Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Power User Journal

Is Daylight Saving Shift Really Worth It? 652

Krishna Dagli writes "Two Ph.D. students at the University of California at Berkeley say that Daylight Saving Shift will not do any good or create any energy savings. We are already spending money for software upgrades in the name of saving energy and after reading following article I wonder has congress really studied the impact of DST shift? " I also read some back story on the concept; OTOH, I found TiVo's suggestions that I manually change everything on my Series 1 device to be somewhat...insulting.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Is Daylight Saving Shift Really Worth It?

Comments Filter:
  • I'd go for double daylight savings if I could.

    Why don't you just ask your boss if you can work 6-3 :)
  • by kaleco ( 801384 ) <greig@marshall2.btinternet@com> on Monday March 12, 2007 @08:42AM (#18314839)
    Quick, someone add the tags please.
  • ... that two college students think they're smarter than a bunch of politicians?
  • by MyNameIsEarl ( 917015 ) <`assf2000' `at' `yahoo.com'> on Monday March 12, 2007 @08:56AM (#18314999)
    A fart is a good enough excuse for big oil to justify an increase in gasoline prices.
  • by cooley ( 261024 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @09:06AM (#18315109) Homepage
    Is DST WORTH IT? Boy, Let me tell you a story about the place I come from.

    I live in Indiana (a midwestern US state). Up until last year, we'd never done DST before at all (with a few exceptions in towns whose economies were linked to cities across the border in other, DST-observing states).

    Before we had DST, it was HELL. All year, it got dark at like 2:00pm. There was no Little League Baseball, no football (american or otherwise) for the kids. Most of our youth joined gangs, who roamed the incessant darkness in large, heavily fortified bad-mpg SUVs, kicking puppies and beating up old ladies just for fun. There was no Christmas and no birthdays, and if we saw the Easter bunny we ATE HIM.

    Though many people had the misconception that we were "America's Breadbasket", in fact the darkness prevented us from raising any sort of sustenance crops and most of us resorted to cannibalism to survive. Most Hoosiers (that's what we're called, it means "land of eternal darkness" in a Native American tongue) eventually starved to death, which was viewed as a welcome respite from the hellish, unstoppable night. Dogs and cats, living together, you get the picture.

    Then, we elected a new Governor who brought us into the light (literally). With the introduction of DST, and the seemingly random (almost whimsical, really) distribution of our Counties between two time zones, our lives were changed forever. Now, it's light outside pretty much twenty-four-fucking-seven. Our kids are all on at least six sports teams and never shoot each other anymore. They call you "sir" or "ma'am" (these words were not used before, as it was difficult to discern gender in the darkness), shine your shoes for you, and present you with ice-cold lemonade from stands with amusingly misspelled signs. We discovered oil everywhere, we grow more crops than the world could ever possibly use (which has ended hunger globally) and we're all filthy, stinking RICH. All the women have big perky boobs, all the men are RIPPED, and everybody has an IQ of at least 160.

    Yes Sir, I don't know what we'd do if it weren't for good ol' DST. I have to assume that with the new DST-extending rule from our good friends in the US Congress, we'll probably just evolve to a higher state of being and shed these silly, out-dated husks to become super-intelligent beings composed of pure energy.
  • by voice_of_all_reason ( 926702 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @09:16AM (#18315221)
    Why don't we just set the clocks back 9 hours? Since Daylight Savings Time adds an hour of light, doing this will make it daytime all twenty-four hours. It's a win-win scenario!
  • by Legion303 ( 97901 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @09:27AM (#18315365) Homepage
    I'm not sure what point you're trying to make. My three-year-old son is smarter than a bunch of politicians.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday March 12, 2007 @09:48AM (#18315643)
    Right! We don't need no daylight saving in our mother's basements!
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday March 12, 2007 @10:12AM (#18316005)
    I too am from Indiana, and I can vouch for everything the poster states. Myself was actually an hour late to work this morning because I was way to busy saving daylight and admiring my new ripped abs. Kudos.
  • by Sponge Bath ( 413667 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @10:38AM (#18316375)
    It looks like someone has a case of the 'Mondays'.
  • by mstahl ( 701501 ) <marrrrrk@@@gmail...com> on Monday March 12, 2007 @10:41AM (#18316405) Homepage Journal

    I don't really think anyone believes that setting clocks a certain way impacts the amount of time the sun spends in the sky daily...

    You'd be surprised. . . .

  • by Not Crafty Enough ( 1074647 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @10:58AM (#18316621)
    Dude, I'm so glad you brought this story to light. I've been telling my friends this story for years, and they look at me like I'm crazy. Truth be told, they look at me like that no matter WHAT I'm talking about, but even more so when I get started on "The Indiana Thing." I drove, naively, into Indiana in 1983, searching for the woman in the L'eggs (panty hose) advertisement in my Mom's Redbook magazine. I was operating under the mistaken premise that Indiana was - rather than the breadbasket of America - the "Pantyhose and Nylons Capital of the World, due to an unfortunate misspelling of "hoosiers" in the budget encyclopedia set that my Mom purchased from someone at her office. Driving around vainly searching for the L'eggs headquarters, the headlights in my '73 Chrysler Newport burned out halfway through my second day there, and I couldn't find my way back to the border. With a horde of cannibals closing in around my car (which only went about 10 miles between fillups - of gas, oil, or coolant) I thought the end was near. Quick thinking saved my life that day, and my penchant for popcorn. I ducked into the back seat and quickly fashioned a mask out of a box of Orville Redenbacher popcorn, and the cannibals began to bow and chant all around the Newport. You didn't TELL your readers that Orville Redenbacher was a God to the denizens of once-dark Indiana, friend. Did you forget? Not likely. Were you, perhaps, brainwashed into secrecy? Possibly. Or, more sinister still, are you STILL a member of Redenbacher's scattered army of darkness? Just waiting for a new Governor to come in and repeal the DST proclamation?? State your motives, Sir!
  • by Phisbut ( 761268 ) on Monday March 12, 2007 @12:35PM (#18317835)

    The thing to fix is, getting rid of the DST change completely

    Or at the very least, the acronym DST should change. Since the so-called "standard" time lasts from the first Sunday of November to the second Sunday of March which is 19 weeks, and the "daylight saving time" lasts the remaining 34 weeks, the one which lasts longer (summer time) should be called "standard time", while the winter time, opposite of DST, should really be called "daylight wasting time".

    Really, if we're so save daylight, why not save it all year long? Otherwise, we're just wasting it.

  • by SCHecklerX ( 229973 ) <greg@gksnetworks.com> on Monday March 12, 2007 @12:46PM (#18318021) Homepage
    And more golf courses means less trees and more global warming too!

For God's sake, stop researching for a while and begin to think!

Working...