margin for "install a US keyboard".
Re:dynamism is a ripoff (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:dynamism is a ripoff (Score:2)
Re:dynamism is a ripoff (Score:2)
Acronym breakdown (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Acronym breakdown (Score:2)
As did I. I wondered what the point of watching HD video on a PDA was.
I wish the article summaries would cut back on the Acronyms. I suppose that was the only way to fit it in the subject field though.
Eh.. great if it wasn't Sharp (Score:2, Interesting)
Why? Well remember that linux-based 6000 version that had several reviews [slashdot.org] on here not too long ago? Well, Sharp is ALREADY DROPPING SUPPORT FOR IT. [zaurususergroup.com]
wtf is up with that? Lots of people around here just dropped $600 for this thing, only to get bent over by Sharp.
For what it's worth, I'm extremely happy with the 6000. It's rugged as hell, the screen literally has to be seen to be believed, and it can
Sharp bails on the Western World (Score:3, Interesting)
I agree with the other takes I've read on this article. Yes, they should've added wi-fi or Bluetooth. And yes, they couldn't dropped the 4 GB HDD in favor of a 4 GB CF HDD. I had an SL-5500 and have to say having a Linux box in the palm of my hand that I could use as an Apache/PHP/mySQL server was certainly impressive. So was the fact I could code and compile on the unit. But the hardware was built on the cheap. And that is being kind.
The thing that saddens me the most about Sharp is that after actively participating on their developer webboard for a couple of years I can say that they don't really foster many close ties with their user population. They drop things like a rock and without much dialog.
US lacking technowizardry? (Score:2)
Seriously, I was in the market for a laptop through a few weeks ago and it amazed me the variety of ultraportables that Sharp Japan produced. They probably have ~10 machines that run on transmeta chips, one of which (MM20, MM10 might be counted as well but I am not sure it is still produced) is readily available in the US. Other vendors offer Linux notebooks in Aisa, we have a single HP model, and a handful of vendor
Re:US lacking technowizardry? (Score:2)
I think the answer to that is almost certainly no. The stuff they have in Japan will make your eyes drop out. My wife got very fed up of me dragging her around the electronics district of Tokyo - it's tech heaven.
4GB implies microdrive... (Score:4, Interesting)
Cool... and now for the software (Score:2)
Re:Cool... and now for the software (Score:2)
Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:3, Insightful)
OTOH, if you do not contact them, you may have to use WinCE and its siblings for the rest of your days. Well, the choice is yours, just don't say you never had one...
Re:Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
Otherwise, it's not worth the money. I'm still waiting for my 3g linux phone with bluetooth.
It'll never happen.
Re: Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
Ask them for it, ask them about it, what else do I have to say? That's all up to Sharp, and this is their URL [myzaurus.com]. What greater favor could you do t
Re:Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
Re:Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
But um...that card won't let me talk on the phone.
Re:Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
Re:Help make this a success outside Japan as well (Score:2)
comparison data (Score:5, Informative)
looking at Palm [palmone.com], iPAQ [hp.com], and iPod [apple.com] sizes
The picture [theregister.co.uk] makes it look like it is quite thick ... I wonder how it will compare to the above.
SD memory for palms is rapidly improving; soon, larger capacities will be cheaper, making a $250 1GB+ palm smaller and better than this toy.
(note, I have posted on this before [slashdot.org])
Re:comparison data (Score:2, Informative)
It also has fully twice the screen resolution as the highest-rez device you listed (the T5, I believe), and closer to 4 times the rez of everything else. It also includes what is probably one of the best built in keyboards on the market, on top of having as much storage capacity as the iPod mini.
How does that make any of the above "better"?
You'd have to combine 1.5 T5's, the Palm C for the keyboard, AND the iPod mini into a single unit to match it. You'd
Re:comparison data (Score:2)
Re:comparison data (Score:2)
Re:comparison data (Score:2)
True, so long as you ignore the fact that Palm's current OS blows goats, and their only working Java VM blows even more and varies farmyard animals.
And I say this being a Tungsten T3 owner, too. It's a good machine, but I really don't like the complete lack of multitasking in the OS. As soon as someone sends you a file via Bluetooth, you will be waiting until it finishes downloading. Never mind if you were trying to listen to music, it just doesn't care.
As a long-time Zaurus owner, my wish list (Score:5, Insightful)
What I wanted however, was decidedly different than what they seem to have provided. Here's a short but simple list that would turn the SL-C760 into a must-have device.
the strength of the 760 is undoubtedly the beautiful screen. At 640x480 and with a pixel density you have to see to believe, it's almost *too* good -- and by that I mean it's almost 800 pixels wide, which would mean you could really surf the web without having to scroll horizontally. There's clearly space in the bezel and the unit is practically screaming for an additional 160 pixels of width to fill out the top portion of the flip.
this is the industry standard and it's hard to not see it as a major issue that it's not included. Yes you can get CF cards (and I've tried them all!) but having a separate card is bulky (they all stick out of the unit ruining the beautiful form factor), it's one more thing to buy and carry around, and it's one more thing to suck the battery since it's not integrated into the MoBo and power management system.
the unit is tantilizingly close to being able to run a full version of Linux (Mozilla, X, gnome/KDE, whatever) but isn't quite fast enough. Having to suffer through a "pocket browser" and a "pocket editor" is frustrating when the real things aren't that far away. Hobbyists have created special stripped-down versions of popular software (minimo is a pocket-mozilla) but I shouldn't have to hack the ROM to get the full potential out of the unit.
See? I told you it was a short list. The C760 is nearly perfect. Nearly. But this latest model is no better.
Why add a Hard Drive? (Score:2)
I use mine primarily as a Wifi detector. I pull out the Zaurus, and quickly check to see if Wifi is available, and if it's open and free. If so, I pull out my PowerBook for any real www access.
But, a hard drive would be the last thing I would have wanted on my Zaurus. The microdrives would be a power drain, on an already power limited device. And, I have plenty of storage already - via the large/cheap SD cards.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:GSM (Score:2)
By the time this makes to the US market, if ever, it will have whatever Sharp US thinks would make them the most $$ there.
Re:Wow, nice (Score:2, Interesting)
How will this one work ?
BTW, my Zaurus also lacked OSX support which made it useless because if you have such a PDA, you might want to work on it and ultimately sync it with a desktop...
So : When will Sharp produce a SyncML-enabled PDA ?
Re:Why use a Zaurus? (Score:3, Interesting)
Might try contacting more than one importer before giving up, too, if the first won't do it.
Re:Why use a Zaurus? (Score:2)
Re:Why use a Zaurus? (Score:2)
I did that several times for people in similar situations; but, I am about to leave Japan, so I can't offer to help you.
Re:This is not just a PDA... (Score:2)
Re:Not surprising (Score:2)