Portable Linux Box 134
libertynews writes: "Last night at the Kitsap Peninsula Linux User Group meeting we had one of our members bring in a new Linux product that he's been working on for the last year. It is a hardbound-book sized Linux PC. Complete with sound, video, touchpad, SVHS output, docking bay for floppy and cdrom, 2 USB ports. It's called the Nano PC by a local Washington State company called Linux-Works. It was running with a 533MHz Celeron and 128Mb of ram and Caldera's Linux distribution (dual booting with win98).
And its only $799!" This thing has wearable potential no doubt.
Very cool looking, and under a pound. Wow. Good to finally see these things (almost) in the wild.
Not a Wearable (Score:2)
-Vercingetorix
snip from the site (Score:1)
When o when will it be "The computer can be operated with Linux as well as Windows® operating systems."
Under a pound? (Score:1)
Oh! You meant one of those old-fasioned kilogram things? ;-)
Re:Some minor corrections: (Score:1)
Re:Celeron? (Score:1)
Re:PCMCIA IS MISSING (Score:4)
Re:Uhh, I think I'm seeing double.. (Score:1)
--
Re:That's not a Linux box! (Score:1)
Only application I can think of... (Score:1)
Off Topic: All those ACs posting about open source girl friends must have been watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer last night and noticed the "Windows NT Explorer"-like internal interface on the girlfriend-bot.
Back of the envelope for battery life (Score:4)
Their power supply output is 15v DC @ 3A (45W).
Now, Sealed Lead Acid batteries (the best power per volume i have been able to find for my wearable) run about 13 Watt Hours per Pound. Now i figure the average draw of the machine is probably slightly less than half the supply rating, (although we still want to source the peak current when needed i'm more concerned with average when figureing out how long the batteries will last), so to be save we call it 20 W. So we need just under 2Lb of battery per hour of battery life. That's something to think about. Right now if i carry all 8 pounds of my wearable battery bank, i get 12 hours out of it (WITH DISPLAY!), wheras here we're talking 4 hours, not even counting that we'll need another 18w according to SONY's specs, so call that 2 hours with display carrying 8 pounds of battery. That sucks.
Now for plan B. We go for high capacity Li-ion batteries, more expensive, larger, but bettwer power-weight. Okay, now we get 34h/battery, and i can't find the weight spec, but i think they are a little more than a pound, but they cost $114/each so 8 pounds gets us 4 hours or so with these, but that's probably over $1500 in batteries. No good =:-( Doh!
Re:It's portable, not mobile. (Score:1)
So for many people it could replace their laptop. In reality, would someone rather show off to their colleagues a shiny small box or the latest Sony Vaio?
I can see it would be useful for presentations. With a good IR/radio mouse and keyboard, you could actually tape the box to the overhead projecter. Don't people always trip over the PC leads in the dark no matter how carefully you try and tuck them away?
Phillip.
Same price...more portable. (Score:1)
Re:Depends what you do with it... and what OS (Score:2)
>
>I've got a server corner of the room, which means >I'm jealous
Don't be too jelous. My server closet is under my desk. I wish I had a corner
>This is a great idea!, but what a niche.
I think they realized this, which is why the next generation (available in Japan already according to an earlier slashdot article) incorporates a NIC card, and the floppy/DVD drive into the unit. The device is bigger, but I can see where it would be useful.
1) Telecommuter who doesn't need the device while in route (Corporate executive?)
2) Security orginization. This would essentially allow them to have people work at 'real' computers, and then check them in to a desk or lock them up in a safe at night.
3) Sales Presentations/Conference Demos. Just add projector. Why bring a laptop? the integrated pointer is perfect for giving demos, (all you need is a mouse durring a presentation), or add a 'happy hacker' keyboard (as small if not small then a laptops. Heck, with the size of projectors nowadays, you might be able to put the device, keyboard, and projector into the same size as a laptop, but with more flexability (being able to give presentations also, or project onto the nearest whiteboard to do some work).
Granted most of this is still a niche market.
Heck, if I knew someone on a budget, for 800 they get a decent computer in a small space. I know one or two people who would jump on that. Add a flatscreen, keyboard, mouse, and low profile speakers, and this might be nice for anywhere where space is at a premium (Int. Space Station?).
Re:What it needs (Score:1)
Useful Applications (Score:1)
What the... (Score:1)
I have to agree with most people posting on this, it is neat to get something to that size, but what market were they thinking of? It's not a PDA, it's not a notebook, it's not a PC.
Just another expensive item that has no handle on it, so when you loose your grip you have to drop another grand to replace it.
Only problem... (Score:2)
When it was first mentioned (as the Espresso) that was the biggest problem everyone had with it.
It's neat, but not yet portable.
Re:What it needs (Score:1)
...or you could just buy a laptop.
Re:What it needs (Score:2)
Celeron? (Score:1)
This could be vastly improved (Score:1)
Of course, the NanoPC's design is neater, but I wouldn't consider buying it unless it came with Ethernet built-in. It's not even an add-on option! If it came with FireWire built-in also, I would actually buy it right now.
If the NanoPC was improved with these two features built-in, and had a reasonable price, I think it'd be a killer product. One could get away from having big inconvinient boxes that need to be opened up all the time, and instead have a bunch of smaller components that can be hot-plugged into each other, as it's suitable at the moment.
Re:Ask Slashdot: Open Source girlfriends (Score:1)
Linux USB Ethernet (Score:2)
You end up on this site [www.qbik.ch], and the "device overview" and "Networking" links show you this USB Networking frame [www.qbik.ch].
Re:Not a Wearable: not really (Score:1)
Re:Needs... (Score:1)
Josh Sisk
Re:Needs... (Score:1)
Re:Okay, so what do you do with it?vcv cxv cvxcv (Score:1)
Tell that to Ben :) Re:No wearable potential here (Score:1)
I was actually considering the cappuccino because its onboard eth it has now but I may more likely go with a sony picture book.
for those interested in other alternatives [blu.org]
Re:Pretty lousy MP3 player. (Score:1)
- A.P.
--
* CmdrTaco is an idiot.
Availability? (Score:1)
Just like something else... (Score:1)
Re:Sheesh...lighten up a bit! (Score:2)
All that means is that they are charging you full price for both operating systems. :)
Another neat idea (Score:3)
Even better - if you need to work with it, just remove it from the rack, and there's its display, right in front of you.
Am I missing something here? Looks like they offer up to Celeron 766, 6GB hard drive and up to 256MB memory. Hell - doesn't sound too far off from a low-end server, except for all the redundant parts.
Displays? (Score:1)
Almost Useless... (Score:1)
Could possibly be bullshit.... (Score:1)
Also, it the pic there looks EXACTLY like the Espresso [slashdot.org] from a post a week or two ago.
Sure, if it is the real deal it would be cool.... but it looks bogus to me.
Steve
No wearable potential here (Score:4)
Uhh, I think I'm seeing double.. (Score:1)
And what's this wearable potential BS? You have to plug it into the wall, at best it's a good pc to have in a car, but hardly wearable. You could get a nice MicroATX case with one of those motherboard with everything build in and have something about the same size (with the CD/DVD drive attached)
--
Needs... (Score:1)
What's the point of a "portable" PC that you still have to plug into the wall?
Josh Sisk
Re:That's not a Linux box! (Score:2)
_____________
Sheesh...lighten up a bit! (Score:2)
Besides, whether it's a Linux box or not, it still looks like something I'd like to find under my Christmas tree!
It's usefull even if not wearable (Score:1)
And of course the obligitory "Imagine a beowulf cluster of these"
Re:It's great! (Score:1)
First, I wouldn't refer to anyone as well-armed as ESR as a "dork", if I were you B-)
Hey, who sez I don't have weapons of my own? ;) 'Sides, even though I give ESR crap for some of his embarrassing statements, I trust him as a gun owner not to abuse the right. And I wasn't declaring him King of all Linux (Linus still has that role), just head of the dork faction. (See: Obi-wan costume ;)
I wouldn't mind debating the true value of VA Linux sometime, but my original post wasn't making any kind of value judgements on the stock itself -- I was just using that fact to show what's happened to the paper value of a certain zealot that we all know...
Cheers,
No Ethernet (Score:1)
Cool -- but where can I find a tiny gaming box? (Score:1)
This is similar to the HP e-pc [hp.com]. It's not what I'm looking for, though.
I'm big into network games, and I want a small system that I can easily tote to LAN parties or to friends houses. I haven't been able to find anything that fits the bill. Neither the Nano PC or the e-pc will work because of the lack of good 3D graphics, or an AGP slot. (The i810 3D graphics decelerator is laughable.)
What I'm looking for would be in a slightly larger package, and have the following features:
In other words, I want something virtually identical to the Nano PC, except for the addition of an AGP video slot. I know you can't do that with the i810 chipset, but I'd rather have it based on an Athlon anyway.
Has anybody seen such an animal in the wild?
I've also been looking for smaller desktop cases to build my own small system with, but I haven't been able to find any at all. Every desktop case I've found, on the web or in shops, is huge, with lots of drive bays I don't need. They're actually bigger than the mini-tower I use for my gaming system now.
Re:Pretty lousy MP3 player. (Score:2)
Although I have no intention of getting one, I've seen a few expressos at conventions demoing software, and they are neat little boxes.
As for the sound, I read that review as well, and it turned out that the person doing the review had either reinstalled Windows, or otherwise screwed with the sound drivers, and that the sound hardware itself was great - the drivers (not the ones that came with the unit) were what was causing the degradation in quality.
But don't even begin to ask for a URL - I just remember reading the same review and the retraction/ update.
--
Evan
They should have a general overview on the web pag (Score:1)
Re:Do you want to Open Source your girlfriend? (Score:1)
original copyrights. So I really have very
little to do with it.
-CrackElf
It's portable, not mobile. (Score:2)
While it isn't a mobile machine, it is a portable machine.
Think about it. If you're like 90% of the laptop users out there (myself included), you take your laptop to work, where you plug it in to a real keyboard, mouse and monitor, then carry it home, where you plug it in to a real keyboard mouse, and monitor.
So tell me why I'm carrying four pounds of LCD, keyboard and battery, when I all I need to carry is one pound of CPU and HD?
-Z
Re:It's great! (Score:1)
[...] because that will give the people running it a choice to go back to Windows, which is not what I want to happen.
Yes, we all know that Linux zealots like you don't want people to have choice, which is why your ilk ranks around the bottom of the social totem pole.
Oh, and here's something to ponder the next time you're masturbating about Linux: VA Linux's stock dropped another 25 to 30 percent today, so the king dork of Linux, ESR, has now seen the value of his stock officially fall below 1 million dollars. And such a shame, too, after hearing him brag to his worshippers about how cool-n-wealthy he was ($40 million back then, how time flies).
Cheers,
Re:Okay, so what do you do with it? (Score:2)
While I think this is a step in the right direction, the problem is that it is in fact a traditional PC masquerading in a very large PDA's body. The absence of character input, battery power, and display simply makes it a lighter desktop box. And is it me or is the touchscreen input useless when you consider that if you need to carry around a keyboard, monitor, and power plug you had might as well carry a mouse or trackman with you.
I think I'd rather have a nice slim Vaio or Portege running Linux.
Pocket EPC-II (Score:1)
Re:Not a Wearable: not really (Score:2)
As for power usage on this PC, even if it was the same as a regular laptop (which it isn't since it doesn't have the same kind of power management as a laptop), you'd still only get a couple of hours of use out of it. A wearable needs to get a minimum of eight hours of continuous usage.
-Vercingetorix
I am SOO pissed about this. (Score:1)
Im just pissed off about it because I just bought a visor, Now it seems like a poor substitute.
Re:open source (Score:2)
Am I missing something? (Score:1)
...what's the big deal?
My laptop is portable, has a 12.1" TFT screen, runs Linux exclusively, and has been around for quite some time. Nobody seems to think it's a particularly unique device (although many have seen it and commented, "Hey, what version of Windows IS that?").
Oh, by the way: I bought it for $799, brand new.
-William
Re:It's great! (Score:1)
Re:Celeron? (Score:1)
A REAL PC Laptop is nice too, you know (Score:2)
Isn't the average Linux user in need of a little more than basic hardware? The ability to use a ton of RAM, solid PCMCIA, decently big disk... I think you may get more at a pretty reasonable price in a real laptop and end up happier down the line with the power and flexibility.
Just my opinion though.
Re:Okay, so what do you do with it?vcv cxv cvxcv (Score:1)
Re:Not a Wearable: not really (Score:2)
Slightly off with that comment.
It depends what you plug into it. Maybe the full sized HDD might draw more power than a notebook sized HDD. But there's no monitor, which uses most of the power. Otherwise, it is essentialy a moble Intel PC in a small form factor.
Does Linux support ACPI 1.8? Does the kernel power down the HDD, or enter the Intel STPCLK/SLP/DPSLP during the idle process? If not, Win2k/98 can effeciently use power saving features.
I don't see how this is any different than a mobile PC w/o a monitor and (it looks like) a battery connection.
Why would you wear it? Not a jab, but I'm curious. I haven't seen any affordable eyeglass-mount optics (like ocular HUDs, etc...)...
---
Useless without a monitor or keyboard (Score:2)
Come on, guys! Let's see some low-priced tablet computers!
Re:It's portable, not mobile. (Score:1)
Re:It's portable, not mobile. (Score:3)
The trend of late has been for corps to buy/lease laptops for many of their employees for a number of reasons.
1. They can take the machines home with them and do work.
Most individuals never even power their company's laptop on at home unless they need to. And I think you'll find with the possible exception of some techies very few people actually plug their laptop into a seperate keyboard, monitor, and mouse at home. Mouse and keyboard maybe, but monitor, I don't think so.
2. They can take their machine on the road/plane with them and do work.
I definitely don't think this machine can fit the bill for trying to get a proposal or piece of code done on a plane.
3. The laptop gives their employees the ability to move around more, bring them to meetings, collaboration sessions, etc.
I don't know about the rest of the world, but at my company this happens a lot and again this machine just doesn't fit there either.
As for the home market, I don't see this replacing any laptops. Not very many people buy laptops for personal use only and those that do typically put the premium paid in its true portability.
Re:Not a Wearable: not really (Score:1)
You're forgetting that the processor on this thing isn't the same as those that go in laptops. These appear to be regular desktop CPUs so you don't get speedstep or any of that other stuff that helps reduce power usage (of course all of them have that low power while idle mode)....
Re:No wearable potential here (Score:1)
Not only that, but until the system will fit on my belt buckle, I don't want to haul it around. My palmpilot is annoying enough, and this thing is several times the size of my palm device. However, a PDA has a reason to be sizable; You have to write on it. A wearable computing device has no reason (other than logistics) to have any size at all, except for plugging things into it.
--
ALL YOUR KARMA ARE BELONG TO US
Re:Okay, so what do you do with it?vcv cxv cvxcv (Score:1)
Re:Sheesh...lighten up a bit! (Score:1)
Imagine.. (Score:1)
--
Re:Some minor corrections: (Score:2)
well, if you bothered to actually look at the page, you would see that the fastest cpu they sell it with is a PIII 700.
they also list the hard drive as "6gb upgradable to 18gb", but have an option for a 20gb drive on the order page.
--
Re:What it needs (Score:1)
http://www.plycon.com/flex.htm [plycon.com]
Windows 2000 please (Score:1)
I will take mine with Windows 2000, thanks.
Hey that looks like... (Score:1)
Or, at least, it's a machine built inside the same clone-kit.
Here's the SaintSong Espresso [saintsong.com.tw] again.
Check the CD-ROM dock, the holes in the case, etc.
So I'm guessing this is like the PC-Book machine you see around and anyone can buy em, slap in a processor, HDD and RAM, load em up and slap their moniker on em.
The Cappuchino [saintsong.com.tw] is still cooler.
TheBitch
But you can't buy it with BSD. (Score:1)
Why should Linux get all the eyeballs?
Whats the Big Deal?? (Score:1)
They had RedHat installed May 2000. They had many things running, just a little difficulty with the network adapter.
Oh well
Re:It's great! (Score:1)
D'oh! I still refuse to believe it, though, that was just too perfect if it was really a troll. So good, in fact, that I'm sure the people that he was imitating were actually nodding their heads in agreement as they read it, so my post served as a counterpoint for them.
Awww, fuck it, who am I tryin' to kid? I just wanted an excuse to let everyone know about ESR's current paper worth. ;)
Cheers,
Portable perhaps, but 'nano'??? (Score:1)
Pretty lousy MP3 player. (Score:2)
This is far from the ultimate MP3 player. Something built around compactflash cards or IBM's microdrive would be much closer to that goal.
- A.P.
--
* CmdrTaco is an idiot.
Depends what you do with it... and what OS (Score:2)
1) want to set up a linux game server for an impromptu Network game?
2) want a quiet low profile firewall in your server closet (what? you mean everyone doesn't have a server closet?)
3) I know someone who works in security. He lugs around two laptops, so he can test things out. Having one of these with an ethernet interface would be lovely. Just set it up to boot a terminal off of the serial interface. Assign it an IP address, and then telnet into it, and Viola. A much smaller solution to needing to lug around two laptops.
Re:Pretty lousy MP3 player. (Score:2)
Re:What about... (Score:1)
But network is essential. Not USB, not PC-Card. I can't remember when I last used my floppy or CDROM for anything. The network is the computer...hey, that sounds familiar...
Re:It's great! (Score:2)
Since when is ESR the "king dork" of Linux? First, I wouldn't refer to anyone as well-armed as ESR as a "dork", if I were you B-), second I think Linus would have dibs on "king anything" of Linux, third the validity of an idea has no relationship to the stock price of a company seeking to profit from that idea.
Network Associates stock has fallen to about one tenth of its peak value. Does that mean that firewalls, virus scanners, and PGP are only one tenth as good ideas now as they were two or three years ago?
Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | http://www.infamous.net/
Re:This could be vastly improved (Score:1)
Im considering it but possibly intead I may get a sony picture book($1,700 with my 15% discount) instead (firewire included and a monitor and keyboard that could be rarely used when called for and battery life should be a bit better - a con of course is the processor power - size wise it "may be" longer but thinner).
There are pluses and minues to both of these systems.
Course if your are not looking at size being critical and are not going to be toting this thing around all the time by all means buy a normal PC or laptop (perhaps a G4 titanium).
Why does it look like it has pepper sprinkled onit (Score:1)
...or that they hire blind men to mill out the holes for the speakers?
Re:Okay, so what do you do with it? (Score:1)
Re:Availability? (Score:2)
You can customize your pc at: http://www.linux-works.com/cgi-bin/shopper.cgi?ke
Been waiting a long time for this!! (Score:1)
That's not a Linux box! (Score:4)
Re:No Ethernet (Score:1)
Note to Linux-Works marketing department... (Score:3)
I've got to believe that the designer of this sexy little toy intended it to be the "big ugly putty box" killer. That's what the nano-PC should be marketed as: the future of the desktop computer.
And about friggin' time too. Computer cases in general are my pet peeve. Why is it that I can buy a piece of home audio equipment for $200 with the most kickassedly(tm) designed case you've ever seen, but when I spend $2000 on a computer I get some putty-colored moster made out the cheapest, crappiest, ugliest plastic the manufacturer could find? OOH IT HAS A BLINKING GREEN LIGHT I'M SO IMPRESSED. Meanwhile, my crappy $300 car stereo can do this waay-fscked-up laser show that makes it just about impossible for me to see oncoming traffic at night. What is wrong with this picture?!?
Why do you think Apple has been so successful with the iMac? They managed to come up with a case design only slighty less vomit-inducing than your average PC case, and the entire computing world lost its collective mind like a pre-teen staring at a copy of "Plumpers Magazine" for the first time.
I think it goes without saying that the nano-PC is only about 1,000,000 times cooler sitting on your desk than an iMac. Actually, even one of those stupid miniature fridges from thinkgeek is cooler sitting on your desk than an iMac, but that is not my point.
For once you've caught the big desktop manufacturers with their pants down. Your Prime Directive is clear: destroy them all while there is still time.
And while you're at it, would it KILL you guys to put a real video card in the thing?!?
DaC
Battery Life (Score:2)
Old story (Score:1)
Re:No Ethernet (Score:1)
It's the Espresso PC (Score:4)
Re:Depends what you do with it... and what OS (Score:4)
True, this would even make LAN parties a little easier.
2) want a quiet low profile firewall in your server closet (what? you mean everyone doesn't have a server closet?)
I've got a server corner of the room, which means I'm jealous
3) I know someone who works in security. He lugs around two laptops, so he can test things out. Having one of these with an ethernet interface would be lovely. Just set it up to boot a terminal off of the serial interface. Assign it an IP address, and then telnet into it, and Viola. A much smaller solution to needing to lug around two laptops.
This is a great idea!, but what a niche.
I think the biggest problem I see is that it just doesn't have broad enough appeal.
Some minor corrections: (Score:2)
-600-800Mhz Pentium® Celeron or Pentium® III Processor
-64MB Ram upgradeable to 256MB
And now for the part that made me spit my coffee over the monitor: Based on the all new Intel® i810 series chipset.
Now I've got nothing against Intel, but the 810 just doesn't cut it like it should. Does anyone have a clue what they mean by 3D Accelerator Integrated Graphics Chipset? AFAIK an S3 Virge fits that description as well, so...
What it needs (Score:2)
Hrm. Needs a good portable keyboard, too... what's the smallest keyboard available these days?
Re:Battery Life (Score:4)
Wow ! Deja Vu ! (Score:2)
Re:It's the Espresso PC (Score:2)
Welcome to Slashdot, the department of redundencey department.
--