No Noise PC Reviewed 214
Arne Anka writes "How about a no noise PC? Well, Hush has recently launched its ATX range, which takes a full ATX motherboard, decent speed processors and graphics card, but sticks to the main concept of producing no noise PCs. The chassis is made from solid aluminum heatsinks and the whole system is fitted with heatpipes. Have a look at TrustedReviews for the first online review of the Hush ATX."
Super secret to noiseless computers (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Super secret to noiseless computers (Score:4, Funny)
Nah... (Score:5, Funny)
Excellent advance (Score:5, Interesting)
Compare a PC to a TV. To use the TV, you just turn your eyes towards the screen and click the remote. Within a few seconds, it's on and you're lulled into its endless mediocre entertainment and corporate propaganda dimension.
PCs with internet access are much more interesting. But you have to be at your PC desk, assuming a posture of office environment productivity. Then turn on the PC and wait, and wait, for the 'boot' process. Yes, twenty, thirty seconds go by, you're still waiting. Screen after screen of garbage text goes by. It's like bringing the Defence Department on-line. Compare the PC to a Commodore 64 (an 8-bit first-generation home-computer from the mid-1980s). With that machine, you flipped the on/off switch, and the computer was on within seconds, ready to do a rather limited number of things, but with no waiting. (You did wait to load files from the floppy drive - about 3 minutes to load 25K bytes).
So after minutes, your PC is finally UP! and ready to go. Click on the telephone access, wait another minute or so before the internet connection is 'established'. Wait...and...wait.
Oh yes, you can buy 24 telephone internet connection service, but it is very expensive. Especially compared to a television as an entertainment medium.
Still waiting? System crashed and needed 're-booting' yet? Is there one little weird-ass little program that has tripled your power-on boot time for no good reason and you can't figure out what program it is?
Are your ears hurting yet from all the white noise from all the powerful machinery creating the 'new information age' next to the desk?
Anyway, the whole point is that PCs have a long way to go from this 'Data Control, IBM, Science Is Mankind's Brother' 1960's mainframe mentality before they can be as advanced as a television set or a clock radio as a home appliance/entertainment device.
But making them quiet is a big and welcome step in that direction. A single step in a thousand mile journey.
Now how about starting to work on an OFF switch? You know, push the button and the machine goes off? Now? Within one second? Goes from using amps of power to microamps? Is it really that hard to do, guys? You'all put a man on the moon.. how about an instant OFF switch on the PC?
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
Why not just use suspend mode? Most PCs have it. The ram is powered and refreshed, but the rest of the system is more or less turned off (except for stuff like the keyboard which is often kept running so you can wake the system up that way, and the NIC for wake-on-lan.) I think this is a reasonable way to split the difference between always-on and turning the system off at night.
IBM MRAM may come along someday and make it possible for the memory to store information without the power being turned on, wh
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
Oh, now I get it. Re-'booting' is what I sometimes have to do when I do a 'Software Update...'. Even then, that only takes about 30 seconds.
(tig)
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
It's really sad that a C64 reading a floppy is okay, and booting a modern computer (roughly 20 seconds on mine) isn't.
I know you were supposed to be humorous, but this is a valid issue. I've noticed that my old computers are untolerably(sp) slow, even though at the time I though they were speedy little buggers. This is very depression, what is waiting a FULL minute for a boot, who cares... It's a minute, I should be capable of waiting that long. I'm sure when the
Laptops are the answer (Score:2)
"PCs with internet access are much more interesting. But you have to be at your PC desk, assuming a posture of office environment productivity. Then turn on the PC and wait, and wait, for the 'boot' process. Yes, twenty, thirty seconds go by, you're still waiting."
I'm reading this slouched on the floor, back against the couch, on a whisper-quiet laptop the I rarely shutdown - I put it into sleep mode and it comes to life faster than the TV. When the rain stops I'll be on the patio knocking out some work
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
I recently discovered this feature in VMWare called "Suspend". It's amazing. I can suspend a VM, then shut down the computer.
I can oopy this VM to another computer, and then restore the suspended session. The VM comes back up, restored at the exact processor/memory state it was suspended in!
So, I ask... why can't this be done in hardware?
Re:Excellent advance (Score:2)
Re:Nah... (Score:2)
Isn't it cheaper... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Isn't it cheaper... (Score:2)
So... (Score:2)
The noise isn't about being able to sleep. It is about being able to use the computer while using it.
Frankly, a well designed desktop case with simple silencing mods should do the trick, should one chose the self-assemble route. My Compaq workstation has four well-built 9.2cm fans and with accoustic treatme
Re:I'd be interested to hear... (Score:2)
Re:I'd be interested to hear... (Score:3, Interesting)
I have a sound box like that, and it is a marvel. A desktop machine that unaided sounds like an Airbus taking off turns into a comfortable whirr that is barely audible at all when it is placed
Here's a silent pc made for gaming. (Score:5, Informative)
Apparently it can cool damn near anything as far as CPUs and GPUs, including an Athlon FX-53 and a Geforce 6800gt and up to 2 Gig of ram. The only thing you'll hear is the drives while you frag.
Re:Here's a silent pc made for gaming. (Score:2)
http://www.zalmanusa.com/usa/product/view.asp?i
which sounds like it uses technologies very similar to the Hush case, though the Hush case is impressively quite a bit smaller. Tom's has a review of the Zalman case here:
http://www.tomshardware.com/howto/20040115/inde
In any case, neat idea, but I don't think I'm alone in balking at spending over $1000 on the case alone... =)
Linkage (Score:2)
Tom's Hardware Review [tomshardware.com]
HD (Score:5, Insightful)
Comment removed (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Solid State Drives (Score:4, Funny)
Don't forget: (Score:2)
Re:HD (Score:4, Funny)
Only the CIA computer (terminal) in Mission Impossible was so silent, that Ethan Hunt had a pretty hard time to work on it without triggering the noise sensor alarms...
Of course it's possible (Score:2)
Re:HD (Score:2)
The Barracuda drives are supposed to be nearly silent. However for the living room I would definately go with netboot and no hard drive instead. btw you say anything with a motor will make a noise but wasn't there an article in Slashdot earlier with HD flash drives using IDE interface?
Phillip.
Re:HD (Score:3, Informative)
The SATA versions are slightly noisier though. I've noticed that if it's quiet enough, you can barely hear the head on the SATA drive seek on occassion.
Re:HD (Score:2)
But then I decided it was quiet enough
Re:HD (Score:3, Interesting)
Use compact flash to hold the os and core applications. CF cards can be connected to an ide port with a simple adapter, so you should be able to boot right off the CF card with any system. I imagine most of the silent PC market will be either purpose-built systems (streaming audio players, dvd/divx players, firewall/router/access-point, etc) or web/e-mail terminals. Both of these should easily fit in a 512MB to 1GB CF card.
Re:HD (Score:2)
Re:HD - Obviously didn't RTFA (Score:2)
The advantage of a solid block of metal for noise dampening is that sound doesn't transition through abrupt density changes very well. In effect, you have a pressure wave that's pretty much energy stored in air. Now you try and transfer that energy to something that's 500 times more dense - you'll get a pretty solid reflection off that surface, with only a miniscule amount of energy transferred into it.
But when you co
Re:HD - Obviously didn't RTFA (Score:2)
There are vibration isolating mounting systems for hard drives, sure...but you have to have something more than just an aluminum box.
That's nice (Score:3, Interesting)
Er RTFA (Score:5, Interesting)
"There are only two backing plate slots for expansion cards and they are both occupied. One is filled by the graphics card ? an ATI Radeon 9600XT with D-SUB and DVI connectors, while the other is filled with a digital TV tuner card."
"Hiding under the CPU heatsink was a 2.6GHz Pentium 4, but Hush has now dropped this chip from its range and will be offering a 2.8GHz Pentium 4 instead."
Is a 9600 vs. a 9800 and a 2.8 vs. a 3.2 really that big a deal? Hell you could probably swap them out and it would still work fine.
Re:Er RTFA (Score:3, Informative)
Well, the 2.8 vs. 3.2 isn't a big deal at all. I don't know why the hell the grandparent wants a Prescott - they absolutely SUCK - 50% more power consumption and 5% lower performance per clock compared to Northwood.
I'm confused as to why this system doesn't use an Athlon 64, or, better yet, a Pentium-M. Both require less power and still offer great performance.
As for graph
Re:That's nice (Score:3, Informative)
Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:5, Informative)
Cooled by convection, the core seems to 'hover' and the only noise-making devices in the whole computer are the hard drive and the optical drive.
Sadly, Apple didn't pursue the design. From a business standpoint, this was neccessary, the computer was almost as expensive as the towers, had no real expandibility, and Apple couldn't put a ramped up G4 in the Cube and keep it passively cooled.
Regardless, it's a Mac collector item, retains a large amount of its value despite being discontinued 3 or 4 years ago, and runs OSX beautifully.
This post brought to you by a G4 Cube and 17" Apple Studio Display. No PC ever looked this good, bay-bee.
Re:Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:5, Informative)
Re:Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:2)
Re:Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:3, Informative)
No kidding. I had owned mine for a year before it ever kicked on and when it did it scared me to death the first time I heard it. "What the hell is THAT?!?!?"
Re:Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:2)
Re:Hate to toot someone else's horn.. (Score:2)
No, the poster was referring to the Revision E iMacs (aka "iMac DV" series) that featured slot-loading DVD drives. Those were convection-cooled, and damned quiet.
~Philly
xbill (Score:2)
And then Apple made a computer that looks like a toaster oven. I thought it was the best joke ever. And how prophetic; the temperature of a modern AMD or Intel powered system tells it all.
Also on The Register (Score:2, Informative)
Soekris (Score:5, Interesting)
I switched recently to a Soekris [soekris.com] net4801 with a 2.5" harddrive as my main ADSL router, Postfix, Cyrus/IMAP, and thttpd server, running FreeBSD 5.2.1.
One of the main reasons was the noise of the PC being always on. Of course, the other reason was to save (a lot of) power. Now, my desktop PC is still not silent, but it's great to be able to turn if off before going to bed.
Re:Soekris (Score:2)
Re:Soekris (Score:2)
Soekris provides small metal cases. You can order them on their site.
a /. koan (Score:2)
Server to busy (Score:2)
Not the first online review. (Score:5, Informative)
After "TrustedReviews" recovers from the slashdotting I will have a look though...
First? (Score:3, Informative)
Comment removed (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
Laptops are anything but noiseless. An older laptop with a very quiet hard drive is near-silent but modern laptops usually have fairly high-speed cooling fans and a loud hard drive, because getting good performance out of a disk that small is nigh-impossible to do quietly. Many laptop drives I have heard (and owned) seek more loudly than many of the desktop hard drives I have owned, even as compared to some of the old ST-506 drives I had "back in the day".
If you want noiseless, I suggest a diskless book
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
The Travelstar isn't too bad. I hear the seek noise, but it is still overall, still quieter than any desktop I've ever owned. Really, the only thing objectionable on my laptop is the DVD drive when reading CD-ROMs or non-video DVD. For video DVD it slows down to
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
My IBM ThinkPad T40p is nearly silent during normal use. The fan noise becomes recognizable when you start taxing the graphics card and processor at the same time. The HDD (Hitachi 60GB 7200RPM) isn't a problem.
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
Re:The obvious solution (Score:3, Insightful)
If you don't need a fast pc then get a fanless mini itx board http://www.mini-itx.com/ [mini-itx.com], a flanless power supply, a quiet hard drive and put it all in a big airy case with a large low rpm fan and hide it all under the desk. Much quieter and cheaper than a laptop.
Re:The obvious solution (Score:2)
yessir... a fanless athlon xp.
have clocked it down to 300MHz with cpumsr...
after the HD spins down it is DEAD QUIET
Underclocking (Score:5, Interesting)
I mean, laptops have already had this technology for years (battery versus wall power), although it is often is fairly proprietary, if it works at all.
For the 9 out of 10 times when I just want web surfing & audio streaming at home, I'd like to run at 20% of my 2 GHz and turn down the fans. After all, when you're trying to set a mood with Soma FM [somafm.com], who needs blaring screaming fans going?
Re:Underclocking (Score:3, Interesting)
Mod Parent UP! (Score:2)
BTW, Here's [amd.com] the link parent forgot to mention/link to. /* basically it`s just a bunch of PR Spin/BuzzWord, as it's a rename of 'PowerNow' that has been in the Mobile cpu's ... I know, I know - why rename/rebrand it and sell it as it where something new? ... what can you do, every Corp. (as we know them) *just* got to show to the world they got a bigger 'DICK" then their
Where to buy (Score:3, Informative)
These would make great MythTv [mythtv.org] boxes if they had more pci slots. Currently there are only two. It would be nice to have two regular tuners and a digital tuner in the box. They could also add an irda port to the front. Also the thing weighs 15kg or approx. 33 pounds; not something you want to trip over in the dark.
Re:Where to buy (Score:3, Funny)
If you're building a home theater setup based around a PC, perhaps you should consider purchasing some furniture first.
Re:Where to buy (Score:2)
Hush Website (Score:3, Informative)
Not for me! (Score:4, Funny)
I'm not sure if I want a computer that the review lables as ripe for a museum!
Mirror of the SPCR review (Score:2)
Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2, Interesting)
They had a whole GUI OS with a built in scripting language (BBC Basic: the best form of BASIC ever made (even had malloc() equivalent and proper pointer indirection:) ), and a few other very interesting features.
But they've gone
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2)
btw, the server and client and run ANY mix of win/unix. win on server and unix on client or unix on both or win on both, etc, etc. you pick. but the important part is that you can have a persistent desktop in the os of your dhoice if you run vnc server on it and 'view' it remotely via a 10/100 or
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2)
Yes. One would think it should have migrated to fast desktop PCs a long time ago. Apparently it did but it is not very widespread.
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2)
Apple will be "inventing" it any time now.
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2)
Thanks for the info. I was aware of that some form of energy saving management existed (monitor and hard drive off after a preset idle duration). I just did not know exactly how much energy was being consummed during sleep mode. If the energy being consummed is low enough (less than a 5-watt bulb would be nice), then this is what I am looking for. I'll just leave the machine "ON" all the time.
I guess it's time for me to
Re:Instant boot and silent PC? (Score:2)
Thanks for the info. This is very enlightening. I realize that this is somewhat offtopic but since we're talking about PC technology, what the heck. I have two additional questions:
1) Are you referring to Linux-based PCs or Windows?
2) Where can I buy this technology?
TAA (This Ain't Astroturf) (Score:3, Informative)
I weighed my options: new CPU heatsink/fan that leaves some room between it and the power supply, underclock my current CPU (going from 1690 to 1250 MHz lowered my CPU temp by 10 degrees C), or try a new case.
At that point, I ran to Fry's and picked up one of those Altec Sonata Quiet cases (the one with a fan in the back of the unit with the 30 dollar mail-in rebate). Lots of room above the CPU fan. Now the only noise I hear from my workstation comes from the hard drives, and my CPU runs at a cool 40 degrees Celsius! That's a 20 degree difference, just by getting a decent case. A quality case and power supply do wonders for keeping a system quiet, cool, and stable. Now I need to do something about those annoying blue LED's...
Oh, and TAA (This Ain't Astroturf). Really!
Re:TAA (This Ain't Astroturf) (Score:2)
That s
Zalman TNN 500A (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Zalman TNN 500A (Score:2)
solid aluminum? (Score:2)
Re:solid aluminum? (Score:2)
Re:solid aluminum? (Score:2)
Why is this a problem? Oxidized copper actually looks quite nice, sort of a pleasant pale green... much better than yet-another shiny silver case (yawn).
Indeed, the more I think about it, the better it sounds -- get away from the shiny technical look, and do something a bit more muted and organic (without the heat problems that come from making your case out of wood!). Too bad nobody will really make one...
Re:solid aluminum? (Score:2)
I think polished copper looks nice. Oxidised looks grotty. It doesn't just go green, splotchy and everything darkens too.
Re:solid aluminum? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:solid aluminum? (Score:2)
Now we're on the right track! For a moment I thought gold would be even better but it's probably too soft.
But does copper really cost that much? Melt down, say, 5,000 old pennies and that's only $50 in material. That should be plenty.
I have found that I can actually access PCs... (Score:2, Interesting)
With a good video/audio distribution plan (hopefully one that incorporates 2-way remote IR), it doesn't actually matter how loud my PC is...it's in another room (along with all my other AV equipment; which also distribute their signals to multiple TVs.
I mean, making a silent PC is kinda like making a silent Central HVAC unit...(nobody steal my idea now...)
Move them (Score:2)
All I have now is one desktop and a notebook. With the data living on the other machines, the desktop often spins down it's HD's reducing that noise (the PS fan is another issue - and it's a G3 desktop so it doesn't use a standard ATX power supply).
Re:Only problem here (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Only problem here (Score:2)
Re:Only problem here (Score:2)
Re:Only problem here (Score:2)
Re:Quiet Power Supplies? (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Quiet Power Supplies? (Score:2)
the PS was about $130 (ouch) but for a fanless model, it did make me want to try it.
google for 'Coolmax CF-400 400W' and you'll find it.
Re:zzzz.... (Score:2)
Re:Something they seem to overlook.... (Score:2)
Re:Something they seem to overlook.... (Score:2)
The answer to why the don't do it is that it's more expensive. The brick typically provides a single voltage and doesn't eliminate the need for a PSU inside the unit. The overall cost of the solution is higher and is something that customer
Re:Dell Optiplex is very quiet (Score:2)
Re:Better use of space: (Score:2, Informative)