A Review of the Top Four External Hard Drives 180
Lucas123 writes "There's a really good, detailed review at the Computerworld site on the top four external hard drives with more than 500GB of capacity. The story reveals some big flaws in the external drives, like malfunctioning one-touch backup buttons, USB 2.0 ports that don't recognize the drives, and drives coming out of the boxes unformatted. It's also an eye opener with regard to actual backup speeds. 'Broadband connections, peer-to-peer networks and larger media files coupled with new regulations that require diligence in backing up files have clearly affected the external hard drive market as drive capacities expand to 1TB and beyond. Meanwhile, the prices of those drives continue to drop, making them ever more attractive, particularly with the ease of deployment -- literally a two-minute installation, and you're ready to go. We put four of the leading external hard drives to the test. Our criteria were simple: The drives had to have multiple connection technologies (USB 2.0 plus FireWire 400 or FireWire 800 or both), include backup software and have a capacity of at least 500GB.'"
TFA: one page, less advertising (Score:5, Informative)
What the shit is this? (Score:2, Informative)
I get my 500gb hard drives from new egg. Was $179 last year, down to $159 now. Maxtor Onetouch 3. Reasonably quiet (can't hear it move than a few feet away), comes preformatted. Doesn't spin down after like 5m of inactivity. Only issue is that it has an huge, annoying blinking light even when idle. I cover that with a beer can.
Re:Why not just do it yourself? (Score:1, Informative)
As for the one-touch button, I don't see much of a need for it personally. Besides, what does it do? It just launches the sync software -- my actual worry (software must already be installed for it to work in the first place). Just give me good sync'ing software and I'll be happy (I'll just schedule it or start it manually) -- preferably freeware/open source. Buying a drive already in an enclosure doesn't do one any good here. There just isn't a whole lot of sync'ing software that "just works" (I'm using SyncBack SE personally).
Re:Why wasn't the LaCie rated higher? (Score:5, Informative)
Regarding the inoperable button, which is their main complaint about the drive, I'm surprised that they didn't contact Lacie support and report back... it's conceivable that it is a know issue or a bum unit. Then again, I'm rarely impressed by the reporting at Computerworld.
Western Digital Passport? My Book "Essential"? (Score:5, Informative)
TFA reviews the My Book Pro, but they also have a USB-only My Book "Essential" (read: Cheaper!) version; anyone tried those?
____________________________________
Dejobaan Games, LLC - Because we love developing games.
Indie Superstar - Because we love webcasting about indie games.
No G-tech ? (Score:1, Informative)
Valid reasons for not preformatting. (Score:5, Informative)
Apple's Disk Utility offers six options to format a disk into: Mac OS Extended (HFS+), Mac OS Extended (HFS+) Journaled, Mac OS Extended (HFS+) Case-Sensitive, Mac OS Extended (HFS+) Case-Sensitive Journaled, MS-DOS File System (FAT32), UNIX File System (EXT2?).
I guess I would assume that a "high end" HW manufacturer like Lacie would pre-format the drives to Mac OS Extended Journaled, because that's what Apple recommends as a default these days, but particularly if it's a product that's being aimed at non-clueless users, they might have just decided it wasn't worth it.
Re:Why wasn't the LaCie rated higher? (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Why not just do it yourself? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Western Digital Passport? My Book "Essential"? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Cheaper than $135? (Score:4, Informative)
So, if you managed to get a deal buying it for $20 less than the already low price at Newegg then good for you, but don't pretend that that's the common going rate for external hard drives.
Re: WD Passports and Mac laptops (Score:3, Informative)
I sold my Powerbook G4 15" a while back though, and now use a Macbook Pro, which works with the WD Passport without problems.
Re:Why not just do it yourself? (Score:4, Informative)
Not the best, but Explore2FS [chrysocome.net] is pretty nice.
Of course, writing a Windows File System is a black art. If MS documented it better, maybe there'd be more third party file systems.
You might want to look at this [fs-driver.org] as well -- disclaimer, I haven't tried it, don't know how good it is.
LaCie support = good (Score:2, Informative)
Also, from experience, these are tough buggers. My Big Disk Extreme needed to have it's interface card replaced. The connection died on the PC, then the Mac. Had some private stuff on there, and they SAY that repair service will wipe the drive, but y'know... So, without cracking the case I gave it a go-over with a full-bore pistol-grip demagnetizer, the kind that plugs in AC, vibrates, and shouldn't run for more than 30 minutes. The drive came back in a week with a new interface card, and all my data perfectly in tact. Perfectly. Which in itself was disconcerting.
My only complaint is that despite having three interfaces, you can't have all three connected to different computers at the same time. That's just too much to ask for I guess. Time for a standalone 4-drive bay, methinks.
Beware of connected storage devices... (Score:5, Informative)
Also, even if you've verified the data is good on your storage device, moving it to another machine and connecting it up may leave you unhappy if the storage interface on the new machine isn't working properly.
You have been warned.
Two plugs, too... (Score:3, Informative)
Of course you then have to figure out still if both ports aren't just on the same controller, etc. (or even if it is a powered port - though rare these days for them not to b) but typically any USB powered port is going to have its own rated 2.5W at disposal. Won't do any good if you stick them both in a USB hub, of course.
You mean... (Score:2, Informative)
Rule #1: Never pass up a pun (or should I say, "Rule number pun?").
*ducks*
Re:Beware of connected storage devices... (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Why wasn't the LaCie rated higher? (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Why wasn't the LaCie rated higher? (Score:4, Informative)
While FAT32 does have the advantage that just about anything can read/write to it, the 4GB file size limitation (which dates back to Seattle Computer Products' QDOS original FAT implementation) really limits its usefulness for large drives. SOP for me is to re-format FAT drives with the most appropriate file system: UFS for Solaris (fun part was figuring out that I needed to use svcadm to kill vold) or NTFS for Windows XP.
I wasn't impressed by the review either.