iBot Self-Balancing Mobility Device FDA Approved 274
ptorrone writes "In November of 2002, I was able to see the self-balancing iBot mobility device, which can go up and down stairs and travel/balance on two wheels, in person. It literally brought tears to my eyes seeing what it will mean for millions of disabled people around the world. Today, the FDA has approved its use, after years of approval processes and testing." We've mentioned this Dean Kamen-created product previously, but it's good to see it officially approved and available for those who need it.
FDA + Wheelchair (Score:3, Interesting)
FDA? (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:FDA + Wheelchair (Score:3, Interesting)
Compare this to the Segway (Score:4, Interesting)
The whole approval thing makes it possible to get part of the (very costly) wheelchair price covered by medical insurances and the like, as I've understood things correctly anyway.
Re:FDA? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:FDA approval (Score:4, Interesting)
The thing people usually misunderstand about drug approval is that the results of the clinical tests are open to scrutiny. If the drugs are not effective, the FDA can (and does) not approve them.
Having said that, pharmaceutical companies spend way too much money on "lobbying" doctors. The usual budget rundown is: 1/3 R&D, 1/3 infrastructure, 1/3 Marketing and sales. Of the 1/3 R&D, 1/3 goes to research, which makes the pharmaceutical industry the industry that spends the most in research.
Re:Hefty price tag (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:FDA + Wheelchair (Score:1, Interesting)
A wheelchair is not food.
A wheelchair is not a drug.
Why does it fall under the FDA's remit to test it then, rather than the federal Wheelchair agency or whatever?
Comment removed (Score:5, Interesting)
Perhaps this is off topic but (Score:5, Interesting)
This is a great invention by a great guy, and I genuinely hope it goes to people who really need and deserve it. Teachers may not be aware of the difference they make in a kids life; I hope these kids realize what a difference they've made to their teacher's life. It's amazing.
Re:FYI on FDA (Score:4, Interesting)
I think your mistrust is unfounded. I admit I don't know how the FDA is operated, who has direct/indirect oversight, etc., but why worry about the FDA (which has an incredible record) while there are plenty of other agencies that have numerous and ongoing cases of blatant corruption and abuses?
Re:FDA approval (Score:3, Interesting)
The reason I know anything about this at all is that the guy who taught me statistics was a specialist in the area of clinical trials. He was also brilliant, and I guess you have to be to be able to navigate your way around such a difficult area.
Re:And here I am (Score:3, Interesting)
Since you are in a position to have an opinion, what do you think of the physical fitness aspects of this?
The most excerise many of us geeks get is walking to and from the car and possibly up the stairs. I see a number of wheelchair-bound people that, judging by their upper body development, get more of a workout moving themselves around than the rest of us.
Obviously the price of this thing is going to prevent very wide use for some time, but if it's successful I can imagine that it has the potential to almost completely take over the powered wheelchair market. If it does, the price point will come down, possibly bringing it down far enough to be a sane purchase for people who otherwise would not get a powered chair.
Is there a potential problem there regarding physical fitness? Even the minimal walking that most people do elevates heart rates enough to maintain some basic (albeit pathetic) fitness levels. Are people who would otherwise be using their upper body to provide locomotive power going to now have to do little more than wiggle their wrist for nearly every sort of movement?
It seems like most powered wheelchairs would not be worth the price for the limited mobility they provide for otherwise healthy people, but this one does stairs, and can raise the user to eye level with up-right folks. Seems that people who haven't really needed a powered chair before might decide they need this one.
In a nutshell, I'm curious if use of a powered chair has more severe physical fitness impact even than a typical persons sedentary lifestyle, and if this will effect people who would otherwise get excersize from daily locomotion.
Re:FDA + Wheelchair (Score:5, Interesting)
Actually, the FDA regulates all manners of medical devices; there's an entire branch of the org which deals with them, the Center for Devices and Radiological Health. That means everything from syringes to x-ray machines to wheelchairs.
I work as a webmaster over there (All Opinions Expressed Are Mine And Have Nothing To Do With My Employer) and got to post the happy news of this thing to the CDRH website (http://www.fda.gov/cdrh) today. Whee! ...please don't slashdot our database server, we're a little understaffed today...
Re:Any videos? (Score:2, Interesting)
Can't believe this isn't moderated higher - that's a really great 2 part video of it.
Re:Videos of it in use (Score:3, Interesting)
hmm speaking of humvees, what would happen if you got an ordinary good quality remote control aeroplane, stripped out all the servos and put two servos on an iBot's joystick and one servo on the trigger of a M249 Squad Automatic Weapon mounted securely to the seat? Add a wireless video camera to the picitinny rail on the top of the machine gun, and maybe a bulletproof riotshield bolted to the front and you have the utimate solution for those pesky barricaded hostage situations in tight urban areas.
Wait, urban areas, poor radio reception... maybe make it cable controlled? Or maybe put a laptop and a thermal camera in the seat and let it make its own decisions. you get the picture.
And the insurance companies don't pay that price (Score:3, Interesting)
It's a way around cost controls - the providers know that insurance will only pay a portion of the costs so they jack up the fees.
The down side is if you don't have insurance and you get billed the "insurance" price. My aunt recently needed treatments that were not covered by her insurance company and was able to negotiate the discounted prices from the providers ahead of time. If she had not asked, she would have been paying much more than the fair market value for the rendered services.