Temporary Wireless Service For An Outdoors Event? 213
SBECK writes "I've been asked to come up with an estimate of how much it would cost to provide wireless internet service for a small convention being held at a campground. That would entail renting or buying enough wireless access points to give coverage to the area and getting temporary satellite Internet service. Unfortunately, I've never done any of this, so I'm floundering. I'd love to get some pointers from anyone who has any experience setting up something like this. What ISP services provide temporary satellite service for something like this?"
Electricity (Score:4, Insightful)
All campgrounds have electricity (Score:2)
This is
No They Don't (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:No They Don't (Score:2, Insightful)
(a) having a large meeeting in an outdoor area
(b) Has some sort of need for a wireless network
(c) Plans on using computers for that wireless network
Re:No They Don't (Score:2)
No, it won't. (Score:3, Informative)
I've seen the output from a rental Honda generator on an oscilloscope and it's pretty clean too. I use two of these generators to power sound (about 3kW of amplifier output) and computer equipment for five hours on a parade float in the summer with no problems.
Add a double-conversion UPS (probably you already have one in your office) between the generator and your equipment and that will let you refuel
Re:No, it won't. (Score:2)
Re:Electricity (Score:2)
Even quiet generators make some noise. Batteries make none.
Uplink? (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Uplink? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Uplink? (Score:5, Informative)
Bi-directional has been available for a few years now. Sheesh I get enough spam for it in my mailbox, some of it from my isp(earthlink) who also sends adds for dsl, which isn't available within my zip or and of the neighboring zips.
Mycroft
Re:Uplink? (Score:3, Informative)
Insightful?? NO, just wrong (Score:5, Informative)
Sorry, this is wrong. Check out DirecWay [direcway.com] for at least one provider for 2 way sat comms.
How fast? (Score:2)
If the link isn't much faster than dialup, the guy trying to setup the link may find he has enough electricity to drive all his access points but the pipe to the sky is so skinny he may as well not have bothered.
Re:Uplink? (Score:2)
you should look at the newer stuff, it's very different (but still has 3000ms latency minimum.)
Re:Uplink? (Score:4, Informative)
Try Starband for 700-800ms latency. Reasonably reliable IP service for an office of 8 users in very remote Colorado mountain country, although their call center blows chunks. I can even VNC (through SSH) to that office, it's slow but the link doesn't drop and it's useable.
--
Karma and Foes, who cares.
Cheap generic routers with third party firmware (Score:5, Informative)
I would recommend using cheap AP's designed for home use and a third party firmware that allows them to link up and form a mesh.
The Linksys WRT54G is about $70 or less on Amazon and with third party firmware it can be linked into a mesh using something called WDS.
You can also add PoE and larger antennas quite reasonably.
See the Sveasoft site [sveasoft.com] for more information.
Re:Cheap generic routers with third party firmware (Score:2)
Mesh photos - three hops deep and workin' great (Score:2)
We have a 7 node mesh with up to three deep on any single linear chain using WDS. It works great. Our longes link [sveasoft.com] is 6 kilometers through forest, islands, and over water.
Linksys stuff is aweful in my experiences (Score:3, Informative)
The linksys WAP11s and WMP54g wireless PCI card were just plain terrible. Did not work as advertised. Doing WEP across two WAP11s in AP/Repeater mode causes instant lockup of the repeater. I spent an entire month on the phone with their Indian tech support until one of them finally admitted that it was a known problem that they've duplicated in their lab. Unfortunately afte
Re:Linksys stuff is aweful in my experiences (Score:2)
Doesn't really apply to the wireless side of things, though. Linksys hardware has always been this side of shabby, just relying on tight written routing algorhythms and little tricks to make it go as fast as possible.
Low Bandwidth, Low Cost Solution (Score:4, Funny)
psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:5, Informative)
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2, Interesting)
Lessons Learnt:
There are more people with good suggestions than people with desire to carry them out.
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2, Flamebait)
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2, Funny)
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2)
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2)
Unfortunatelly with Mozilla you do need to have at least two tabs open for the button to be visible, but still it is very usefull.
Re:psand have been doing this in the UK (Score:2)
Hmmm
But you did have a net, so maybe your catch was ok?
Direcway (Score:4, Informative)
-Pascal
Re:Direcway (Score:5, Informative)
Lincsat is trying to get the DW4000 modems out the door, and is offering a deal of $499CDN with dish, free installation, and 'only' $49.95 for the first two months. After that, the price goes up to the regular $79.95/month for the remainder of the two year contract.
Re:Direcway (Score:2)
Note, however, that the 4000 series ends in a USB cable, not an ethernet cable.
Re:Direcway (Score:5, Informative)
This is not inexpensive to setup - the hardware isn't cheap (though you might find it on E-bay). BUT, the major issue is that in the US, you have to have a licensed installer because the DW6000 has a built-in uplink. Of course, if you know someone who has is licensed and is willing to do it, you can save there.
And, having had quite a bit of experience with Direcway, if you have any kind of bad weather, you may have no connectivity. Rain is your enemy.
Re:Direcway (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Direcway (Score:2, Interesting)
What you really need... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:What you really need... (Score:2)
anyway, back to thread topic:
I have to think, of all the....
erm...
I thought one of the attractions of doing remote camping was to get AWAY from technology for a few days?
I do think the project is interesting, but it seems to defeat the point of the event. I think standard convention houses offer at least broadband, I can't say much for wireless.
Re:What you really need... (Score:2)
If you get people fast enough, you could even do teleconferencing over this link. Voice Over IP Over Voice (VOIPOV).
Sell your wireless (Score:4, Interesting)
Personally, I use my cell/Palm-PDA to surf when I'm away from home/work. I love my Samsung i500!!!!
Ask Burning Man? (Score:5, Interesting)
Also, the Mars Society [marssociety.org] uses satellite hookups to keep in touch with its field stations. Perhaps they can give you some pointers?
Depending on where the event is held and how well cellphone signals can be received, you might also want to try a mobile phone carrier. A lot of the larger UK events like Glastonbury are, I believe, getting support in this area from larger telcos. It may be more complex, and will probably involve getting everyone a new PCMCIA card, but it could be an option.
Sorry I couldn't be of more help; sadly IANA techie, but I hope these couple of snippets I've seen around the net are of use to you.
Re:Ask Burning Man? (Score:5, Interesting)
They get the additional fun of having to put up with Dr Megavolt [mit.edu]. Last time I was out there (a few years back) I chatted with a few guys trying to do some long wire runs and RF comms. Appearantly everytime Dr. Volt's van drove by and fired the Tesla, they'd lose another piece of gear!
Re:Ask Burning Man? (Score:5, Informative)
Line of sight? (Score:5, Informative)
You may only need 2 directional antenas instead of a satilite uplink.
Re:Line of sight? (Score:4, Interesting)
Depending on whether this is a comercial project or not, one might be able to use the amature shortwave / longwave bands. It has it's limits, but it's not limited to line of site as with microwave.
Re:Line of sight? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Line of sight? (Score:4, Insightful)
brian de kf4zwz
Re:Line of sight? (Score:2)
It's not just commercial transactions are out. Encryption on amature shortwave is a no-no, too. There goes SSH, https:, VPNs, etc..
And 9600bps? <Shudder>
Reminds me trying to get through MAE-East [mae.net], about 10 years ago. At times, it was SO congested that it was faster and less of a headache to use a 14.4 modem to dial into St. Louis (had to go far enough West to keep from being routed back through it) from DC and just skip that particular choke point. But I digress.
No, leave the amature shortwave s
Re:Line of sight? (Score:4, Informative)
Why not try negotiating with the site owner about having the system installed permanently, that way the costs can be recovered from users over a long time, so an expensive solution might become viable?
If you can get an ADSL line to the site, it gets easier and you only need standard stuff, firewall, router, WiFi access points and so on. It would be best to have a caching proxy server, it can take a lot of load off the line as many people might be looking at the same sites. All of this is straightforward Linux/BSD/Windoze (if you really must) territory, the only thing difficult is the telecom infrastructure. Oh, and watch out for electrical safety regulations, there are lots of potential difficulties, and you reall do need to know your local regulations, and comply with them, or use low-voltage batteries for the lot.
I would ask the local telecom provider how much a decently fast line would cost before messing with satellite systems. The people who supply networking, cable TV, or voice comms in that geographic area are the people who know. In the UK, which does not help you very much, BT can and will provide a voice line or lines (you could aggregate the bandwidth with multiple modems) anywhere, or an ISDN line in most places, ADSL gets slightly harder because of the distance limit. All this is at a cost, of course......
Just let them (Score:3, Funny)
Use their Trekie Communicators.
more info please? (Score:5, Informative)
I've organised a few LAN-parties (up to ~250 attendants) and providers are more than willing to help you out. Also talk to one of your local IT shops, they usually don't mind you using their stock for this kind of event for a small rental fee. As an example: for a LAN-party for 100 participants we paid about 200,-- in fees for the whole network infrastructure & server park. We got to use 3 3com superstack switches and 5 dual xeon servers. The internet router (cisco 2600 series) was provided by the ISP. We just hooked the stuff up & had a great party. The help provided by both the ISP & the IT-shop was tremendous. All the help we got was from volunteers of those companies... they only asked free entrance in the gaming contest in return. Oh, and some beers :).
Re:more info please? (Score:5, Insightful)
- in which country is this event going to be held?
- what infrastructure do you have available?
going to satellite link should only be a last resort.
Re:more info please? (Score:2)
For servers, if you do this kind of thing often, it would pay to accumulate obsolete PCs (a lot of people seem to be disposing of 733MHz Pentiums thse days, they don't cost very much at all), for use as servers, they are perfectly adequate for Linux or FreeBSD. That way you could k
Re:more info please? (Score:2)
802.11g isn't that expensive now, either.
Static or mobile devices? (Score:5, Interesting)
If you are having static devices that get setup, connected then left in place for the duration then you can get away with using cheaper network switches. However, if youa re using mainly mobile devices then you can get disconnections as the user roams between access points on different cheaper switches.
This has happened to some of our customers using handheld barcode scanners as they network equuipment could not perform the handoff between access pints quick enough, logging the radio user off.
Not really directly answering your question but its something to consider.
Re:Static or mobile devices? (Score:3, Funny)
Is that what happens to electronics the morning after a night of camping?
Re:Static or mobile devices? (Score:2)
Re:Static or mobile devices? (Score:2)
My spelling goes right out the window when I'm typing fast
Re:Static or mobile devices? (Score:2)
This is called a hard handoff. An example of a soft handoff is a cell phone, where you can switch between different cell towers and not be disconnected. However with current wireless networking implementations you are only able to do hard handoffs, where you will be disconnected when you go from one AP to another
Try a local computer provider... (Score:5, Interesting)
Even if you offer them a stand at the event to allow them to show off their services, you can probley get them to help out!!!
I know the manager, but not sure if they have what you need.
http://www.eurorent.ie
Outsourcing... (Score:4, Insightful)
Also, try to stick with as few different vendors as possible. That way, you won't introduce unnecessary incompatibilities and you won't have to deal with different setups and configurations (that may not be such a big problem as long as you stick to using SoHo equipment, as it's usually fairly standard-compliant and easily configured through a web interface).
If your conference is really out in the middle of nowhere though consider turning to the pros. I have worked with T-Mobile techs on providing Internet access at an outdoor sports event in a fairly secluded area and have nothing but good things to say about them. Since there were no landlines and no WiFi coverage available we basically had to rely on cell transmissions. So we setup a IEEE 802.11 network and they provided the cell-phone backend. We had to put in a few restrictions (bandwidth throttling, etc) to ensure that the network was reasonably secure and to keep costs in check but it did work like a charm. Of course, that might not be an option depending on your choice of locale and your budget.
Sponsors? (Score:5, Informative)
"WiFi hotspot courtesy of Apple|Linksys|Lucent" blah blah blah... I know in France, Apple sponsors big events organized by the municipality and lends quite a lot of equipment. Maybe you should try.
Mesh networking (Score:5, Informative)
Thomas Krag & Co. also maintain a wiki [wire.less.dk] that you may find useful.
Mobile Mesh [mitre.org] runs in user-land and is covered by the GPL. It seems to get the best reviews.
-- Douglas
Satellite rental (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Satellite rental (Score:3, Informative)
Why not ad-hoc (Score:4, Interesting)
Did it at the MASP (Score:5, Interesting)
Why WiFi at a Campground? (Score:2)
Maybe you mean RVing?
I'd look at a simple WiFi router and some HAM radio equiment to do it on the cheap. Remember, Linux kernels can do that kind of thing
Re:Why WiFi at a Campground? (Score:2)
Re:Why WiFi at a Campground? (Score:2)
Hams (not HAM) cannot be WISPs as Amateur Radio is a non-comercial service.
Re:Why WiFi at a Campground? (Score:2)
in other news (Score:3, Informative)
do what I do when consulting: say anything is possible, but estimate something that can't possibily be affordable.
PS - Most campgrounds have one residential unit on the lot; its usually where the owners live and it usually can get cable. Contact the local cable company to see if they can provide high speed internet service to the residence, then base your wireless out of the residency (something on the roof, then repeaters)
Some work has been done on the ISP side (Score:2)
The folks at OSU might be willing to share information. I know they have used the trailer system to provide 11b wireless to events held "out in a field" as well.
Cash and Cache (Score:2)
Maybe this is close to what you're looking for (Score:4, Informative)
Here are some people with experience: (Score:2, Informative)
The CCC Camp 2003 was a really cool event [xs4all.nl], and i really hope there are going to be more camps like this in the future (thanks, guys!).
Long Range WiFi Connection (Score:3, Informative)
where is this event? (Score:4, Informative)
Some cases you can have the phone company provision a line to the site (though you generally need a few weeks to make this happen). It is possible that the site already has phone/dsl service (unless it's out in the middle of nowhere).
One of the best options is to see if there is a wireless provider in the area and back haul a connection from them, in some cases there are many free/opensource type communities that run their own wireless core network. Look at settle wireless or the BAWUG (Bay area wireless user group) as they have done point to point backhauls to a park so everyone could surf while they were there... backhaul with some good equipment then use some dlinks or linksys units for the WLAN
Make sure AP's and backhaul are on seperate channels too..seen some people doing backhaul with 802.11a equipment (modifed) which is sometimes cheap to buy, and less bleedover signal in the spectrum. Oh.. lastly.. Trees are not your friend! they will kill your signal, don't bother trying to do this in a forest.
-b
Coverage (Score:4, Informative)
One problem with "hopping" is that occasionally if one of the access points in the middle of the link goes down, you may need to reset each of the other AP's down the line to get them back up and running.
We also ran into some interesting problems such as the time that around 8am in the morning our coverage started dropping when all the houses around the course started turning on their microwaves. You can never guarantee that the coverage you have at one time will be consistent throughout the day.
Along with a power supply and an access point, we also bought these special antennas that could be attached to camera tripods to give us a mini cell tower like setup. Oh yeah, and lesson learned, don't take those down during a thunderstorm.
Packet Radio (Score:2, Insightful)
Transfer rates have tipically been very low, but might be Ok for email and low-bandwith use.
Depends, are you going to give it away or sell it? (Score:2)
You should really look into hiring someone that has past experience with this as an amature you could really get into some interesting issues.
skycasters will rent you a two-way internet dish (Score:2, Informative)
slashdot cut (Score:2)
Frickin' lasers for last miles (Score:4, Interesting)
http://www.washingtontechnology.com/new
Here are Cannon's frickin' lasers:
http://www.usa.canon.com/html/industrial
Terabeam Elliptica, plus links to other free fpace optics:
http://www.freespaceoptics.com/Free_Spac
Re:Frickin' lasers for last miles (Score:2)
I'd be really interested in this technology, if it wasn't for the '1 km seems to be the limit,' well, limit.
Mesh networks (Score:2, Informative)
Transportable Satellite Internet System (Score:3, Informative)
Use an outdoor WAP (Score:3, Informative)
Wireless ISP (Score:2)
For instance, this [skyweb.ca] is a local company who provides wireless TV and internet (competing head-to-head with the local cable companies). Something like that would take care if the internet feed for relatively cheap, if it's available wherever you are. (My parents are using this service for TV and internet on their farm, which as about 30Km from the main tower.)
Cellular is the easiest (Score:2, Interesting)
An RV with MOTOSAT sounds perfect. (Score:3, Informative)
connection means trade off dependent on media (Score:2)
For instance, one thing I haven't seen brought up is iridium. If what you're doing is streaming audio of the conference you could use it's voice features to call up a voice modem in a box that could encode the stream and stream it on it's merry way. I've done ppp over iridium (slooowwww) too, so if you're streaming the audio during the day, you could call another number at night to get connectivity and may
Burning Man? (Score:4, Informative)
Ask the right people (Score:3, Informative)
Forget satellite, find a wireless isp that will rent you the gear and handle the setup. The complexity of the project is too high to ebay and figure it out yourself, especially for a short-term event. In regards to cost, a minimum expectation is $2000, with a reasonable ceiling being $6000. Your results may vary.
Re:Why Fi? (Score:2)
Because they did that last year, and the hotel manager hasn't forgiven them for setting off the fire-alarms after they tried to have a traditional barbecue in the conference hall.
Re:you have the money honey, I have the time. (Score:2)
It's amazing how many times I've heard the argument that a wagon full of tapes delivers bandwidth which can compete with our outperform Internet2. BULLSHIT.
The people always forget or deliberatly ignore the fact that you need to write the data to tape, and then read it at the other end. The speed with which most tape drives can store data is often a lot lower than a 100Mbit internet link.
Expensive?? (Score:2)
Sprint PCS Data Link, WAP and big omni antenna (Score:3, Informative)
Re:What at a camp ground and net access is a piori (Score:2)
You really want embedded hardware for this. (Score:2)
You're reinventing the wheel here. Building your own kernel with all the features needed to become an AP is simply replicating all the effort expended by the AP vendors. There are also prebuilt c